Maple Leafs Face A Costly Dilemma In Pursuit Of Simon Edvinsson

While the Toronto Maple Leafs eye a trade for promising defenseman Simon Edvinsson, the team must carefully weigh the high cost and strategic maneuvers required to bolster their roster with his youthful talent.

The Maple Leafs are still working the phones, and Simon Edvinsson keeps surfacing as one of the names tied to Toronto.

Under first-year GM Johb Chayka, the Leafs have stayed active on the trade front, and the Edvinsson chatter makes sense on paper. He would bring something Toronto does not really have on the blue line right now: youth. He would also be the youngest defenceman on the roster by a wide margin, and very likely the best one too.

That kind of player is not cheap.

Edvinsson is a 23-year-old defenceman with top-four upside, and he is just getting into his prime. He is also 6-foot-6 and can play on both sides of the puck.

For the Red Wings, that makes him a valuable piece. For the Maple Leafs, it means the price to pry him loose would be steep.

One possible framework would have Toronto sending Easton Cowan as the centerpiece, along with the 2027 first-round pick the Leafs received from the Colorado Avalanche in the Nicolas Roy deal.

There are other ways to build the package, but they still come with real pain. Another idea would center on Oliver Ekman-Larsson, the 2027 first-round pick, and either Tinus Luc Koblar or Ben Danford.

If Toronto had its way, Cowan would stay put. He has played well this season, and Ben Danford also looks like someone the Leafs would want to keep in the future core. That would make Koblar the likeliest prospect to move if Toronto had to choose one.

The Leafs would also need to send a current roster defender with a meaningful cap hit. That is where Ekman-Larsson comes in. Even with the strong play he has shown over the last two seasons, he looks like the most realistic candidate to be included.

And that would not be enough on its own. Toronto would likely have to add more future value, which is where the 2027 first-round pick fits in. The 2028 second-round pick could also be part of the sweetener.

Any deal would not stop at the trade itself. Chayka and the Leafs would also need to lock Edvinsson into an extension.

Reports have said he turned down a contract with an AAV of $8.5 million and is looking for something in the $10 million range. On a max-term deal, that would land around $70 million.

For now, it is still unclear whether Toronto and Detroit are actually talking. But reports circulating online say the Maple Leafs are among the teams making inquiries.

In Other News...

Maple Leafs May Have Found A Real Mitch Marner Successor

The Maple Leafs have spent plenty of time looking for the right fit beside Auston Matthews, and Jack Roslovic has at least given them a compelling answer early in the season. Slotted onto Torontos top line with Matthews and Kirill Marchenko, Roslovic has looked comfortable in an elevated role and has brought the kind of pace and finishing touch that can change the feel of a line in a hurry.

Through 17 games, Roslovic has already piled up eight goals and 10 assists, putting him on track for a career-best offensive season. The next wrinkle is how Toronto handles the line when Marchenko is ready to return from a lower-body injury, because the Leafs now have to figure out whether this alignment is a short-term spark or something worth keeping intact. [Read more 🡒]

Maple Leafs Rookie Faces A New Test As Tavares Nears Return

Gavin McKennas role has shifted again as the Maple Leafs start to get healthier, with the rookie no longer working on the top power-play group and settling into a prominent spot on the second unit. It is the kind of adjustment that comes with playing on a contender, where one lineup change can ripple through the special teams setup and force a young player to keep finding ways to stay useful.

Jim Hiller has pointed to McKennas growth, especially away from the puck, as a reason the coaching staff still trusts him in an important spot. The timing matters because John Tavares is nearing a return, and the Leafs are preparing for a familiar kind of squeeze that comes when a veteran center is ready to rejoin the mix and everyone else has to adapt around him. [Read more 🡒]

Maple Leafs Just Got More Frustrating News On Kirill Marchenko

Kirill Marchenkos return is still not close enough to help the Maple Leafs in the immediate future, even as the club keeps inching toward better health elsewhere. After getting hurt on Oct. 26, Marchenko had sounded optimistic about a two-week timeline, but the latest update suggests the recovery has moved more slowly than hoped, leaving Toronto to wait longer for a player it could use back in the mix.

The timing is especially frustrating because the Leafs are finally starting to see the rest of the roster trend in the right direction, with John Tavares expected back soon. For a team trying to stabilize its lineup and build some continuity, Marchenkos delayed progress is another reminder that the injury picture still has a few loose ends. [Read more 🡒]