The Maple Leafs have a cap problem on their hands before the 2026-27 season even gets rolling, and Gavin McKenna has only made the math messier.
Toronto is already $2.75 million over the projected cap after a busy offseason, which means some kind of move has to come soon. A trade could do it.
Waivers could do it. Either way, the roster has to be trimmed down before the regular season starts.
Then there’s McKenna.
His current cap hit sits at just $1.075 million, but the bonus structure attached to his deal can balloon into a much bigger issue down the line. Toronto has put $3.5 million in bonuses on the table, and while the club does not have to pay that money immediately, it could still wind up counting against the cap later if McKenna hits the right marks.
The setup is pretty straightforward on paper. McKenna can trigger four “A” level bonuses, each worth $250,000, by reaching milestones like 20 goals, 35 assists, 60 points, a top-six finish in ice time among Toronto forwards, a top-three finish in plus/minus among forwards, 0.73 points per game, an End-of Season All Rookie Team nod, an All Star Selection or All Star MVP. Hit four of those and Toronto is on the hook for $1 million.
The bigger swing comes from the “B” level bonuses, which are worth $2.5 million and would be paid if McKenna reaches one of these 2026-27 benchmarks: top ten in NHL forward goals, assists, points or points per game, winning the Hart, Selke, Richard, Conn Smythe or Norris, or landing on the 1st or 2nd team All-Star.
One important wrinkle: the Calder Trophy does not count toward those bonuses. So if McKenna wins that award without checking off any other “B” level requirement, Toronto would only owe the $1 million tied to the “A” bonuses.
If McKenna earns bonuses the Maple Leafs can’t absorb under this season’s cap, the unpaid amount gets pushed onto 2027-28 as an overage charge. Toronto is already locked in beyond this season and doesn’t have major free-agent worries, but that doesn’t make the situation any easier. It just means they have less room to maneuver.
That’s why the opening-night roster decisions matter so much. Every dollar saved now gives the Maple Leafs a little more breathing room later, especially with a logjam up front. The club has to get cap compliant immediately, but it also has to think ahead in case McKenna turns that rookie deal into something much more expensive.
And when the team starts sorting through who stays and who goes, the contracts of players like Dakota Joshua or Max Domi could become part of the discussion. If they aren’t producing, keeping those deals around only tightens the squeeze now and down the line.
For Toronto and John Chayka, the task is clear: get under the cap now, and leave enough space to cover McKenna if he breaks out the way the bonus structure says he can.
In Other News...
Maple Leafs Still Have One Big Blue Line Worry Before Camp
Torontos offseason overhaul touched nearly every corner of the roster, but the blue line remains the area worth watching as camp approaches. The Maple Leafs brought in Darren Raddysh in a sign-and-trade deal to help stabilize the defense, part of a wider reset that also included a new general manager, a new coaching staff and several personnel changes around the club.
Chris Tanev is still the question mark hanging over that plan. After dealing with multiple injuries last season, the defenseman is waiting on medical clearance before he can join team activities, and his availability for the start of training camp is still uncertain. For a group trying to reset its identity on the back end, the Leafs can only do so much planning until they know whether one of their most important veteran defenders will be ready on time. [Read more 🡒]
Matthew Knies Could Spark Torontos Biggest Lineup Debate
Matthew Knies has given the Leafs a legitimate reason to reconsider how they arrange their forward group. His most productive stretches have come alongside Auston Matthews, and the underlying numbers have backed up what the eye test suggests, with a stronger goals-for rate there than in combinations with William Nylander or John Tavares. For a team always trying to balance its top-end talent, that kind of fit matters, especially when Knies brings a mix of physical play and a growing ability to make plays rather than simply finish them.
The real debate is whether his game is best served in the top six or as the driver of a deeper line where he can tilt the ice in a different way. Knies showed more of that playmaking side when Matthews was injured, which only adds another wrinkle to the discussion about where he belongs once the lineup is fully healthy. Jim Hiller will ultimately decide how aggressive he wants to be with the forward combinations, and the answer could shape one of Toronto's most important depth questions. [Read more 🡒]
Chris Tanev's Camp Status Suddenly Feels Huge For Toronto's Blue Line
With the Maple Leafs still sorting through the finer points of their blue line, Chris Tanevs status has quietly become one of the more important storylines heading toward training camp. Toronto brought him in for the kind of steady, defensive work that can stabilize a group, and now the focus is simply on getting him cleared and ready to go. Around the league, a flurry of restricted free-agent talk has only added to the sense that this stretch of the calendar can turn on one players availability faster than anyone expects.
Tanev is aiming to open camp fully healthy, but he is still waiting on medical clearance, which leaves Toronto in a familiar holding pattern with the season approaching. For a defense corps that could use every bit of reliability it can get, his timeline matters just as much as any contract chatter elsewhere. The Leafs do not need drama on the back end right now, but they do need answers, and this is one situation that could shape the early days of camp in a meaningful way. [Read more 🡒]