The NHL offseason always comes with a fresh coat of optimism, but not every player enters a new season with the same cushion. For a handful of teams, the margin for error is thin, and the pressure lands squarely on the shoulders of a few key names.
Bowen Byram, Auston Matthews, Leo Carlsson, Simon Nemec and Luke Hughes are the players who stand out most. Some are trying to justify massive contracts.
Others are trying to prove they can carry bigger roles. All of them can shape how their teams are viewed by the time the season is over.
For the Blackhawks, Byram is a major piece of the puzzle. Chicago has enough talent on paper to push for the playoffs, and Byram arrived in the blockbuster of the summer before landing an extension that will pay him $12.5 million per season beginning in 2027-28.
He has already shown what he can do as a strong skater with offensive value in a No. 3/4 role. The question now is whether he can handle more.
His defensive numbers may take a hit in a bigger assignment, but if he can lift a rough power play and help turn around one of the league’s weakest blue lines in points, that would be a huge step for both him and the Blackhawks.
Matthews is in a very different spot, but the pressure is just as real. The last two seasons have not gone the way Toronto expected.
In 2023-24, he put up 69 goals and 107 points, but he has only 60 goals across his last 127 games. Injuries have been part of the story, and the Maple Leafs have slid from Cup contender to “in transition.”
Mitch Marner was the one who moved on, yet the speculation around Matthews has not gone away. Another down year as he approaches 30 would only intensify that chatter.
Toronto needs a rebound, and a return to 50 goals is the standard for “Papi” if the Leafs want to get out of this transitionary phase sooner rather than later.
Carlsson became one of the summer’s biggest stories after a wild offer sheet saga left him as the NHL’s highest paid player, at least until Macklin Celebrini’s extension kicks in for 2027-28. He already backed up the hype with career highs across the board: 29 goals, 38 assists and 67 points, while logging more than 19 minutes a night.
Still, the new $18 million AAV brings a different kind of scrutiny. He is close to superstardom, but now the expectations are huge.
Unless he is in the mix for the Art Ross and Hart Trophy, people are going to talk. Even so, another jump - 30-plus goals and 80-plus points - would quiet plenty of that noise.
Nemec’s situation is different again. Taken second overall in 2022, he was supposed to be a franchise defenseman.
He did take a clear step forward as a 21-year-old in 2025-26, but he was still far from reaching that level when the Devils decided to trade him to Calgary rather than pay for more promise as he approached restricted free agency. The Flames gave him a five-year, $36.25 million deal, and now the expectation is straightforward: he has to become a top-pairing defenseman.
His offensive game is high-end, but he needs to clean up more in his own end if he is going to justify that contract.
Hughes is carrying his own kind of pressure in New Jersey. The fourth overall pick in 2021 and one of the Hughes Brothers, he had shown offensive promise before taking a step back in a bigger role in 2025-26.
There were even rumors of a benching before injury ended his season. His seven-year, $63 million contract only makes the scrutiny sharper; he is tied for 13th in cap hit among defensemen in 2026-27 with a $9 million AAV, and he has not looked like the top-pair player that deal was built around.
If he does not make progress in both zones, the Devils could be staring at a contract that becomes very hard to move.
There is a common thread running through all five cases: each player has either already been a star or has flashed star-level upside. Matthews has been there.
Carlsson is trying to get there. Byram, Nemec and Hughes are trying to prove they can handle more responsibility.
And while Calgary remains in the middle of a rebuild, the other four teams are looking toward the playoffs. If any of these players falls short, the discomfort will be felt quickly in those front offices.
In Other News...
Maple Leafs May Have Found A Defense Fit They Rarely Get Cheap
The Maple Leafs added another piece to their blue line pipeline in the 2026 NHL Draft, taking right-shot defenseman Mans Gudmundsson with the 76th overall pick. For a team that has long searched for affordable, homegrown help on defense, the selection checked a few boxes at once: size, puck-moving ability and a physical edge that can be hard to find once the price tag starts climbing.
Gudmundsson is not just a flyer on a later pick, either. Toronto appears to see him as part of a longer-term succession plan for its defense corps, with room for him to keep developing in North America. Whether he becomes the kind of steady, cost-controlled fit the organization is hoping for will depend on how quickly he adapts, but the Leafs clearly think there is more there than a depth add. [Read more 🡒]
Leafs Still Have One Unsettled Goalie Question Before Camp
The Maple Leafs head into camp with their goaltending chart already taking shape around Anthony Stolarz and Sergei Bobrovsky, but it is not hard to see why the room still feels unfinished. Stolarz brings injury concerns into the conversation, while Bobrovskys age makes depth behind them more than a luxury, especially for a team that knows how quickly a crease plan can get complicated over a long season.
One possible answer is a familiar kind of training-camp insurance, with Toronto weighing a veteran option who has NHL experience and just spent time in the KHL. It would not change the outlook at the top of the depth chart, but it would give the Leafs another layer of protection if the kind of goalie trouble that tends to arrive unexpectedly starts to show up again. [Read more 🡒]
John Tavares Maple Leafs Signing Is Back In The Spotlight
John Tavares was back in the spotlight in a very different setting this week, appearing in Tax Court of Canada to challenge a Canada Revenue Agency demand tied to the signing bonus he received when he joined the Maple Leafs in 2018. The dispute centers on how that money should be treated for tax purposes, with the CRA arguing it belonged in the same bucket as regular salary while Tavares and his lawyer say his residency status at the time changes the calculation.
For Toronto, the case is another reminder of how much attention followed the captains arrival and how long the aftershocks from that decision can linger. The court has not ruled yet, leaving one more off-ice storyline hanging over a player whose move to the Maple Leafs already reshaped the franchise and still draws scrutiny years later. [Read more 🡒]