Leafs May Be Drifting Toward A Reset Fans Never Wanted

John Chayka faces a pivotal decision that could redefine the Maple Leafs' future, as the possibility of trading their star players looms large amid ongoing struggles and contract uncertainties.

Toronto’s latest collapse has pushed the franchise to a place it has spent years trying to avoid: the point where moving a superstar no longer sounds crazy, but necessary.

The Leafs have spent a decade cycling through summer fixes - new forwards, new defensemen, new goaltending - and the result has stayed painfully familiar: another second-round ceiling. This time, the damage is worse.

Toronto is spiraling, and it does not control its own first-round picks in 2027 or 2028. It does own Colorado’s 2027 first, but with the Avalanche among the league’s elite, that selection is expected to land in the high 20s.

The front-office trail explains how the club got here. Lou Lamoriello built the base by drafting Auston Matthews first overall, signing John Tavares and trading for Frederik Andersen, a move that cost a first and a second. He also left behind the Patrick Marleau contract that was later dumped at the price of another first-round pick.

Kyle Dubas kept the core intact and kept spending futures, dealing seven first-round picks along the way. That included a first for 11 games of Nick Foligno and a package of four picks for a few months of Ryan O’Reilly. The results never changed.

Brad Treliving doubled down and lost the hand. In March 2025, he sent a first and Fraser Minten to Boston for Brandon Carlo, then moved a 2027 first to Philadelphia for Scott Laughton.

That summer, Mitch Marner left for Vegas in exchange for depth centre Nicolas Roy. A year later, Toronto finished 28th and Treliving was out.

John Chayka inherited the wreckage, and then got a gift. Forty-eight hours into the job, he won the draft lottery and selected Gavin McKenna first overall. He also turned Matthew Knies into Kirill Marchenko and signed him for six years.

That’s the backdrop for the uncomfortable question now hanging over the Leafs: is it time to move Auston Matthews?

Matthews’ contract runs through 2027-28, and his full no-move clause gives him control over where he goes. With Toronto off to such a brutal start, it would not be a shock if a trade request surfaced before the March deadline.

The same logic applies to William Nylander, who has six years left at $11.5 million and a full no-move clause. He has 11 goals and 22 points in 21 games, but his 5-on-5 numbers have slipped.

Chris Johnston and Nick Kypreos have both reported the Leafs are willing to listen.

If Toronto goes down that road, the point is not to move them just to move them. The point is to get the right return and build around McKenna’s window instead of the old one.

For Matthews, the most obvious destinations include San Jose, Anaheim and Los Angeles. San Jose has Macklin Celebrini and one of the league’s deepest prospect pools, while all three California teams could appeal because of the no-move clause. Toronto’s ask would need to be substantial: an NHL-ready prospect, ideally a blue-chip right-shot defenseman; two first-round picks, likely in 2027 and 2028; and, if salary comes back the other way, a second-rounder or another mid-tier prospect.

Nylander’s market could be broader. Chicago makes sense because Connor Bedard needs a winger who can tilt the ice, and the Blackhawks have the picks and right-shot defense prospects Toronto would want. Seattle and Utah could also be in the mix as teams looking for a front-line scorer to accelerate their climb.

Two division opponents also belong in the conversation. Boston is already set to receive one of Toronto’s next two firsts, which could make the Leafs’ own pick part of a deal.

Ottawa is another possibility. The Senators traded Brady Tkachuk to Florida this summer for three first-round picks and a second, leaving them with both a hole on the wing and plenty of draft capital.

Sitting sixth overall, they have reason to think a playoff push is realistic, and Nylander would fill the void while giving the fan base something to absorb after the Tkachuk move. Because he would have to waive, his list matters as much as Toronto’s.

The ask there would be an NHL-ready prospect and a first.

There is also the timing issue. Matthews and Nylander are both around 30, with maybe three or four prime years left.

Wait another season and the return drops. Together, they carry $24.75 million in cap hits, which makes moving both at once difficult for most teams.

Splitting them into separate deals could create two bidding wars instead of one.

If Toronto did pull it off, the haul could reshape the organization: two young defensemen and three first-round picks added to a core built around McKenna, Marchenko, Easton Cowan and Ben Danford, with Alexander Bilecki among the prospects on the way.

For a franchise that spent years trading the future for the present, the next move may be the opposite.

In Other News...

Maple Leafs Just Got A Front Office Warning They Couldnt Ignore

The mood around the Maple Leafs has only grown heavier after a 6-3 loss to the Chicago Blackhawks, and the response from above came quickly. MLSE CEO Keith Pelley went into the locker room afterward to address the teams poor performance, a sign that the organizations patience is being tested as Toronto continues to linger near the bottom of the division.

Pelley reportedly spoke with some key personnel in the room, though the club has not confirmed exactly who was involved. No firings or trades have followed, but the visit itself sent a clear message: the Leafs are being watched closely, and the front office is no longer treating this slide like something that can be brushed aside. [Read more 🡒]

Maple Leafs Face One Big Trade Question On Defense

The Maple Leafs are still looking for ways to sharpen the roster, and the blue line is where the conversation keeps circling back. Brandt Clarke of the Kings has surfaced as a possible target, which makes sense for a Toronto team that could use more offense from its defense and more long-term upside on the back end.

The catch is simple: a player like Clarke is not the kind of add a team lands cheaply. Any serious pursuit would likely mean parting with meaningful assets, whether that is prospects, current players or draft capital, and that is where the real debate begins. Morgan Rielly has even been floated as a possible trade piece in the discussion, but for now it remains exactly that, a discussion, with no confirmed move on the horizon. [Read more 🡒]

Leafs Just Made A Telling Change With Gavin McKenna

Gavin McKennas role with the Maple Leafs is already changing in a meaningful way. After carving out a spot on the third line, he has been bumped up to the second line and placed back on the top power-play unit, a clear sign the coaching staff wants to lean harder into what he has brought through his first 23 games.

The move comes with McKenna sitting among the NHL rookie leaders in goals and assists, production that has made it hard to keep him buried in a lower-profile role. For Toronto, the adjustment is about more than reward - it is a push to give him more ice time, more offensive touches and a bigger chance to keep driving the attack. [Read more 🡒]