Mario Ferraro was Toronto’s target, but the Maple Leafs couldn’t get the one thing they needed done in time: move Morgan Rielly.
That’s the reporting from NHL insider David Pagnotta, who said on the Leafs Morning Take podcast that Ferraro’s camp wasn’t interested in waiting around while Toronto worked through the rest of its business.
“But the message was we have to move Rielly before we can sign you,” said Pagnotta in the Leafs Morning Take podcast. “And clearly they were not willing to wait, and he got the next option in Winnipeg. And I think it would have come in around three or four years and somewhere in the 4 to 5 million range with Toronto.”
Ferraro ended up taking a three-year, $12 million deal with the Winnipeg Jets, carrying a $4 million AAV. Toronto, meanwhile, was still boxed in by the cap and would have needed another move to make the numbers work.
That’s the heart of the issue here. The Leafs wanted to add a defenseman, but they were not in position to do it cleanly without first clearing space. Rielly’s $7.5 million cap hit was the obvious lever, and Ferraro’s camp wasn’t prepared to sit and wait while Toronto figured out its roster.
For Ferraro, the choice was pretty straightforward. He’s from Toronto, so the hometown angle was there, but Winnipeg’s offer was in the same neighborhood and came with certainty. In a market that was thin for defensemen, that mattered.
Ferraro is 28 next season and still in his prime years. He spent his early career on some rough San Jose Sharks teams, often with very little help around him on the blue line.
He hasn’t been a major power-play piece, but he can chip in offensively and remains dependable defensively. At 5-foot-11 and 200 pounds, he doesn’t bring much height, but he’s not an easy guy to move around either.
The fit in Winnipeg is clear enough. Ferraro projects on the left side of the third pair, and he’ll be playing in front of Connor Hellebuyck. That kind of environment could help his numbers, especially with the burden of top-four minutes no longer on his shoulders.
For Toronto, the takeaway is just as clear. If the Maple Leafs want to keep adding on defense, they probably have to subtract first, and Rielly is the most movable piece.
His play has dipped, he’s older, and his cap hit is significant. Unless he rebounds in a big way, he looks like the first name to watch, whether that happens this offseason or later if the Leafs go looking for help at the deadline.
John Chayka has already been aggressive in building out the roster and carving out space, but that room has shrunk quickly after an active first day of free agency. The left side of the defense has long been a strength, and if Toronto does make another move on that side, it appears Rielly is the one most likely to go.
In the end, this was a case of a player choosing the guarantee over the wait. Ferraro didn’t stick around for Toronto to sort out its cap puzzle, and the Jets got him before the Leafs could clear the path.
In Other News...
Maple Leafs Finally Addressed The Matthew Knies Trade Rumors
Matthew Knies has been the kind of name that naturally draws trade chatter when the Maple Leafs are looking for ways to reshape the roster, but Torontos front office has now made clear how it views the young forward. Assistant general manager Ryan Hardy addressed the rumors and framed Knies as more than just a useful piece, pointing to his versatility and the way he fits the kind of lineup Toronto wants to ice when the games get tighter.
Hardy also stressed that Knies is the sort of player who can move around the lineup, including alongside Auston Matthews, and still handle different situations without losing his value. Coming off a full season in which he played 79 games and heading into the second year of a six-year contract, Knies looks like the type of player the Maple Leafs would rather build around than entertain offers for, even if the speculation around him has not gone away. [Read more 🡒]
These Maple Leafs Signings Suddenly Feel Like Part Of Something Bigger
The Maple Leafs free agency work has started to look less like a series of isolated depth bets and more like a deliberate push toward a heavier, more dependable bottom six. Colton Sissons, Teddy Blueger and Nick Paul all fit the same broad idea: players who can handle defensive minutes, bring size, and give Toronto more options when the lineup gets tight over a long season.
What makes the signings interesting is the uncertainty around how they all fit together. There is a sense that management has a larger roster blueprint in mind, and maybe even a move or two still to come, but the exact shape of that plan is not yet clear. For now, the Leafs have added a cluster of similar players and left the bigger question hanging: how many of them can actually be in the lineup at once, and in what roles? [Read more 🡒]