Jim Hiller’s decision-making came under the microscope again after the Toronto Maple Leafs’ 4-3 shootout loss to the Los Angeles Kings, and the biggest flashpoint was Gavin McKenna’s quiet night in overtime.
Toronto had erased a 3-0 deficit before the game slipped away, leaving the Leafs with a chance to salvage two points in the extra frame. Instead, McKenna barely factored, even though overtime is exactly the kind of open ice where his skill should matter most.
McKenna is still an 18-year-old with clear limitations. Earlier in the game, he showed the kind of issues that come with being a smaller player trying to survive in the NHL: he struggles to create his own space and can get pushed around when the physicality ramps up. But when the ice opens up, he’s one of the most dangerous players on the roster.
That’s why Hiller’s explanation for keeping him on the bench in overtime drew so much attention. Speaking to SDPN’s Jesse Blake, Hiller said, “He’s watched.
We’ve had him up. And then called him off.
He’ll get out there eventually. But it’s obviously a high leverage time.
And you need somebody who can make a play. And again I just want to make sure he’s ready.”
The problem with that reasoning is obvious: making a play is what McKenna does best. In 3-on-3 overtime, with space everywhere, he should be one of the first names Hiller leans on.
Instead, the minutes went to the usual core. Auston Matthews skated with Jack Roslovic, while John Tavares, William Nylander, and Easton Cowan handled the rest of the forward shifts.
It wasn’t just overtime, either. McKenna was also removed from the top power-play unit during the game, another sign that Hiller isn’t putting him in the spots where he can do the most damage.
For a player whose best trait is pure skill, that approach stands out. Hiller seems to be treating McKenna like a grinder who needs to be eased in, but the source of his value is much simpler than that: give him room, and he can make something happen.
In Other News...
Maple Leafs Just Got A Front Office Warning They Couldnt Ignore
The mood around the Maple Leafs has only grown heavier after a 6-3 loss to the Chicago Blackhawks, and the response from above came quickly. MLSE CEO Keith Pelley went into the locker room afterward to address the teams poor performance, a sign that the organizations patience is being tested as Toronto continues to linger near the bottom of the division.
Pelley reportedly spoke with some key personnel in the room, though the club has not confirmed exactly who was involved. No firings or trades have followed, but the visit itself sent a clear message: the Leafs are being watched closely, and the front office is no longer treating this slide like something that can be brushed aside. [Read more 🡒]
Maple Leafs Face One Big Trade Question On Defense
The Maple Leafs are still looking for ways to sharpen the roster, and the blue line is where the conversation keeps circling back. Brandt Clarke of the Kings has surfaced as a possible target, which makes sense for a Toronto team that could use more offense from its defense and more long-term upside on the back end.
The catch is simple: a player like Clarke is not the kind of add a team lands cheaply. Any serious pursuit would likely mean parting with meaningful assets, whether that is prospects, current players or draft capital, and that is where the real debate begins. Morgan Rielly has even been floated as a possible trade piece in the discussion, but for now it remains exactly that, a discussion, with no confirmed move on the horizon. [Read more 🡒]
Leafs Just Made A Telling Change With Gavin McKenna
Gavin McKennas role with the Maple Leafs is already changing in a meaningful way. After carving out a spot on the third line, he has been bumped up to the second line and placed back on the top power-play unit, a clear sign the coaching staff wants to lean harder into what he has brought through his first 23 games.
The move comes with McKenna sitting among the NHL rookie leaders in goals and assists, production that has made it hard to keep him buried in a lower-profile role. For Toronto, the adjustment is about more than reward - it is a push to give him more ice time, more offensive touches and a bigger chance to keep driving the attack. [Read more 🡒]
