Jim Hiller didn’t wait long to make a point with William Nylander.
After Nylander’s defensive lapse against the New York Islanders on Wednesday, the Maple Leafs winger found himself on the wrong end of an early-season message from his coach. He didn’t log much ice afterward, and he was left out of the team’s 6-on-5 against the Ottawa Senators because Hiller didn’t want to take a chance on another mistake.
The sequence that set it off came when Nylander tried to recover on a 2-on-1 but never really got to Emil Heineman in time. Heineman blew past him and scored, ending the shutout and creating a moment that could have turned uglier after Heineman collided with Anthony Stolarz. The play was preventable if Nylander had gotten back faster.
“You can tell that once Nylander got into his zone, he let up just a little bit, as Heineman got a couple extra steps ahead of the forward and scored shorthanded.”
It wasn’t the kind of breakdown that defines a player’s night on its own, but it was enough for Hiller to react. That’s the message: the margin for error is small, and the bench is waiting if the effort slips.
The Leafs are off to a 1-2-0 start, but there have been some encouraging signs. Kirill Marchenko and Auston Matthews have shown chemistry, Easton Cowan has been off to a fantastic start, and the defensive group has looked much more succinct.
Still, the second line of Gavin McKenna, John Tavares, and Nylander has been a problem. By the source’s account, it has been the worst line on the team by far, giving up too many chances without generating enough of its own. Nylander’s turnover and the goal that followed only added to that frustration.
Nylander has shown some improvement in his own end this season. He has battled back, used his stick well, and contributed defensively in stretches. But the inconsistency is still there, and the giveaways keep stacking up.
He’s not a liability every shift. The issue is the effort level that comes and goes.
That was a familiar complaint last year under Craig Berube, who pushed Nylander to bring more in every area. At times, Nylander seemed to do things his own way.
The frustration is that he can look engaged one moment and then ease off the next. Compared with Auston Matthews or John Tavares, who keep fighting for pucks in their own zone even when they lose the battle, Nylander can seem to assume the breakout is coming. Hockey doesn’t always give you that luxury.
This probably won’t turn into a nightly issue for Nylander. But Hiller has already made it clear that if it does happen again, the response will be simple: sit down and think about it.
In Other News...
Nick Robertson Is Reopening A Maple Leafs Debate Fans Hated
Nick Robertson is doing exactly what tends to complicate a clean breakup: he is making his new team look smart for taking the chance. After the Maple Leafs sent him to Pittsburgh, the winger immediately found some comfort with the Penguins and started producing right away, the kind of early impact that naturally sends Toronto back to the same old questions about what he might have been able to become here.
From the Leafs side, the explanation for moving on was practical enough, centered on salary considerations and roster fit. Still, when a player who once felt like a puzzle piece in waiting starts clicking somewhere else, it reopens the debate fans never fully loved in the first place, and leaves Toronto wondering whether the picture would have looked different with a longer runway. [Read more 🡒]
Maple Leafs Win Couldn't Hide A Problem Before This Road Trip
The Maple Leafs left their four-game homestand with a 5-4 overtime win over Nashville, but the mood around the result was hardly pure celebration. Toronto got the two points it wanted, and the underlying numbers still lean in a positive direction, yet the game also offered a familiar reminder that the margin for error on this team can disappear fast when the defensive structure slips.
Brandon Duhaime, Jake McCabe, Chris Tanev and Oliver Ekman-Larsson were all part of the breakdowns that helped Nashville find openings, and those kinds of mistakes are hard to ignore with a demanding road stretch ahead. A win can cover up a lot for a night, but for the Leafs, the next phase of the schedule will say more about whether the defensive issues were a one-game mess or something more persistent. [Read more 🡒]
Maple Leafs May Be Overlooking The Edge This Lineup Still Needs
The Maple Leafs brought in Zack MacEwen over the offseason as a depth addition with a clear purpose in mind: add some size, edge and energy to the bottom of the lineup. After a brief stint with New Jersey last season, MacEwen arrived on a two-year deal and has so far been used sparingly, with Toronto treating him as the kind of forward who can give a game a different texture even without heavy minutes.
MacEwen has only dressed once this season, and the usage suggests the Leafs are still deciding how much room there really is for that brand of player. Toronto already has enough skill to survive most nights, but the question hanging over this roster is whether it is leaving itself a little light on the kind of toughness that can matter when the games tighten up later on. [Read more 🡒]