The All-MLB picture is coming into focus as the regular season winds down, and the starting pitchers may be the cleanest part of the board.
Jacob Misiorowski is the easiest call of the bunch. The Brewers right-hander has separated himself from the field with a 1.75 ERA, 210 strikeouts, a 13.6 K/9, a 0.75 WHIP and a 6.8 K/BB ratio.
Cristopher Sánchez, Dylan Cease and Cam Schlittler have also locked themselves into the first team unless something goes sideways late, and all three sit above the rest of the pack in fWAR alongside Misiorowski. Chase Burns gets the final first-team spot for now, even though the second-team group could make its own argument for that place.
The second-team starters would still be plenty strong: Jesús Luzardo, Chris Sale, Yoshinobu Yamamoto, Drew Rasmussen and Tarik Skubal. Burns just gets the edge because his season has been too strong to ignore.
The bullpen race is more straightforward. Mason Miller belongs on the first team after putting up a 0.88 ERA and a ridiculous 16.3 K/9 over 51 1/3 innings, along with 30 saves.
Louis Varland joins him after emerging as one of the few bright spots in a rough Blue Jays season; his 1.26 ERA is third-best among relievers, and only Miller has a higher fWAR than Varland’s 2.6. Bryan Baker and Jhoan Duran land on the second team.
Behind the plate, Dillon Dingler has built a real case as the American League MVP, even if he’s still a long shot to actually win it. He’s seventh in MLB with a 5.2 fWAR and has put together 26 home runs, 82 RBIs and an .818 OPS while playing elite defense. Gabriel Moreno has also put together a strong year, posting a position-best .855 OPS and a 135 wRC+.
At first base, Matt Olson headlines the first team after hitting 36 home runs with 77 RBIs and leading all first basemen with a 4.1 fWAR. The second-team race is tighter, but William Contreras gets the nod thanks to a 155 wRC+, the best mark at the position. Injuries have also dinged the cases for Nick Kurtz and Munetaka Murakami, who would have had a better shot if they had stayed healthy.
Brice Turang has been one of the best second basemen in the game, leading qualified players at the position in fWAR (4.2) and wRC+ (123). He’s added 16 home runs, 75 RBIs and strong defense, with 10 outs above average that rank third among second basemen.
J.J. Wetherholt makes the second team with a quieter bat but elite glove work; his 105 wRC+ is above average, and his 22 outs above average trail only Bobby Witt Jr. and Pete Crow-Armstrong across MLB.
Junior Caminero is the class of the third-base group offensively and earns a first-team spot on the strength of 35 home runs, 79 RBIs, a .537 slugging percentage and a 146 wRC+. Miguel Vargas takes second-team honors after a breakout season that has brought 28 home runs, an .831 OPS, and a tie for second in wRC+ at the position, plus third in slugging.
Witt remains the sport’s top defensive shortstop, with 23 outs above average and 17 runs prevented. He’s also on pace for a 20/40 season and has produced a 127 wRC+ and .460 slugging percentage, while his 6.0 fWAR ranks third in MLB.
McGonigle gets the second-team shortstop spot after splitting time between shortstop and third base as a rookie. He leads all shortstops with a .385 on-base percentage, sits second at the position with a 4.7 fWAR, and trails only CJ Abrams with a 131 wRC+.
In the outfield, Pete Crow-Armstrong is a first-team lock and a legitimate challenger to Shohei Ohtani for the National League MVP. His 8.4 fWAR is double that of any other outfielder in MLB.
James Wood joins him after leading MLB with 100 runs and pairing that with 30 home runs, 73 RBIs and a 155 wRC+. Ceddanne Rafaela rounds out the first team thanks to his defense and a solid all-around season that includes 16 home runs, 64 RBIs and 16 stolen bases.
The second-team outfield includes Corbin Carroll, Randy Arozarena and Wilyer Abreu.
And then there’s Ohtani. He could win his third straight NL MVP, but he still doesn’t fit neatly onto the All-MLB first team because his value gets split between batting and hitting.
That opens the door for Yordan Alvarez, who has been the sport’s best hitter and could win the Triple Crown. Alvarez leads MLB with a .318 batting average, ranks second with 37 home runs and sits fourth with 88 RBIs.
Ohtani has been excellent, but the way his responsibilities are divided likely keeps him off the first team in either role.
In Other News...
Blue Jays May Have Landed A Future Bat Fans Will Obsess Over
The Blue Jays are already chasing a postseason spot in 2024, but they also appear to be making a major bet on what their lineup could look like years from now. Toronto has reportedly reached a verbal agreement to sign 15-year-old Dominican third baseman ngel Monts for a $5.5 million bonus, a deal that would not become official until January 2028, but one that signals just how highly the organization views the young infielder.
Monts is being billed as a prospect with real athletic ability and impact with the bat, the kind of profile that can create a lot of buzz long before he takes a professional swing in the system. For a Blue Jays team trying to win now, it is another reminder that the front office is keeping one eye on the future, and this one could eventually become the sort of prospect fans start tracking well before he arrives in Toronto. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Suddenly Face A Gimnez Concern They Cant Ignore
Andrs Gimnez left Torontos game against the Rays in the fourth inning because of right hamstring tightness, a sudden exit that forced the Blue Jays to reshuffle their infield on the fly. Brandon Valenzuela took his spot in the lineup, and the defensive alignment changed several times after Gimnez headed for the clubhouse, underscoring how important he has been to the club on that side of the ball this season.
For a team that leans on Gimnezs glove and stability, any hamstring issue is the kind of development that gets attention quickly. He has not previously been placed on the injured list for a hamstring injury, so the Blue Jays will be watching closely to see whether this is a short-term interruption or something that could linger and affect an already thin infield mix. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Keep Facing The Same Jess Snchez Problem Late In Games
Jess Snchez keeps forcing the Blue Jays into the same uncomfortable trade-off. His bat has been valuable enough that Toronto keeps writing his name into the lineup, but his glove has become a recurring issue, and it surfaced again in the loss to Tampa Bay when a fly ball got away from him and helped tilt the game toward the Rays. For a club trying to squeeze every run it can out of tight games, that kind of defensive blemish is hard to ignore even when the offensive upside is real.
The Blue Jays have mostly lived with the arrangement because Snchez has been one of their most productive hitters. He brings enough punch that the team is willing to accept the risk early and then look for a cleaner defensive option later, which has become a familiar late-game move. The tension for Toronto is obvious: keep him in there to benefit from the bat, or start planning around the possibility that one misplay can turn a close night into a costly one. [Read more 🡒]