When the Toronto Blue Jays decided to bring back Max Scherzer, the three-time Cy Young award winner, this offseason, fans were thrilled. Scherzer had been a key player in their successful run last year, but there was an elephant in the room: his thumb injury. This nagging issue had nearly derailed the Blue Jays' 2025 season, keeping him sidelined for much of the first half and leading to some shaky performances upon his return.
But Blue Jays fans can breathe a sigh of relief. Scherzer has tackled his thumb troubles in a rather unconventional way-by becoming a musician.
Yes, you read that right. The 42-year-old pitcher found healing at the piano.
In a conversation with Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic, Scherzer shared how tickling the ivories helped him overcome his thumb pain. “When you’re playing different keys and notes and chords, your hands are in very unique positions.
It makes you really work through your fingertips,” Scherzer explained. “By working those muscles in my hand, it got my fingers quote-unquote stronger.
All of a sudden, that alleviated the thumb pain.”
Scherzer started playing the piano around the All-Star Break last season, initially to teach his kids. As he fiddled with the keys, he noticed an improvement in his thumb, and soon, the piano became his go-to remedy. The results were evident as he delivered vintage performances in the playoffs, seemingly turning back the clock.
This musical therapy hasn't just revitalized Scherzer's career; it's also made him a crucial part of the Blue Jays' rotation this season. With injuries sidelining Shane Bieber, Trey Yesavage, and José Berríos, Scherzer's presence is more vital than ever. What was initially a depth insurance move now looks like the offseason's most significant signing for Toronto.
With Scherzer healthy and ready to go, he could be the linchpin in the Blue Jays' quest for a World Series return. That journey kicks off Tuesday when Scherzer takes the mound against the Colorado Rockies.