Louis Varland’s 2026 season ended the way a closer dreams about it: with the ball in his hand, the game on the line, and a strikeout to slam the door.
His final pitch of the year was a 100 mph fastball that found the upper third of the strike zone and beat Sal Stewart for strike three, setting off the usual roar from the Rogers Centre crowd. That was outing No. 71 for Varland, and save No. 35, sealing the Blue Jays’ 6-5 win over the Cincinnati Reds on Sept. 25.
The finish only underscored how far Varland had come over the course of the season. He wrapped up with a 3.1 fWAR, second among qualified relievers across Major League Baseball, and led that group with a 1.27 ERA. Only San Diego Padres closer Mason Miller finished ahead of him in fWAR, posting 3.7.
More than the numbers, Varland became the most trustworthy arm in the Blue Jays bullpen and, along with starter Dylan Cease, one of the team’s most important pitchers.
That wasn’t the expectation when the season began. Varland wasn’t supposed to be Toronto’s closer, and Jeff Hoffman opened the year in that role. But Hoffman’s uneven work in save situations left the door open, and Varland forced his way through it.
Beginning April 21, he put together a run of 41 straight relief appearances without blowing a save chance. Over that stretch from April 21 through Aug. 5, Varland went 3-3, picked up 24 saves and two holds, logged a 1.39 ERA, struck out 55 hitters and gave up only one home run in 180 batters faced.
Across the full season, he was charged with just two blown saves. Baseball Savant’s Statcast Player Comparison Tool had him leading the field in average percentile rankings across all 16 of its metrics.
Varland’s breakthrough earned him a spot on Sporting News’ 2026 American League All-Star team as one of the relievers, with the announcement coming Thursday. The honors are voted on by players, coaches and executives.
He’s now the first Blue Jays closer recognized since the reliever category was introduced in 2013, and the first Toronto pitcher honored since Roy Halladay in 2003. Before Varland, the Blue Jays had only seen Dave Stieb (1982), Jimmy Key (1987), Pat Hentgen (1996) and Roger Clemens (1997 and 1998) make the team.
In Other News...
Blue Jays Face A Costly Choice Before Free Agency Changes
With the current collective bargaining agreement set to expire and the possibility of a lockout and salary cap looming, the Blue Jays are being pushed into a familiar front-office dilemma: move early, or wait and risk a more restrictive market. The best available names on the free-agent board all come with a price, but they also represent the kind of talent Toronto does not often get a chance to chase, especially if the rules change after the next labor deal.
Tarik Skubal sits at the top of that conversation as a frontline arm with a projected cost that already looks steep, while Jazz Chisholm Jr. brings a different kind of appeal as a dynamic fit who could land in a more manageable range depending on how the Yankees handle his status. Randy Arozarena is also in the mix as another potential impact bat, giving the Blue Jays a short list that will test how aggressive they want to be before the market shifts underneath them. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Prospects Are Giving Fans Early Reasons To Pay Attention
The Blue Jays sent eight prospects to the Mesa Solar Sox for the Arizona Fall League, using the assignment to speed up development in a setting that can serve a lot of different purposes at once. For some, it is about getting innings or at-bats in a controlled environment. For others, it is about returning from injury, adjusting to a new position or sharpening specific parts of their game before the offseason really kicks in.
Among the group, pitcher Jake Bloss has already given Toronto something to track, showing the kind of stuff that can make AFL innings matter. Position players Aaron Parker and Jake Casey are in the mix too, with Parker getting work in left field and Casey easing back in after a hamate injury, even if the early numbers have been quieter. The whole point is development, but for a fan base always looking for the next wave, early flashes like these are enough to keep one eye on the desert. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Get An October Look At Three Intriguing Pitching Options
With the World Series still providing a live scouting stage, the Blue Jays are getting a close look at three free-agent pitchers who could fit into their offseason plans. The group is varied enough to be interesting: one has been a steady postseason force for Tampa Bay, another has long offered the kind of front-end stuff teams dream on, and a third has worked out of the bullpen while already getting a taste of October.
For Toronto, the appeal is in the range of possibilities as much as the names themselves. The Jays need ways to deepen and upgrade their staff, and this trio gives them different paths to do it, from impact starting upside to bullpen reinforcement. What happens in the rest of the Series may not decide their market, but it should give them another reminder that the next wave of help could be on display right now. [Read more 🡒]