The Toronto Blue Jays are staring at a strange kind of pressure in 2026: one year after reaching the World Series and coming within a couple of outs of a championship, they’re fighting just to stay in the playoff picture. That reality has put John Schneider in an uncomfortable spot.
Toronto sits at 65-70, below .500 and on the outside looking in for the postseason. The American League has opened the door enough that the Blue Jays still have a path, but it’s a tight one. They’re 3.5 games behind the third and final Wild Card spot, which is currently held by the 68-66 Cleveland Guardians.
The rest of the chase is crowded, too. The Texas Rangers are 2.0 games back, the Baltimore Orioles are 3.0 games back, and the Seattle Mariners and Minnesota Twins are both 4.0 games back. In a weak AL overall, that leaves Toronto with a chance - but not much margin for error.
That’s why Sports Illustrated’s Karl Rasmussen sees Schneider as someone who could be on the hot seat.
“Would Toronto really move on from Schneider just a year after he led them to a World Series appearance, and came an inning away from winning a championship?” Rasmussen writes. “Considering the Blue Jays' struggles this season, it's not out of the question.”
Schneider has been in charge for five seasons, and the track record is solid: a .529 winning percentage, three postseason trips, and one World Series appearance. He also has the benefit of a strong 2025 season behind him, when Toronto went 94-68 and made that deep October run.
That matters because the 2024 season was rough, with the Blue Jays finishing 74-88. But the combination of the 2025 breakout and the near-title run would normally give a manager some cushion.
If Toronto can claw its way into the postseason this year, Schneider’s job would likely be safe. If the Blue Jays miss out, though, the conversation changes fast.
Even so, moving on from a manager just one year after a World Series appearance would be a stunning call. Rasmussen says it’s possible, and if it happened, it would be a brutal ending for a team that was half an inning from a title.
In Other News...
Blue Jays May Be About To Lose A Former Top Prospect
The Blue Jays made a notable roster shuffle by bringing back right-hander CJ Van Eyk and designating Simeon Woods Richardson for assignment, a move that speaks to how quickly the margin for young pitchers can shrink. Woods Richardson has been fighting through a rough stretch, and Torontos decision to make room points to a club still searching for stability on the pitching staff while trying to see what it has in Van Eyk.
Woods Richardson now goes on waivers, and because he is out of minor league options, any team that claims him would have to keep him on a major league roster. If he clears, he would have the choice to elect free agency, leaving the Blue Jays with a former top prospect at a crossroads and a bullpen/rotation depth picture that could change again before long. [Read more 🡒]
Bo Bichette Just Reopened A Blue Jays What-If Fans Will Feel
Bo Bichettes move to the Mets already carried enough for Blue Jays fans to sort through, but his recent comments added another layer to the departure. In talking about the leadership role he has taken on in New York, Bichette said he has been working closely with rookies A.J. Ewing and Carson Benge, a reminder of how much his own path in Toronto asked him to figure things out on the fly.
Bichette also looked back on the early part of his career and the absence of a mentor, while crediting Marcus Semien for the example he set during their time together. For Blue Jays fans, it nudges open the old what-if: how different might Bichettes Toronto years have felt with more guidance around him, and what might the organization have seen if the relationship had been built to last? [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Suddenly Need Anthony Santander Back More Than Ever
Anthony Santanders recovery has quietly become one of the Blue Jays most important storylines, even with the season already deep into its second half. The outfielder has been out all year after surgery to repair a labral tear in his left shoulder, and for a team with playoff ambitions, every update on his status has carried a little more weight than the last. Manager John Schneider said Santander is making progress, has been taking swings off a machine in Dunedin and is aiming to get to live pitching soon.
For Toronto, the appeal is obvious: Santander was brought in to be a difference-maker, and he has played only 54 games since signing his five-year deal. The Blue Jays have had to move forward without him for months, but the possibility of getting him back before the end of 2026 changes the conversation around their stretch run. Even without a firm timetable, the fact that he is nearing the next phase of rehab gives the club a reason to keep one eye on the standings and another on Dunedin. [Read more 🡒]