The playoff field has thinned, and with it the list of former Blue Jays still chasing a World Series ring. A bigger group had hopes alive not long ago, but after the Division Series, only five ex-Toronto players remain in the hunt.
They’re spread across two teams: the Los Angeles Dodgers and the Tampa Bay Rays, with the Cleveland Guardians waiting on the other side of the bracket. Steven Matz, Brock Stewart, Teoscar Hernández, Bryan Baker and Foster Griffin are still standing.
Matz is back in the postseason picture after a winding stretch away from Toronto. He was part of the Blue Jays’ 2021 push, when he posted a career-high 2.7 fWAR and made 29 starts.
After leaving in free agency the next year, he spent time with the St. Louis Cardinals and Boston Red Sox before landing a two-year deal with Tampa Bay this offseason.
He made the Rays’ playoff roster, though he wasn’t used in the ALDS against the New York Yankees. Tampa Bay moved on in three games, leaning on Cam Booser, Ian Seymour and Bryan Baker out of the bullpen.
Now Matz should get his 2026 MLB playoff debut when the Rays open the best-of-seven ALCS against the Guardians.
Baker has a far different Blue Jays memory, but his postseason path is just as alive. He debuted for Toronto on Sept. 5, 2021, throwing one inning with one strikeout and one hit allowed.
That was his only work in a Blue Jays uniform before he went on waivers and landed with Baltimore. Since then, he’s pieced together five seasons with the Orioles and Rays, and this year he was excellent for Tampa Bay.
He worked 65 games, put up a 1.44 ERA and 3.07 FIP, and led the league with 41 saves and 63 strikeouts in 62.1 innings. He also made history in the ALDS against the Yankees.
Griffin’s Toronto stint was even shorter. He threw two innings for the Blue Jays in 2022, striking out two while allowing one walk and one hit without giving up a run.
He then spent the next few seasons in Japan before returning to MLB this year. Griffin signed with the Washington Nationals to begin the season, then the Guardians acquired him.
In nine starts for Cleveland, he went 3-3 with a 5.19 ERA and 4.95 FIP.
That sets up an ALCS matchup that will put the two former Blue Jays on opposite sides. The Rays host the Guardians when the series opens Monday (Oct. 12) at Tropicana Field.
On the other side of the bracket, Stewart and Hernández are still rolling with the Dodgers. Stewart had a brief 10-game run with Toronto in 2019 after the Blue Jays claimed him off waivers from Los Angeles on July 31, then released him on outright waivers at the end of that season.
He made it back to the Dodgers, missed their 2025 World Series run because of season-ending shoulder surgery in September, and returned healthy this year. The 35-year-old right-hander appeared in two NLDS games against the Atlanta Braves, throwing 1.1 scoreless, hitless innings with one strikeout.
He’s long been tough on right-handed hitters, holding them to a .224 average and an OPS close to .700, and that could matter even more against Milwaukee, with Jackson Chourio and William Contreras among the bats Los Angeles may need to quiet.
Hernández’s name will sting for some Blue Jays fans, but he’s still alive for what would be his third straight World Series title with the Dodgers. He struggled in the NLDS, hitting .188 with a .563 OPS in 16 at-bats, but there’s plenty of runway left in the NLCS against the Brewers for a hitter known for big moments to change the story.
In Other News...
Blue Jays Face A Tough Bullpen Choice This Offseason
Torontos bullpen was one of the more interesting parts of its 2026 season, with Louis Varland and Tyler Rogers giving the club steady innings while the front office cycled through several arms along the way. The Blue Jays also saw a few pitchers move off the roster entirely, whether through designation for assignment or the start of free agency, leaving this relief group looking a lot different now than it did a few months ago.
Patrick Corbin and Paul Sewald are among the names now in that uncertain middle ground as Toronto weighs whether to keep leaning on familiar veteran depth or turn over more of the relief corps. The decisions feel especially tricky because both pitchers bring some level of track record the club can point to, but the Blue Jays still have to decide how much of that matters when building a bullpen for next season. [Read more 🡒]
Vladdys Next Step Could Decide How Real This Blue Jays Rebound Is
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. took a notable offseason step with laser eye surgery, a move that naturally invites a fresh round of curiosity about what it might mean for the Blue Jays at the plate. A 2025 Society of American Baseball Research study looked at the broader effect of LASIK on major league hitters and found a positive trend, though not one that showed up as statistically significant, with most players not quite getting back to the level they had been two years before surgery.
For Toronto, the more interesting question is whether Guerreros recent struggles were ever going to be solved by vision alone. The full picture around his dip has included other possible contributors, from a bad back to anxiety and depression, and the details of his procedure and pre-surgery eyesight have not been disclosed. So even as the surgery adds a compelling new layer to his reset, it remains only one part of a much bigger rebound storyline for a player whose next step could tell a lot about how real this Blue Jays push really is. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Face A Tough Bieber Decision This Offseason
Shane Bieber gave the Blue Jays a late-season reminder of why he remains such a complicated offseason case. After dealing with health setbacks and limited innings over the past three seasons, he settled in enough down the stretch of 2023 to leave Toronto with a meaningful sample to consider, and that matters because his next stop could come on the open market shortly after the World Series.
Bieber has said he would like to return, and the Blue Jays appear at least open to exploring it, especially if the price reflects the risk that comes with his recent track record. General manager Ross Atkins said the club will work through its process before deciding, which leaves Toronto in the familiar spot of weighing upside against uncertainty as it tries to sort out whether Bieber fits as a reunion candidate this winter. [Read more 🡒]