With MLB free agency set to open in just days, the Toronto Blue Jays are staring at a winter that could shape the lineup in a hurry. They need pop in the outfield.
They need help for the rotation. And according to former Blue Jay Kevin Pillar, they also need to move quickly on a hitter he believes Toronto would be “foolish” to pass on: Luis Arraez.
Pillar made the case on the latest episode of the Blue Bird Territory podcast, where he and Ricky Romero talked through several names they’d like to see the Blue Jays chase this offseason. Tarik Skubal and Seiya Suzuki came up in the conversation, but Pillar kept coming back to Arraez.
"He's a guy that it doesn't matter who's on the mound [...] he hits elite pitching. It would be foolish for them not to want a guy like that in their lineup," Pillar said of Arraez.
He doubled down on that idea by emphasizing how steady Arraez is from one plate appearance to the next.
“Whether Luis Arraez is getting on base or not, you know what you're going to get [from him] every single time. He's going to grind out at-bats, and he's going to be tough.”
Arraez enters free agency after splitting last season between the San Francisco Giants and the Philadelphia Phillies. At 29, he’s already built a rare résumé: he’s one of only two players in the modern era to win a batting title in both the American League and National League.
Since debuting with the Minnesota Twins in 2019, Arraez has hit better than .300 in six of his eight seasons and has been named an All-Star four times, including last season.
He isn’t a power-first bat, but the contact still plays. Toronto’s top hit total last season came from Ernie Clement, who finished with 153.
Arraez had 185, and that gap alone would have pushed the Blue Jays into the top 10 in the league in hits. He’d also give the lineup a dependable presence near the top.
The fit isn’t simple, though, because Toronto still has to figure out where he’d play in the field. One route would be moving Kazuma Okamoto to DH after George Springer’s departure and sliding Arraez to third base. Another would be keeping Clement at third and using Arraez at second, where he played 147 games last season.
The financial side won’t be cheap, either. Spotrac projects Arraez could land around $18 million per year, though a three- or four-year agreement could lower that annual number some.
Even at that price, Pillar clearly sees the logic. In his view, a hitter who can keep putting the ball in play and make life miserable for opposing pitchers is exactly the kind of add Toronto should be chasing, especially in an AL East that gives no one much breathing room.
In Other News...
Blue Jays Roster Move Leaves One September Call-Up In Limbo
Rudy Martin Jr.s brief September run with the Blue Jays has already taken another turn. After clearing waivers, he was outrighted to Triple-A Buffalo and removed from the 40-man roster, a procedural move that trims the clubs depth chart while sending him back out of the big-league picture for now.
Martin got into two major league games for Toronto this month, a small but notable stop for a player who has spent most of his career bouncing through the minors and independent ball. Because he has been outrighted before, the next step is not entirely straightforward, and the clubs roster flexibility is part of the broader story as September gives way to whatever comes next. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Look Poised To Strike Before Baseball Freezes
With a labor stoppage looming on Dec. 2, the free-agent market suddenly has a clock attached to it, and the Blue Jays look like one of the clubs most likely to move before everything gets stuck in neutral. Toronto has obvious roster needs and the payroll room to chase them, which makes this a natural fit for a team that has spent the winter weighing how aggressive to be while the rest of the market tries to guess how long the freeze might last.
The scramble could create a short window where clubs are forced to act faster than planned, and Toronto is being mentioned among the teams best positioned to take advantage. In the broader picture, the Blue Jays are linked to several of the top names still out there, with one projection connecting them to Seiya Suzuki, a reminder that the market may not wait for the usual long negotiations to play out. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Just Lost A Reunion Path They Could Really Use
The Blue Jays were already staring at an offseason with a thin pool of impact bats, and one of the cleaner reunion ideas on the board has now disappeared. Bo Bichette is staying with the Mets through the 2027 season, which shuts the door on any easy path back to Toronto and takes a familiar middle-of-the-order bat off the market.
For a club that still needs help adding power, the timing matters. Toronto now has to sort through a free-agent class with fewer difference-makers and more competition for the ones who can actually change a lineup, making the search for offensive help a little trickier than it looked just a few days ago. [Read more 🡒]