The Toronto Blue Jays are taking a calculated risk by bringing Eloy Jiménez into the fold with a minor league deal. Once a top prospect, Jiménez had a brief stint with the Blue Jays' organization last season, hitting .167 over 21 plate appearances with Buffalo. While the outfield is crowded, recent developments suggest that Jiménez might not be competing for an outfield spot after all.
Reports from Keegan Matheson indicate that Jiménez has been working out at first base during early Spring Training sessions. With the first game of Spring Training set for Saturday, Jiménez was seen taking reps alongside Vladimir Guerrero Jr., the Blue Jays' starting first baseman.
The Blue Jays are looking for a reliable backup for Guerrero Jr., especially considering the short offseason and the desire to give him more rest days. Jiménez has a shot at securing a bench role if he can demonstrate his defensive capabilities. His performance in the Dominican Winter League raised some concerns about his defense, particularly at first base, but his potential with the bat remains a significant asset.
The recent addition of Jesús Sánchez to the roster could complicate matters. Sánchez is expected to become a full-time outfielder, which might affect Myles Straw's position on the team. If Jiménez secures a spot, it could come at Straw's expense, leaving Nathan Lukes as the utility outfielder and Jiménez potentially sharing first base duties with Guerrero Jr.
Jiménez's history of injuries means that putting him in the outfield for extended periods is risky. His best chance to make the roster is likely as a designated hitter or first baseman. However, with Guerrero Jr. and George Springer regularly occupying those roles, Jiménez's path to the roster is not straightforward.
Despite these challenges, Jiménez arrives at camp motivated and eager to prove himself. After nearly retiring last season, his stint with Toros del Este in the Dominican Winter League revitalized his career.
Reflecting on his journey, Jiménez shared, “A few months ago, I didn’t want to play baseball anymore. I was seriously considering retiring.
I talked to my family about it because I couldn’t stand so many injuries and felt like I wasn’t getting the opportunities I wanted.”
His impressive performance in the Dominican Winter League, where he hit five home runs and earned MVP honors in the round robin with 10 doubles and 16 RBIs, showcases his potential. If Jiménez can carry that momentum into Spring Training and demonstrate at least average defensive skills, manager John Schneider might just find a spot for him on the Opening Day roster.