The Blue Jays are heading into another winter with room to spend and plenty of reasons to be active. George Springer, Shane Bieber and Max Scherzer are all coming off the books, which should put Toronto back in the mix for some of the biggest names on the market.
But Jim Bowden doesn’t see the Jays as the obvious destination for many of the top free agents. The former general manager, now a writer for The Athletic, has Toronto as the best fit for only one player in his top 20: Seiya Suzuki.
He also lists Japanese right-hander Hiromi Itoh, who will be posted by the Hokkaido Nippon-Ham Fighters of NPB, as a good fit for the Blue Jays at No. 27 on his board. Beyond that, Toronto doesn’t show up again among his top 40.
That leaves a few names on the table that feel like they should at least be in the conversation.
Tarik Skubal sits at No. 1 on Bowden’s list, with the New York Mets, LA Dodgers and Chicago White Sox named as his best fits. Bowden called him “the best left-handed starting pitcher in the game to finish the season” after he got healthy and settled with L.A., pointing to a 2.72 ERA across 158.2 innings with 186 strikeouts and 27 walks.
He also noted that Skubal made two postseason starts for the Dodgers and allowed three runs in 11 innings. Bowden expects him to command a contract somewhere between $350 million and $500 million, depending on the length.
Freddy Peralta comes in at No. 2, and Bowden has the San Diego Padres, Chicago Cubs and Chicago White Sox as the best landing spots. His path to free agency was more uneven.
Bowden wrote that Peralta “never got into a groove with the Mets,” posting a 4.99 ERA in 22 starts before being dealt to the Rays at the deadline. Once in Tampa Bay, though, he turned things around quickly under Kyle Snyder and the club’s pitching infrastructure.
He finished with a 3.25 ERA in 10 regular-season starts for the Rays, then won ALCS MVP. Bowden projects a five-year, $140 million deal.
Teruaki Sato is another name Bowden sees going elsewhere, with the New York Yankees and Boston Red Sox listed as his best fits. Bowden wrote that Sato is poised to become “the first Japanese position player since Hideki Matsui 23 years ago to win the MVP Award in the Nippon Professional Baseball league and then join an MLB team the next season.”
He won the league’s Triple Crown this year, hitting .306/.383/.609 with 40 doubles, 39 homers and 106 RBIs. Bowden believes that profile points to a big-market bidding war, and he has Sato landing a five-year, $180 million contract.
Brandon Lowe checks in at No. 9, with the San Francisco Giants, Pittsburgh Pirates and San Diego Padres as Bowden’s preferred fits. Bowden highlighted Lowe’s power and value when healthy, noting that he played a career-high 150 games this year, hit 29 doubles and 35 homers, and posted a 121 OPS+.
He also pointed to his defense, saying Lowe ranked in the 96th percentile in defensive run value. Bowden forecasts a three-year, $54 million deal.
None of that means Toronto won’t be involved. In fact, there are reasons to think the Blue Jays should at least be in the mix.
They need pitching help, which makes Skubal and Peralta natural names to monitor. They’ve also built a stronger presence in the Asian market in recent seasons, signing Kazuma Okamoto last offseason and bringing over Cody Ponce from the KBO, along with international free-agent signings Seojun Moon and Si-Woo Kwon.
That makes Sato a logical player to explore.
And then there’s Lowe, who fits a clear Blue Jays need: more punch from the middle infield. A second baseman who can hit 35 homers and provide strong defensive value is exactly the kind of player Toronto could use both on the field and in the lineup.
Maybe the Blue Jays don’t end up seriously pursuing any of them. But given how Ross Atkins typically operates, it would be surprising if the front office didn’t at least check in on a few of these names.
Whether Toronto lands one is another matter entirely. The bigger point is that Bowden may be underselling just how involved the Blue Jays could be.
In Other News...
Blue Jays Reunion Buzz Comes With One Obvious Roster Problem
The Blue Jays are at least keeping the door cracked on a familiar name, with reports saying they had interest in bringing back Teoscar Hernandez after missing out on Kyle Tucker last offseason. Hernandez has since helped the Los Angeles Dodgers win two championships, and his status there could become more fluid if the club decides to get younger and trim payroll by moving veteran pieces.
From Torontos side, the appeal is easy to understand. The lineup could use more power, and Hernandez remains the kind of bat that fits that need. The obstacle is just as obvious, though, because the Blue Jays already have outfield depth to sort through, which makes any reunion harder to fit cleanly even before the money comes into play. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Linked To Risky Trade Idea Fans Will Debate
The Blue Jays are being tied to a trade idea that would be as bold as it is divisive, with C.J. Abrams of the Nationals emerging as a possible target if Toronto wants to keep pushing its offense forward for the 2027 season. The appeal is obvious enough: a young, dynamic infielder who could change the look of a lineup and give the club another impact bat to build around.
But any conversation about Abrams comes with a catch, and it is a big one for a team that has to weigh both present upside and future roster flexibility. Toronto would have to decide whether the offensive boost is worth the cost in prospects and the defensive questions that have followed him, which is exactly why this kind of proposal is the sort of idea fans can argue about for a while before anyone in the front office gets serious about it. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Prospects Are Sending Very Different AFL Signals
The Arizona Fall League has given the Blue Jays a mixed read on a group of eight prospects suiting up for the Mesa Solar Sox, with some players making their case early and others still searching for traction. Jake Cook has been one of the brighter spots, piling up a team-leading 19 hits in 13 games, while Jake Casey has had a tougher time getting his bat going and has been stuck near the bottom of the offensive leaderboard.
On the pitching side, Jake Bloss has offered both promise and frustration. He opened the fall with a strong showing, only to see one recent outing drag his numbers in the wrong direction, even as Toronto can at least take comfort in the fact that he is healthy again after a rough injury stretch. For a club trying to sort out which prospects are ready to take a step forward, the AFL has already provided a reminder that development rarely moves in a straight line. [Read more 🡒]