Blue Jays Suddenly Have A Real Shortstop Problem For 2027

The Blue Jays face a critical decision at shortstop as they look to boost their offense for the 2027 season, but Andrs Gimnez may not be the solution.

The Blue Jays can’t keep pretending the shortstop spot is fine if they want a real answer for 2027.

Toronto’s 2026 season fell apart because the lineup never got off the mat. Injuries and key players underperforming left the club with baseball’s worst offence, and the front office is expected to hunt for at least one or two bats in free agency this winter.

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. should also be in line to hit much better in 2027. But one problem doesn’t have an easy fix: the production coming from Andrés Giménez.

There’s no way around it. Giménez has not been a good hitter, and the Blue Jays have to decide whether they’re willing to keep living with that.

His 2026 numbers tell the story. He hit .241/.291/.359 with nine home runs and 59 RBIs, while stealing 20 bases in 24 attempts.

The speed still plays. The bat, not so much.

The issue isn’t just the batting average or the power. Giménez walked only 17 times in 148 games, and that sub-.300 on-base percentage is a major problem. His at-bats too often disappear without much resistance, and his approach at the plate doesn’t give Toronto much room to hope for a rebound.

The underlying numbers are just as rough. His Baseball Savant page is loaded with blue, and not in a good way.

He chases pitches outside the zone 43.9% of the time, which ranks in the 2nd percentile. His 24.9% hard-hit rate is among the worst in the sport, and his 68.3 mph bat speed is right there with it.

At this point, the Blue Jays have to accept that the player who posted a .837 OPS in 2022 is gone. The version that was roughly league average in 2023 may be gone too. Whatever optimism came with acquiring him has been wiped out over the last two seasons.

The problem, of course, is the contract. Giménez is owed roughly $23.5 million in each of the next three seasons, which makes any move complicated. It’s hard to view Ross Atkin’s decision to take on that deal as anything other than an unforced error.

Still, Toronto is a big-market team, and that matters. If a player isn’t producing, the club doesn’t have to keep running him out there just because of the money. That same logic also applies to Anthony Santander.

A trade would be difficult. There probably isn’t much of a market for Giménez at that salary unless the Blue Jays are willing to absorb another bad contract in return. The Texas Rangers are floated as one possible match, especially in a deal that would let them move Corey Seager’s albatross of a contract.

If Toronto wants a true shortstop upgrade, the open market doesn’t offer much. There isn’t a star shortstop available this winter, so the trade route looks more realistic. Jeremy Peña would be a strong fit if the Houston Astros were willing to deal him, and the same goes for Gunnar Henderson.

Another possibility is to shop in a different part of the infield. Jazz Chisholm Jr. and Brandon Lowe are both available, and signing one of them would at least give the Blue Jays a chance to platoon Giménez with Ernie Clement. That would let them work the matchup game by handedness and maybe squeeze more out of both players.

But the larger point is simple: Toronto needs a different plan. Great defense and useful baserunning only go so far when the bat is this light. The Blue Jays need more offence at shortstop, and Giménez hasn’t given them enough reason to believe he’s the answer.

In Other News...

Blue Jays Fans Just Got A Bittersweet Rowdy Tellez Update

Rowdy Tellez is heading overseas for the 2027 season, a move that closes the book on a major league run that stretched across nine seasons and six clubs. For Blue Jays fans, it lands with a little extra weight because Tellez was one of the more memorable homegrown bats to come through Toronto, and his name still carries plenty of goodwill north of the border.

His path has been winding since then. Tellez spent 2026 mostly in Triple-A after a brief stint with the Atlanta Braves, and now he is set to continue his career with the Rakuten Golden Eagles of Nippon Professional Baseball. It is a bittersweet update for fans who followed him from his Toronto days, especially given how well he peaked with the Milwaukee Brewers in 2022 and how long he remained a familiar figure in the majors. [Read more 🡒]

Blue Jays Trade For A Needed Bat Looks Even Worse Now

The trade Toronto made to add a needed bat has taken on a strange look in a hurry. Joey Loperfido, one of the players involved, was placed on outright waivers by the Astros, cleared, and then came off Houstons 40-man roster with a trip to Triple-A Sugar Land ahead while he continues recovering from hip surgery.

Jess Snchez, the other piece in the deal, has followed a similarly unsettled path. Toronto designated him for assignment earlier, the Diamondbacks claimed him and then designated him again, and he has now cleared waivers and will become a free agent. For a move that was supposed to help the Blue Jays on offense, the reality now is that neither player is on a major-league roster. [Read more 🡒]

Yankees Fans May Not Love Where Jazz Chisholm Fits This Winter

The Blue Jays are keeping an eye on one of the more intriguing names in this winters free-agent market, with Jazz Chisholm emerging as a possible fit as Toronto looks to add offense. Chisholms appeal goes beyond the bat, too. He has shown strong defensive ability and has averaged 2.9 WAR over the past three seasons, which helps explain why a team looking to raise its ceiling would have interest.

For Toronto, the fit is straightforward enough: a player with athleticism, versatility and enough impact to matter on both sides of the ball. For the Yankees, the wrinkle is less comfortable. Chisholm is not expected to return to New York, which leaves the Blue Jays as a plausible landing spot and adds another layer to a rivalry that rarely needs much help getting interesting. [Read more 🡒]