The Blue Jays already have one of the stronger bullpens in the league, with closer Louis Varland at the front of it. But if Toronto wants another arm who can handle leverage, Emilio Pagán just put himself on the market in a way that should get the front office’s attention.
Francys Romero of Beisbol/FR reported yesterday that Pagán declined his 1-year, $10M player option and will test free agency in search of a multi-year deal. Romero also reported that Pagán had a strong second half, going 3-0 with a 1.71 ERA, 29 SO in 26.1 IP and 18 SV.
It’s a bold move for a 35-year-old who turns 36 in May, but the numbers give him a real case. Over the last two seasons, Pagán ranks eighth in MLB with 57 combined saves, only three behind Mason Miller and ahead of Josh Hader. He finished this past season 5-1 with a 3.38 ERA, 1.03 WHIP and a 45:11 K-to-BB ratio in 42 innings.
He was even sharper after coming back from a hamstring injury, converting all 19 of his save chances with a 1.88 ERA.
Toronto doesn’t need another closer in the strictest sense, but Pagán could fit as a right-handed setup option alongside Tyler Rogers. And while he is not Varland, the gap may not be as wide as it first appears when you stack up the last two seasons.
Pagán has also been especially effective on the road. Across 2025-2026, his road ERA was 2.03 with a .86 WHIP, compared to a 3.88 ERA and 1.04 WHIP at Great American Ballpark.
There are obvious concerns, too. Pagán is an extreme fly-ball pitcher, ranking in the 3rd percentile in ground-ball rate in 2025, and he would have ranked in the 1st percentile in 2026 if he had enough batted balls to qualify. He also allowed a 10.1% barrel rate this season and has given up 1.5 HR/9 in 2026 and for his career.
That profile makes strong outfield defense a bigger issue, which is why Brett Bateman or another strong center fielder would matter even more if Toronto signed him. His injury history is part of the equation as well, with time on the injured list in both 2024 and 2026.
Even with those risks, Pagán still checks in as one of the better relievers available. Pitcher List ranks Padres setup man Adrian Morejon as the top free-agent reliever and 10th best overall, followed by Bryan Abreu, Evan Phillips, Raisel Iglesias and Pagán.
If Toronto can’t land Morejon, Pagán would still be a useful addition, and he brings more closing experience if Varland goes down. John Schneider has already shown he’ll lean hard on a small group of trusted arms, with Mason Fluharty, Braydon Fisher and Tyler Rogers all ranking in the top 10 in baseball in appearances. Varland was 22nd, and Jeff Hoffman, who spent two-thirds of the season with Toronto, was 18th.
Ross Atkins could give Schneider another option he trusts. Pagán’s pitch mix is built around a high-spin four-seamer he throws 63% of the time, plus a cutter at 20% and a splitter at 18%.
Toronto could use another leverage arm. Just don’t ask for much in the way of a breaking ball or changeup if you want to get into Schneider’s Circle of Trust.
In Other News...
Blue Jays May Have Found Their Best Rotation Upgrade This Winter
Michael Kings name has quickly moved into the conversation for clubs looking to bolster the top of their rotation this winter, and Toronto fits that group as well as anyone. After opting out of his Padres deal on Oct. 29, the right-hander is suddenly one of the more intriguing starters on the market, coming off a season in which he gave San Diego a heavy workload and steady results over 185 innings with a 3.21 ERA and 1.18 WHIP.
For the Blue Jays, the appeal is obvious: they need pitching help, and King offers the kind of track record that can change the look of a staff. There has been no official signing or offer reported, but the fit is easy to see, which is why his market figures to stay worth watching as the offseason unfolds. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Fans May Need To Let Go Of These Reunions
A familiar trio surfaced in Jim Bowdens early look at the 2026-27 free-agent class, with former Blue Jays Kevin Gausman, Shane Bieber and Daulton Varsho all landing on his list of top names. For Toronto fans, it is the kind of reminder that the roster churn never really stops, especially when players who once mattered in the clubhouse and in the standings start popping up in future market projections.
The Blue Jays have reason to keep an eye on all three, but the fit is not as simple as nostalgia might suggest. Recent performance and injury history are part of the equation for each player, and Bowdens read points in directions that could make those reunions harder to imagine than some fans would like, leaving Toronto to weigh memory against the realities of what comes next. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Offseason Debate Just Got A Compelling New Offensive Option
The Blue Jays search for offense has already led them down the familiar path of chasing power, but Kevin Pillar thinks Toronto should widen the lens. He pointed to free agent Luis Arraez as a player who could fit what the roster needs, bringing a different kind of impact than the usual slugger-centered offseason target. Arraez, a three-time batting champion, just put together an All-Star season split between the Giants and Phillies, and his calling card has long been the same: put the ball in play, work counts, and make pitchers uncomfortable.
For a Toronto lineup that has spent plenty of time looking for more consistency, Arraez offers a complementary route rather than a flashy one. His contact ability and defensive versatility could help balance a group that is also being linked to other free agents with more pop, giving the front office a real stylistic choice as it weighs how to improve the offense. The question now is whether the Blue Jays want to keep chasing the biggest swing or consider a hitter whose value shows up in a different, but still meaningful, way. [Read more 🡒]