The Blue Jays’ bullpen had plenty of bright spots in 2026, but the left side of it still looks like a soft spot Toronto can’t afford to ignore.
Louis Varland, Spencer Miles and Tyler Rogers did the heavy lifting all season long, and Jeff Hoffman found his footing after losing the closer’s role early in the year. Hoffman finished with the bullpen’s highest strikeout rate at 14.06 K/9 and the third-highest fWAR in 48 innings before heading to the Minnesota Twins at the trade deadline. Still, the real backbone of the group was Varland, Rogers and Miles.
That trio put together a 1.62 ERA across 186 relief appearances, piling up 39 holds, 41 saves and only six blown saves. Varland accounted for 35 of those saves, while Rogers had four blown saves and Miles went 6-0 without blowing an opportunity. They were the engine of the relief corps, and the difference was obvious whenever one of them wasn’t on the mound.
Even with that strength, Toronto’s bullpen still finished with the 10th-highest fWAR in the league at 4.9 in 2026. The group also cracked the Top 10 in Run Value with three pitches: the slider ranked third at 19.8, the curveball was fifth at 4.5, and the four-seam fastball came in seventh at 19.5.
The bigger picture around the pitching staff is less tidy. Toronto dealt with a long list of problems, inconsistencies and injuries, especially in the rotation, and the expectation is that the club will chase a high-profile free agent and at least one mid-rotation starter for 2027.
But the bullpen could use a move too, and the issue is pretty clear: the Jays need more help from the left side. Their top three relievers are all right-handed, and the left-handed depth behind them was thin in 2026.
Only four lefties reached at least 20 innings out of the bullpen for Toronto. Mason Fluharty logged the most value of that group with 0.5 fWAR in 79 relief appearances and 58 ⅓ innings.
Joe Mantiply worked 27 innings and posted a 5.38 xERA. Brendon Little made 30 appearances, threw 28 ⅓ innings and finished at -0.2 fWAR, while also allowing a .414 BABIP and a 31.3% HR/FB rate.
Adam Macko turned in a 5.31 ERA and a 4.56 xFIP, the highest among the club’s left-handed relievers.
One name stands out as a possible fix: Alex Vesia. He’s one of the better left-handed relievers on the free-agent market, and he’ll turn 31 in April 2027. Vesia has seven seasons of major league experience, including six as a key piece of the Dodgers’ bullpen during their back-to-back World Series runs in 2024 and 2025, when they beat the New York Yankees and the Blue Jays.
Vesia’s 2026 season was steady again. He finished in the 77th percentile in pitching, kept missing bats at a high clip and continued to limit hard contact.
He landed in the 95th percentile in whiffs and the 96th percentile in strikeout rate, even while dealing with the control issues that have followed him throughout his career. He’s also shown he can handle a real workload, with at least 56 relief appearances in each of the last five seasons and an average of 69 over the last three.
That combination of availability and reliability is what makes him such an appealing target. The estimate here is a $9 million value, which could make a two-year deal in the $16 million to $18 million range possible. If Toronto wants to raise the ceiling of its bullpen, Vesia would be the kind of under-the-radar arm that fits the bill.
And the case for him gets even stronger when you look at the recent track record. Over the last three seasons, Vesia has posted a 1.24 ERA against relievers who have faced at least 180 batters in appearances on one day of rest. He also owns the lowest OPS allowed at .463 and the second-highest strikeout rate at 12.18 K/9, trailing only Aroldis Chapman at 12.86.
In Other News...
Blue Jays Are Suddenly Dealing With A Santander Controversy
Anthony Santanders social media activity has put the Blue Jays in an awkward spot before he has even had a chance to settle into the lineup. General manager Ross Atkins addressed the matter publicly and made clear he was disappointed by what he saw, saying he had already communicated his concerns directly to Santander and that the comments do not line up with the organizations values.
For Toronto, the issue lands at a delicate time because Santander is already on the shelf after shoulder surgery, leaving the club to manage the optics of a major offseason addition from a distance. The Blue Jays signed him to a five-year deal, and now the focus around that commitment has shifted away from baseball and toward how the team handles a controversy that has quickly become part of the conversation. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Face A Costly Offseason Call In Search Of More Power
The Blue Jays are looking at ways to add more punch to a lineup that could use it, and Brandon Lowe has surfaced as one possible fit after his 2026 season with Pittsburgh. The veteran second baseman hit .260 with 35 home runs and 96 RBIs, and he also showed improvement on defense, the kind of all-around season that tends to draw attention when a club is searching for offense without sacrificing too much on the other side of the ball.
For Toronto, though, this is not a simple shopping trip. The talks are still early, other teams are expected to be involved, and any serious pursuit would force the front office to weigh the cost of adding a proven power bat against the financial and roster-building penalties that can come with it. In a winter where every move matters, the Blue Jays will have to decide how much they are willing to pay for a player who could change the middle of the order. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Face A Familiar Kevin Gausman Decision Again
Kevin Gausman is back in the conversation as another offseason approaches, and the Blue Jays have reason to pay close attention. MLB Trade Rumors included the right-hander among its top free agents for the 2026-27 market, a reminder that his value still sits near the top of the pitching class after years of steady work and durability. For Toronto, the appeal is obvious: Gausman has already been part of the rotation picture, and his track record gives the club a familiar benchmark as it weighs its next move.
The projection only adds to the intrigue around where this goes from here. MLBTRs panel sees a possible return to Toronto as a real outcome, while another voice in the group points him toward Baltimore, which keeps the discussion from feeling settled just yet. There is no deal in hand, only the kind of familiar winter question the Blue Jays have faced before with a pitcher they know well, and one whose next contract could shape the market around him. [Read more 🡒]