With the August 3 MLB Trade Deadline creeping closer, the Blue Jays are suddenly looking less like buyers and more like a club that may have to cash in on what it has left. Toronto sits at 42-49 and has dropped 10 of its last 13, a skid that has pushed the conversation away from adding help and toward what it would mean to sell.
The Jays are still only 3.5 games out of an AL wild card spot, but the recent stretch has been brutal. Over their last three games, they’ve been outscored 25-1, and the bigger concern is that this team is now largely healthy with few excuses left to lean on. Trade chatter has followed the reigning American League champions for much of the season, but the possibility of moving pieces now feels real if 2026 keeps slipping away.
That puts president Mark Shapiro and GM Ross Atkins in a tough spot. Nobody in Toronto wants to think about a path that leads to 2027, but the front office has to be ready for it. If the season keeps going this way, the Blue Jays may have to consider moving some of their biggest names before they walk for nothing this winter.
Kevin Gausman would be the headliner if Toronto decided to put a starter on the market. If the pending free agent gets dealt, he could rank just behind Detroit Tigers ace Tarik Skubal as the second-best starting pitcher available.
Gausman has been shaky lately, but that doesn’t erase the value of a 35-year-old who has built a reputation as a reliable, proven big-game arm. In five starts and six total appearances during the 2025 postseason, he went 2-3 with a 2.93 ERA, and over the life of his five-year contract he has been a steady frontline presence for Toronto.
If someone like Dylan Cease or Louis Varland isn’t available, Gausman would likely bring back the biggest return among Blue Jays pitchers. Even so, Atkins could also try to squeeze value out of other veteran starters on expiring deals.
Shane Bieber has had a rough return from injury, but his Cy Young background still carries weight. Max Scherzer has shown signs that age may finally be catching the 41-year-old, though Toronto fans know he still rises when the stage gets bigger. Patrick Corbin has already pitched himself out of the rotation, but a club in need of innings could still see something there.
Daulton Varsho is another name to watch. The Blue Jays are believed to want to work out an extension with him, but if those talks don’t go the right way, he’d draw plenty of attention.
Varsho brings elite defense, speed, power and a left-handed bat, and he just turned 30, which means there should still be several peak years ahead. The flip side is familiar: injuries have piled up, and his bat can go quiet.
Even so, there’s enough upside to make him a desirable target if Toronto ever decides to listen.
George Springer is in a different spot, but the risk is still there for anyone considering his next contract. Whether it’s the Blue Jays or another team, someone is going to be taking a big swing on the 36-year-old slugger.
Toronto may not even be worried about that part if it chooses to trade him, but his final months of contract still come with some offensive value. His 2026 numbers aren’t where he wanted them, yet he’s only one year removed from a .959 OPS and a 32-homer 2025 season.
Postseason teams may also remember what he did last spring, when he hit four home runs, collected 10 extra-base hits and drove in 10 runs in the playoffs.
Of course, Toronto could still turn this all around. A hot run would wipe away the seller talk in a hurry and drag the Blue Jays back into the playoff race. But right now, Shapiro, Atkins and the rest of the front office have to live with the possibility that the deadline becomes less about adding and more about getting value before free agency takes those players away for nothing.
In Other News...
Blue Jays Fans Now Know The Heartbreaking Reason Braydon Fisher Left
Braydon Fisher is back with the Blue Jays after stepping away on bereavement leave, but the circumstances behind his absence have cast a much heavier shadow than any bullpen storyline. Fisher has been one of Torontos more important relief arms this season, the kind of steady late-inning piece a club leans on when the schedule tightens and every out matters.
The reason for the leave was as heartbreaking as it gets, with the loss tied to a family trip to San Francisco during the Blue Jays series there. Fisher has returned to the team, though he still remains on bereavement status, and the personal toll of the past stretch is now part of the backdrop as Toronto moves on without one of its most dependable relievers fully in the fold. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Just Got A Trade Deadline Answer Fans May Hate
The Blue Jays are still hanging around the playoff race, but the offense has not looked like the kind of unit that can carry a team deep into October. With the deadline approaching, the front office is being pushed toward a familiar question: add a useful bat and hope the lineup wakes up, or pay up for someone who can actually change the shape of the order.
One suggested path would bring in a versatile right-handed hitter who can cover multiple spots and supply moderate power, the sort of player who helps in a lot of ways without necessarily solving the biggest problem. That is where the hesitation starts for Toronto, because a steady regular is not always enough when the lineup needs impact more than depth, and the cost of settling for merely solid could be a tough sell to fans expecting a real jolt. [Read more 🡒]
Jordan Romano Is Back In The Majors With Something To Prove
Jordan Romano is back in the majors after working his way through the Rockies minor league system, and the former Blue Jays closer already has a fresh opportunity to remind people what made him such a reliable late-inning arm in Toronto. Colorado called him up after a roster opening created by Tomoyuki Suganos move to the injured list, giving Romano another shot at a big-league role after a stretch of trying to rebuild his footing.
The timing matters because Romanos recent stops with the Phillies and Angels did not go well, leaving him with plenty to prove every time he takes the mound. He has already been used in back-to-back games for Colorado and logged a save against the Giants, a useful first step for a pitcher whose path back to relevance is still being written. [Read more 🡒]