Blue Jays Saw Trey Yesavage's Upside Before His Season Took A Turn

Trey Yesavage's rookie season with the Blue Jays showcased flashes of brilliance and resilience, positioning him as a promising talent despite injury setbacks.

Trey Yesavage’s first season in the majors gave the Blue Jays a glimpse of why they were so high on him - and a reminder of how much of his future still depends on staying on the mound.

The Blue Jays’ first-round pick in 2024 reached Toronto in September 2025, made three starts, then added five more starts and one relief appearance during the playoff run. Across 27.2 innings, he posted a 3.58 ERA while giving up 18 hits, 11 walks and piling up 39 strikeouts. The club had hoped hitters would struggle with his “over the top” delivery, and that did seem to be the case.

The bigger issue was availability. Yesavage missed a fair bit of time with injury, so the full-season test never really arrived. When he was out there, though, the results were encouraging enough to keep the optimism alive.

Baseball Reference credited him with 2.0 WAR, while Fangraphs had him at 1.3, which valued him at $10.0 million to the Blue Jays. His 4.22 FIP and 4.57 xFIP help explain why the Fangraphs number came in lower. He also worked with a .214 BABIP, well below the team’s .283, and stranded 74.8% of the base runners he allowed, compared with the team mark of 72.4.

The batted-ball profile was a mixed bag. His line drive rate sat at 16.4%, below the team’s 19.4.

He produced ground balls 32.2% of the time, well under the team’s 42.3, while his fly ball rate climbed to 50.4% against the team’s 38.2. Of those fly balls, 8.1% left the park, compared with the team’s 9.5.

His strikeout rate was 24.2%, a touch better than the team’s 23.1, but his walk rate also rose to 11.7% from the team’s 9.7.

He was slightly better against right-handed hitters, who hit .174/.263/.356 against him, than left-handed hitters, who went .195/.300/.349. On the road, he was sharper too, holding batters to .172/.281/.316 with a 3.20 ERA. At home, they hit .200/.287/.388 and he carried a 4.21 ERA.

Month by month, the line moved around. In April, he made one start and went 1-0 with a 0.00 ERA, while opponents hit .200/.200/.250.

May was his busiest stretch, with six starts and a 2.56 ERA. June brought five starts and a 4.75 ERA, and July featured five more starts with a 4.81 ERA.

He also made one short August start, then two September starts totaling four innings.

Toronto’s record in his starts was 7-13, and the offense averaged 3.63 runs in those games. The Blue Jays scored three runs or fewer in 13 of his starts.

Rest didn’t seem to change much. On four days’ rest, he made eight starts and went 3-3 with a 2.85 ERA.

With five days’ rest, he was 0-2 with a 4.23 ERA. With six or more days, he had four starts and a 4.42 ERA.

The catcher pairing also varied. Tyler Heineman caught him in three games and 14.1 innings, and Yesavage had a 1.26 ERA in those outings.

Alejandro Kirk caught nine games and 35 innings, with Yesavage posting a 4.63 ERA. Brandon Valenzuela worked with him in eight games and 48.1 innings, and that came with a 3.72 ERA.

The splits by trip through the order told their own story. The first time through, hitters managed just .158/.257/.283.

The second time, they hit .185/.290/.290. The third time, the line jumped to .250/.333/.618.

He was also effective with runners in scoring position, holding opponents to .149/.269/.216. In high-leverage situations, though, hitters reached .241/.343/.407, compared with .167/.254/.333 in low leverage.

His best outing by GameScore came on May 20 at Yankee Stadium, when he posted a 76 after six innings, two hits, no walks and eight strikeouts. The roughest one came on July 7 in San Diego, when he lasted just 1.2 innings and was charged with four earned runs, seven walks and one strikeout for a 31 GameScore.

He averaged 4.9 innings per start. And the underlying Savant numbers were strong in a few key areas: xBA in the 92nd percentile, Whiff % in the 84th, Barrel % in the 65th. The red flags were the ground ball rate, which landed in the 11th percentile, and the walk rate, which sat in the 13th.

Injuries defined the season more than anyone wanted. He dealt with a shoulder issue at the start, then missed time after meniscus surgery in early August, and threw just four innings after that near the end of the year. Still, the raw stuff and the flashes of dominance were enough to keep the bigger picture intact.

The caution around his unusual delivery was there before the season, and it remains. But one year isn’t enough to make a final judgment, especially with so little uninterrupted time. The Blue Jays were careful with him in spring training, and that caution didn’t prevent the injury problems - it just showed they had reasons to be cautious in the first place.

He’s still only 23, turning 24 at the end of July. There’s plenty of time for him to grow into the top-of-the-rotation starter Toronto was hoping for.

In Other News...

Blue Jays Pitching Outlook Just Shifted In A Way Fans Will Feel

FanGraphs latest update to the Blue Jays top 38 prospect rankings brought a noticeable shakeup on the mound, and it says plenty about how the organizations next wave of pitching talent is being viewed. Nolan Perry climbed all the way to No. 3 after a strong 2026 season in the wake of Tommy John surgery, while Johnny King moved into the No. 2 spot on the strength of encouraging performance metrics that have helped his stock keep rising.

Jake Bloss, meanwhile, slid to No. 9 after a 2026 season that was interrupted by injuries and marked by uneven results, a reminder that pitching depth can change fast. For Toronto, the update is more than just a list shuffle. It reflects a system where the upside is still there, but the order of the arms fans are watching has shifted in a way that could shape how the club thinks about its future rotation plans. [Read more 🡒]

Blue Jays Could Make A Rotation Move That Changes Everything

After a 2026 season that was badly affected by injuries, the Blue Jays are heading into the offseason with one priority that could shape everything else they do: the starting rotation. Toronto is expected to build around a group that includes Dylan Cease, Trey Yesavage, Jose Soriano and potentially Cody Ponce, but the front office is also being linked to a far bigger swing as it looks for ways to raise the ceiling of the staff.

Tarik Skubal has emerged as the name that would change the conversation entirely if Toronto decided to push hard enough. The two-time Cy Young winner would instantly alter the look of the rotation and send a clear message that the Blue Jays intend to be aggressive, but for now it remains more of a possibility than a plan, with the offseason still offering plenty of room for the picture to shift. [Read more 🡒]

Blue Jays Suddenly Have A Roster Squeeze Fans Cant Ignore

The Blue Jays are still in the early stages of shaping their offseason, but the roster picture is already getting crowded in a way that could force some tough decisions. Toronto has not landed a major signing yet, and the front office is reportedly looking around the trade market for ways to upgrade the infield and add more power in the outfield, with the Dodgers and Tigers among the clubs mentioned as possible partners.

In that mix, Brandon Valenzuela, Ernie Clement, Nathan Lukes and Josh Smith have surfaced as names worth watching because their performance and arbitration projections help define how much value they might carry in a deal. Nothing has been finalized, and no transactions are confirmed, but the Blue Jays appear to be weighing whether the best path forward is adding talent or using some of their existing pieces to get it. [Read more 🡒]