The Blue Jays keep shuffling the deck, and Davis Schneider is the latest name to get moved out.
Toronto made another round of roster changes as it tries to keep itself afloat down the stretch, and Schneider’s demotion is the headline. It’s the fourth time he’s been optioned this season after opening the year with the big club, and the numbers never really gave him much breathing room. The 27-year-old utility player is hitting .142/.295/.274 with three home runs.
The club had hoped Schneider could carve out a role as a strong platoon bat who would punish lefties, but that part of the plan never clicked. In 58 at-bats against southpaws, he’s hitting .103 with a .493 OPS. Against right-handers, he’s at .182 with a .650 OPS in 55 at-bats.
His runway is getting shorter. Schneider now has just one option remaining, and if Toronto uses it on him again as one of its two September call-up spots and things still don’t turn around, he could be on waivers this winter and looking for a new team for 2027.
Still, the story with Schneider isn’t just failure. Every time he’s gone back to Triple-A, he’s shown why teams keep taking a chance on him.
In 2026 with Buffalo, he’s posted a .253/.503/.482 slash line. That kind of on-base number won’t carry over to the majors, but there’s reason to think he should be able to get well above .300 there.
The sticking point has been strikeouts. Schneider’s K-rate has jumped from 20.2% with the Buffalo Bisons to 33.6% with Toronto. At this point, a fresh start might make the most sense for the former 28th round draft pick.
Lazaro Estrada was also sent down to Triple-A after another brief stint with the Blue Jays. He’s been bouncing between levels all season in 2026, and the split tells the story.
For Buffalo, he’s thrown 25 innings across 10 starts with a 2.52 ERA and a 3.54 FIP. In Toronto, he’s worked 12 innings over seven bullpen appearances, putting up a 4.50 ERA and 5.92 FIP.
Estrada’s latest call-up came because of need, and he did give the Blue Jays a lift before things unraveled. He appeared in all three games against the Philadelphia Phillies over the weekend, and in his first two outings he threw a combined 2.1 hitless innings with two walks and two strikeouts as Toronto won both games. On Sunday, though, he allowed two runs, one earned, walked one and recorded only one out.
Taking Schneider’s roster spot is Charles McAdoo, who is back for his second big league stint. The 24-year-old made his MLB debut on May, 29 and played in eight games in his first run with Toronto, batting .160 with one home run, six strikeouts and no walks.
Since returning to Buffalo, McAdoo has been on a tear. Over 39 games, he hit .290/.376/.503 with a 131 wRC+ and launched eight home runs. Four of those homers came on consecutive days before his latest promotion, and he added another in Toronto’s 2-1 win over Boston on Aug. 10, giving him five straight games with a homer.
Replacing Estrada in the bullpen is Simeon Woods Richardson, who is also back for a second stint with the Blue Jays this year. He was DFA’d by the Twins on May, 30, traded to Toronto on Jun. 3, and used in a bulk role in each of his first three appearances with the club. In those outings, he threw 10 scoreless innings, allowing four hits, striking out five and walking seven.
His early results were clean on the scoreboard, even if the underlying numbers were less flattering. Woods Richardson had a 0.00 ERA at the time, but his xERA sat at 5.13. He was DFA’d again on Jun. 26, cleared waivers and went to Buffalo, where he made six appearances, five of them starts, and posted a 4.07 ERA with 20 strikeouts and nine walks in 24.1 innings.
And the roster churn may not be done yet. Jameson Taillon left Monday night’s start after the fourth inning with what the team called “right forearm discomfort.” That comes just after Toronto’s plan to run a six-man rotation lasted less than a week.
There’s already another injury issue hanging over the staff, too. Trey Yesavage left his start last week, on Aug. 4, after feeling pain in his knee. He’s being evaluated and may need surgery at some point.
For now, the Blue Jays were looking at a rotation of Dylan Cease, Shane Bieber, Max Scherzer, José Soriano and Taillon. But if Taillon’s issue forces another change, Toronto could be back down to four starters again - a problem that has shown up far too often in 2026.
In Other News...
Blue Jays Just Got An Unexpected Cody Ponce Rehab Look
Cody Ponces road back from ACL surgery has taken an unusual turn, even by rehab standards. The Blue Jays pitcher is recovering from the injury he suffered in his first start of the 2026 season, and the process has included some work away from a mound, part of a rehabilitation plan that has kept him active while he waits to rejoin Torontos pitching picture.
Ponce still looms as a meaningful piece of the Blue Jays rotation once he returns, which is why every step of the comeback matters. The timeline points toward spring training in 2027, and for now the focus is simply on getting him healthy and back on track, even if the latest glimpse of that process came in a setting few would have expected. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Need To Notice What Taillon Is Becoming
Jameson Taillon still looks much like the pitcher he has been for a while now, at least on the surface. The velocity is there, the strike rate is in line with past seasons and the overall shape of his arsenal has not changed much, but hitters have clearly gotten more comfortable with what they are seeing. The result has been more traffic on the bases, a higher walk rate and less of the element of surprise that once helped him work through lineups.
What has made the shift especially noticeable is how much harder his fastball and cutter are being squared up, while his changeup and curveball have not provided the same kind of escape valve. The batted-ball profile has tilted in the wrong direction, and the home run total tells the story of a pitcher who is still competing but no longer missing the same bats in the same spots. For a Blue Jays club tracking every rotation detail, that is the kind of adjustment worth noticing before it becomes something bigger. [Read more 🡒]