The Toronto Blue Jays cleared a roster spot on Monday by optioning pitcher CJ Van Eyk back to Triple-A Buffalo, and with no corresponding move announced, the path is now wide open for what looks like three September additions.
Van Eyk’s return to the Bisons comes after a strong minor league run this season. In 21 games, including 15 starts, the 27-year-old right-hander went 6-3 with a 3.79 ERA and a 1.34 WHIP.
Over 95 innings, he allowed seven home runs, walked 35 and struck out 68. That performance earned him multiple chances with Toronto.
His big league stint, though, didn’t match what he had done in Buffalo. Across four relief appearances, Van Eyk posted a 4.05 ERA and a 1.95 WHIP, gave up 11 hits, and recorded just one strikeout in 6.2 innings. For a club getting ready to sharpen its roster for the stretch run, the move points toward a search for a more effective option.
One name near the top of the list is Ricky Tiedemann. He made his MLB debut earlier this month against the New York Yankees and, even though he allowed one earned run, he flashed the kind of stuff that gets attention fast. In 1.2 innings of relief, he struck out two Yankees.
His quick return to the minors caught some people off guard, but Toronto may have had a plan in place to build him back up after his time on the IL and get him better prepared for September.
Another possibility is a bat, and Sean Keys fits that idea. He’s been one of the hottest hitting prospects in the system, and the Blue Jays could decide a young power hitter is the kind of boost they want for a playoff push.
There’s also the route Toronto took last season, when it added Isiah Kiner-Falefa from waivers to help fill out the September roster.
However it plays out, Monday’s move sets up an interesting Tuesday for the Blue Jays as they get ready to chase a postseason berth starting in Cleveland.
In Other News...
Blue Jays Suddenly Have A Bigger Spencer Arrighetti Problem
Spencer Arrighetti looked like he might be settling in after a strong opening run with the Astros, but the right-handers season has taken a sharp turn since late May. The home runs have piled up, the fastball has lost some of its edge, and the result has been a pitcher who is no longer giving Houston the kind of stability it expected when he first flashed promise earlier in the year.
For the Blue Jays, the concern is less about one bad outing than a growing pattern that has made Arrighetti a tougher assignment than he seemed a few weeks ago. Most of the damage has come against his fastball, which puts the focus on how effectively he can make the pitch work again, and whether Houston can help him get back to the version of himself that looked so much more dependable before the slide. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Make A Telling Pitching Change Before Guardians Series
Toronto is leaning on a familiar modern pitching wrinkle as it opens its series against Cleveland, handing the first-inning assignment to Spencer Miles and planning for Spencer Arrighetti to cover the bulk of the game behind him. Miles has been one of the more dependable arms in the bullpen this season, giving the Blue Jays steady innings in 42 appearances with a 5-2 record and a 2.92 ERA, the kind of profile that makes him a natural fit for a short opening role.
The move is also a clear attempt to simplify things for Arrighetti after a difficult start to his Toronto tenure. Acquired in a trade, he has yet to settle in, and the club is hoping the opener setup can ease some of the pressure and help him find a better rhythm while giving the Blue Jays a cleaner path through a lineup that will be tested early. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Face A Tough Myles Straw Decision This Offseason
Myles Straw has given the Blue Jays what they expected on the defensive side, but his fit in Toronto is still going to be judged on more than glove work alone. As the 2026 season winds down, the front office has a decision coming on an $8 million club option for 2027, and Straws uneven offense has made it one of the more interesting calls on the clubs offseason docket.
Toronto does not need to decide immediately, and that matters. The team plans to keep evaluating Straw through the end of the season before settling on the option, which gives him a little more time to strengthen his case. For a club weighing roster value and payroll flexibility at the same time, the final weeks could go a long way toward shaping what Straws future looks like in blue and white. [Read more 🡒]