The Blue Jays may not be done with Kevin Gausman after all.
Toronto’s 2026 season was already battered by injuries in the rotation, and by the time the second half rolled around, the club was leaning on bullpen days far too often. That kind of collapse makes the next offseason easy to read: the Blue Jays are going to be hunting for arms.
And Gausman, the reliable ace they shipped out at the trade deadline, could end up back in the mix.
Toronto dealt Gausman to the Chicago Cubs for Brett Bateman and Ty Southisene, but the veteran right-hander is set to reach free agency after the 2026 season. If he doesn’t retire, a return to Toronto is starting to look like a real possibility.
In his final regular-season write-up for 2026, The Athletic’s Mitch Bannon pointed directly to that idea.
"Like Springer and Scherzer, it’s unclear if Gausman’s playing days are over. If he returns, a reunion with Toronto seems likely," said Bannon.
The biggest obstacle to any comeback is retirement. Back in February, when Bannon spoke with Gausman in Dunedin, the two-time All-Star said the thought has already crossed his mind.
"It's definitely a possibility. I have really loved my time [in Toronto].
Do I know what's ahead of me? I don't know.
No idea. It's something that I have definitely thought about in the offseason."
If there is a landing spot for a reunion, Toronto appears to be the one. Gausman’s best work came in a Blue Jays uniform, where he put together a career-high 12.5 WAR, a 3.62 ERA, and 920 strikeouts across 861 innings. His top season came in 2023, when he finished third in Cy Young voting after logging a 3.16 ERA, a 12-9 record in 31 starts, and a season-best 237 strikeouts.
Chicago brought him in at the deadline for rotation help as it pushed toward the postseason, and Gausman went 4-2 with a 4.83 ERA in nine appearances. That was enough for the Cubs to grab the No. 5 seed and advance to the Wild Card round against the San Diego Padres.
His final start of the season ended with a shoulder injury, which left his status uncertain. Even so, the Cubs announced him as their Game 2 starter for Wednesday’s game, Sept.
- He’ll try to help keep Chicago alive after it dropped Game 1, 8-0.
From Toronto’s side, the fit is obvious. The Blue Jays’ projected 2027 rotation includes Dylan Cease, José Soriano, Cody Ponce, and Trey Yesavage, leaving a vacancy in the fifth spot.
If Gausman chooses to keep pitching, he could slide right into it. There are also reports that Shane Bieber could return.
Toronto learned last season how fragile pitching depth can be. The club believed it had enough starting help, and then that cushion disappeared after April. A Gausman reunion would go a long way toward rebuilding that lost depth.
And with the way Gausman and his family have spoken about the city and its fans, the idea of him finishing as a Blue Jay makes plenty of sense.
In Other News...
Blue Jays Offseason Starts With Recognition And One Notable Exit
The Blue Jays offseason opened with a mix of recognition and roster churn, as a few familiar names surfaced in different corners of the news cycle. Kazuma Okamoto, Dylan Cease and Louis Varland were all named finalists for the 2026 All-MLB Team, a reminder that Torontos recent season produced some individual performances worthy of leaguewide attention even as the front office turns its focus to the winter ahead.
On the move side, Joe Mantiply elected free agency after clearing waivers following his season in Toronto, giving him the chance to look elsewhere for his next landing spot. And there was also a notable farewell for a former Blue Jays reliever, as Liam Hendriks announced his retirement after a 14-year major league career, closing the book on one of the more recognizable arms to pass through the organization in recent years. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Cant Stop Chasing Pitching Depth After This Latest Reminder
The Blue Jays are still looking for answers on the mound, and Jameson Taillons name has popped back into the conversation after Toronto acquired him from the Cubs when he was designated for assignment. His time with the club was a reminder of how quickly rotation plans can get unsettled, with injuries and inconsistency cutting into what the Blue Jays hoped would be a steadier presence. Forearm tendinitis and elbow pain both surfaced during his stint, but the offseason outlook at least leaves room for a fresh start.
For a team that keeps circling back to pitching depth, Taillon now fits into an awkward but familiar category: a starter whose recent results were difficult, yet whose track record and availability could still make sense on a short-term, low-risk deal. Toronto has to keep building contingencies, and this is one of those cases where the appeal is less about the past season than the possibility of finding enough stability to matter over the long haul. [Read more 🡒]
Dylan Cease Just Gave Blue Jays Fans Another Reason For Optimism
Dylan Cease gave the Blue Jays exactly what they hoped for when they committed seven years and $210 million to him in December 2025. In his first season in Toronto, he backed up the price tag with a fourth-place finish in MLB in ERA and a third-place showing in strikeouts, the kind of production that quickly turns a big signing into a foundational piece.
Cease also sounded like a pitcher already leaning into the city and the expectations that come with it. After the season, he publicly thanked Blue Jays fans for their support and said he was motivated heading into next year, which is the sort of note Toronto wants to hear as it tries to build around him. [Read more 🡒]