Teoscar Hernandez is suddenly back in the Blue Jays conversation, and the fit is easy to understand even if the path to making it work is messy.
Hernandez hasn’t worn a Toronto uniform since 2022, when the Blue Jays traded him to the Seattle Mariners in the final year of his team control. Toronto got Erik Swanson and Adam Macko back in that deal, but the return hasn’t really landed. Since then, Hernandez has collected a pair of championships with the Los Angeles Dodgers, including last year’s World Series win over the Blue Jays.
Now the Dodgers may be ready to move in a different direction. After getting hammered by the Milwaukee Brewers in the NLCS, they’re at a crossroads with their dynasty and know they need to get younger and cheaper, especially with the lockout about a month away. That could mean moving some veteran contracts, and Hernandez is the kind of name that could come up.
FanSided’s Pat Ragazzo reported that the Blue Jays tried to get Hernandez last offseason after missing on Kyle Tucker, and the idea could be back on the table again after both clubs came up short of another trip to the Fall Classic.
“Within, the Blue Jays had some level of interest in bringing back Teoscar Hernandez after missing out on Kyle Tucker last offseason, a source told FanSided”
More: https://t.co/I4YefT2u1q
- Pat Ragazzo (@ragazzoreport) October 28, 2026
Toronto’s interest in a reunion isn’t new. After the Dodgers won the World Series in 2024 with Hernandez, the Blue Jays came close to signing him when he hit free agency.
He ended up staying in Los Angeles, while Anthony Santander signed with Toronto instead. That move has not gone the way Ross Atkins hoped.
Santander’s situation is one of the biggest reasons a Hernandez reunion makes sense. He has barely played since signing his five-year deal, missing the entire 2026 season after shoulder surgery. If he comes back healthy, he’s probably looking at full-time DH duty, but right now it’s hard to bank on him for much of anything.
Still, the fit isn’t clean. Toronto needs outfield help, but Hernandez is no longer a strong defender. That creates a problem if the Blue Jays are trying to find at-bats for him in a corner spot, especially with Addison Barger and Nathan Lukes in the mix and Brett Bateman locked in as the everyday center fielder.
His salary is another obstacle. Hernandez is set to make $22.1 million next year, which makes the whole thing harder to pull off.
Even so, the Blue Jays’ need for a real power bat hasn’t gone away. At 34, Hernandez is still doing the one thing Toronto desperately wants: hitting for impact.
He has 41 homers over the last two seasons and remains nearly elite in that area.
The interest is there. The need is there. If Toronto can shuffle the roster enough, Hernandez could wind up back where his Blue Jays story started.
In Other News...
Blue Jays Winter Outlook Feels Smaller Than Fans Were Hoping
The Blue Jays winter shopping list may not look as expansive as some fans hoped, at least not in Jim Bowdens latest free-agent projections. The former GM and writer mapped out his top 40 available players and tied Toronto most clearly to Seiya Suzuki, while also pointing to Japanese right-hander Hiromi Itoh as a realistic fit for the club as it looks for ways to add offense and pitching help.
Bowdens board still leaves Toronto in the mix around several bigger names, but the picture he paints is a narrower one than the markets splashiest possibilities. Tarik Skubal, Freddy Peralta, Teruaki Sato and Brandon Lowe are all slotted with teams Bowden views as better fits, which means the Blue Jays may have to do their heavy lifting in a less crowded part of the market if they want to make a meaningful upgrade. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Linked To Risky Trade Idea Fans Will Debate
The Blue Jays are being tied to a trade idea that would be as bold as it is divisive, with C.J. Abrams of the Nationals emerging as a possible target if Toronto wants to keep pushing its offense forward for the 2027 season. The appeal is obvious enough: a young, dynamic infielder who could change the look of a lineup and give the club another impact bat to build around.
But any conversation about Abrams comes with a catch, and it is a big one for a team that has to weigh both present upside and future roster flexibility. Toronto would have to decide whether the offensive boost is worth the cost in prospects and the defensive questions that have followed him, which is exactly why this kind of proposal is the sort of idea fans can argue about for a while before anyone in the front office gets serious about it. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Prospects Are Sending Very Different AFL Signals
The Arizona Fall League has given the Blue Jays a mixed read on a group of eight prospects suiting up for the Mesa Solar Sox, with some players making their case early and others still searching for traction. Jake Cook has been one of the brighter spots, piling up a team-leading 19 hits in 13 games, while Jake Casey has had a tougher time getting his bat going and has been stuck near the bottom of the offensive leaderboard.
On the pitching side, Jake Bloss has offered both promise and frustration. He opened the fall with a strong showing, only to see one recent outing drag his numbers in the wrong direction, even as Toronto can at least take comfort in the fact that he is healthy again after a rough injury stretch. For a club trying to sort out which prospects are ready to take a step forward, the AFL has already provided a reminder that development rarely moves in a straight line. [Read more 🡒]