Blue Jays Playoff Push May Come Down To One Lineup Spark

The Toronto Blue Jays' playoff dreams hinge on Brett Bateman's explosive impact and Vladimir Guerrero Jr.'s potential resurgence.

Jamie Campbell sees a clearer Blue Jays path to October, and it starts with two very different kinds of difference-makers.

Toronto’s season has been messy enough that Campbell wouldn’t pretend to know exactly where it ends up - “I don't do predictions,” he said - but he did zero in on the pieces that could decide the race. One has already altered the feel of the lineup. The other, if he heats up at the right moment, could take the Blue Jays from fringe Wild Card hopeful to a team nobody wants to draw in October.

That first piece is Brett Bateman, the player Toronto picked up from the Chicago Cubs in the Kevin Gausman trade. In just 20 games heading into Wednesday’s matchup with Cleveland, Bateman is hitting .317 with a 116 wRC+, and Campbell said his value goes beyond the numbers. Toronto has been leaning on speed, contact and pressure, and Bateman has supplied all three.

“There are a lot of reasons why they are where they are, and I hate to put the focus on one individual, but it’s interesting how Bateman has changed the perception of the offence by his mere presence, notably at the top of the order.”

Campbell compared Bateman’s effect to the kind of nuisance player who can rattle a defense the second he reaches base.

“I remember in the middle of the summer watching a Tampa Bay Rays series and thinking, wouldn’t it be nice if the Jays had someone like Chandler Simpson?” Campbell said.

“Someone who was just a terror on the basepaths and made you nervous whenever he got to first base because you’re thinking he could be at third at any moment. Or someone slapping balls into the infield, knowing that unless the infielders are on their toes, it’s likely a base hit.

That’s kind of what Bateman serves for this team.”

Bateman’s arrival, Campbell said, has also lifted the group around him. Nathan Lukes has started to find his swing again.

Alejandro Kirk has been rolling for about three-and-a-half to four weeks. George Springer, Campbell added, “has absolutely come to life again.”

“I think his impact has re-energized a few people,” Campbell said. “Nathan Lukes has seemed to find his stroke again.

Alejandro Kirk’s on fire and has been for about three-and-a-half to four weeks. It seems George Springer has absolutely come to life again.

I’m not going to say it’s the kid’s responsibility or the kid’s impact entirely, but his presence certainly changes the look of the offence.”

The other player Campbell pointed to never came out and was named outright, but the reference to “No. 27” left no doubt: Vladimir Guerrero Jr. And if Guerrero catches the kind of late-season fire that defined his postseason a year ago, Campbell thinks Toronto’s playoff chances change fast.

“This goes without saying - it’s an obvious statement - but if No. 27, in the next three weeks, can become the hitter he was in the postseason a year ago, I can’t imagine this team not surging into that third spot,” Campbell said. “If he catches fire, to me, it’s a foregone conclusion that your final spot would belong to the Blue Jays.”

Campbell’s point was simple: Bateman has changed the offense’s tempo, while Guerrero can still raise its ceiling. Put both together, and Toronto becomes a much tougher out than its record suggests.

Pitching, though, may be the other half of the equation. Campbell said Dylan Cease has started to look dominant as the season has worn on, called José Soriano “an absolutely wonderful addition,” and pointed to Max Scherzer’s recent outing as another encouraging sign for a staff that needed answers.

“Cease has turned it up a little bit,” Campbell said. “It seems as the season goes longer, his performances have been utterly dominant.

Soriano has been an absolutely wonderful addition. When you get a frontline starting pitcher, yes, you gave up Arjun Nimmala, and yes, he may become a frontline shortstop in the majors at some point, but in the short term, it’s worth it.”

He also noted the possibility that Soriano could remain in the picture beyond this push.

“Maybe you get Soriano on a contract extension at some point and he ends up in your rotation for years to come,” Campbell said. “ Scherzer’s effort yesterday (Sunday, Aug. 30) was so welcome because of the questions that lie beyond Cease and Soriano. If Max keeps doing that kind of thing, that solves a problem too.”

For Campbell, the bottom line is that Toronto looks different now than it did earlier in the summer.

“I’d say that both Cleveland and Baltimore better take a good look over their shoulder and realize that the Blue Jays are a different team than they were, say, two months ago,” Campbell said.

In Other News...

Blue Jays Deadline Call Looks Even Better For One Big Reason

When the Blue Jays moved Kevin Gausman to the Cubs at the trade deadline, it looked like the kind of decision that would be judged mostly on return and timing. But the deal has taken on a little more weight because reports say the Yankees were also in the mix for Gausman before Toronto sent him to Chicago, a wrinkle that adds some extra significance to a trade that already shaped the rest of the season.

For Toronto, the bigger picture now includes what has happened since. Prospect Brett Bateman has brought useful production on both sides of the ball since arriving, giving the Blue Jays a more immediate reminder that deadline deals are not just about subtracting a veteran arm, but about what comes back and how quickly it can matter. [Read more 🡒]

Blue Jays Castoff Suddenly Has A New Chance Fans Will Notice

Simeon Woods Richardson is getting another reset, this time with the Seattle Mariners, who signed the right-hander to a minor league deal and sent him to Triple-A Tacoma. For Toronto fans, it is the latest turn in a season that has already taken him through three organizations, after he opened the year with Minnesota, was designated for assignment and then landed with the Blue Jays before being waived.

Woods Richardson chose free agency after Toronto let him go, and now the Mariners will see if they can get something back from a pitcher whose talent has kept him on the move even as the results have lagged. It is a reminder of how quickly a promising arm can slip into roster churn, and why a stint in Tacoma can still matter for a player trying to get back on track. [Read more 🡒]

Blue Jays Opener Carries One Big Question For Returning Veteran

Jameson Taillon is on track to take the ball for the Blue Jays in the upcoming series against the Royals, a sign that Toronto is ready to fold another experienced arm back into the mix as the push for a postseason spot tightens. Manager John Schneider said the veteran right-hander is expected to start, and Taillons recent bullpen session after rehabbing right forearm tendinitis only added to the sense that his return is moving in the right direction.

For Toronto, the appeal is straightforward: Taillon has already given the club two solid outings, posting a 3.38 ERA, and any healthy reinforcement matters this time of year. The bigger question is not whether he can help the rotation in the short term, but how the Blue Jays manage his workload as they try to balance immediate results with a pitcher they have every reason to protect. [Read more 🡒]