A lockout would not just freeze Major League Baseball’s offseason. It could rewrite how the Blue Jays approach it.
Toronto has already lived through the kind of frantic, deadline-driven spending binge a lockout can trigger. Before the 2021-2022 shutdown, MLB clubs spent $2.16B ahead of the lockout, with $1.67B going to free agents and another $489B in extensions. On the final day before the lockout in 2021, teams were racing to beat the clock, and the Blue Jays were right in the middle of the frenzy.
They landed Jose Berrios on a 7-year, $131M extension in mid-November. They reached a 5-year, $110M deal with Kevin Gausman on Nov. 29, though it was not officially processed until the evening of Dec.
- Then, just before the deadline, they added Yimi Garcia on a 2-year, $11M contract.
That kind of rush is exactly what could define this winter, too. Toronto has been tied to power bats, including Seiya Suzuki, who would fit in right field. If the Blue Jays want him, they may need to move before the lockout.
A pre-lockout signing can work for everyone involved. Players, especially those with families, get clarity on where they will live and more time to sort out housing, schools, and the rest of the move.
Clubs get to lock in cost certainty and fill roster holes before the market shuts down. And depending on what the next agreement looks like, a deal could even be grandfathered under the old rules if owners get their way on a salary cap, shorter contract lengths, or restrictions on deferred money.
The same pressure could also spill over into the posting market from Japan. Posted players have a 45-day window to sign with MLB clubs, and if they do not, they go back to their team in Japan. Last season, three Japanese stars were posted - Munetaka Morikami, Kazuma Okamoto, and Tatsuya Imai - and all three signed just before their windows expired.
Normally, teams post those players in mid-to-late November. If a lockout hits, the 45-day clock would likely be frozen, but the timing problem would still be there once baseball resumes. That matters even more for players making a huge cultural and logistical transition on a compressed timeline.
The biggest Japanese name expected to be posted this offseason is Triple Crown winner Teruaki Sato of the Japanese Central League. Toronto has been linked to Sato, whose current club, the Hanshin Tigers, is expected to post him in early November.
The Blue Jays already have a third baseman in Okamoto, but Sato has also played both corner outfield spots. He is not considered a strong defender, so DH would be another possible role.
Toronto will also have to navigate the Rule 5 side of the offseason, lockout or no lockout. Teams must decide by Nov. 17 whether to add Rule 5 Draft-eligible players to the 40-man roster to keep them protected. Blue Jays fans know from Spencer Miles how much one of those picks can matter.
Nolan Perry, Toronto’s No. 2 prospect, is Rule 5-eligible for the first time because he signed out of high school in 2022, and he is viewed as a lock to be added to the 40-man roster. Jay Harry is likely to stay as well. The tougher calls will come with pitchers like Gage Stanifer and Daniel Guerra, plus infielder Josh Kasevich.
The Blue Jays currently have 39 players on their active 40-man roster, but that number does not tell the whole story. Players returning from the 60-day IL have to be added back before the Rule 5 Draft, which creates a roster squeeze regardless of any lockout. Pending free agents will clear some space, but Toronto still looks headed for a crowd in the bullpen and among the middle infielders.
A lockout could ease that pressure by wiping out the Rule 5 Draft altogether. If Toronto believed that was coming, it might gamble by leaving someone like Josh Kasevich off the 40-man roster in order to keep a veteran like Myles Straw.
That is the kind of decision a lockout can force on a front office. Of course, the Blue Jays would prefer none of this matters at all. Right now, though, that seems about as likely as Oprah giving me a brand-new Ferrari.
In Other News...
Blue Jays Could Chase A Huge Bat If This Offseason Breaks Right
The Blue Jays are headed into another offseason where the mandate is clear: add offense and keep pushing the roster toward contender status. Toronto has shown a willingness to spend in recent years, and that matters now because the market could include an intriguing international bat if the right domino falls.
One name already linked to the Jays is Teruaki Sato, a Japanese third baseman with corner outfield experience whose power has drawn plenty of attention. He won the NPB Triple Crown and hit 39 home runs for the Hanshin Tigers this season, but the bigger question is whether he will actually be posted. If he does become available, Toronto is expected to be among the teams that take a serious run. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Suddenly Face A Tough Davis Schneider Decision
Davis Schneider has spent four seasons in the Blue Jays organization, bouncing between Toronto and Triple-A Buffalo as the club has tried to find the right fit for his bat and his role. Now the calculus has shifted. With roster competition tightening and Schneider's recent performance trending the wrong way, the Blue Jays are no longer just deciding where he fits on a given week. They are deciding whether he still fits into the long-term picture at all.
Schneider is under team control through 2030 and has said he hopes to stay in Toronto, but the organization does not have the same easy flexibility it once did. The front office has to weigh a future with him against the risk of being boxed into a move it does not want to make, and that is what makes this offseason so delicate. If the Blue Jays conclude there is not a clear path for him, the conversation could turn quickly from retention to dealing him elsewhere. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Face A Kirk Debate They May Not Want
Former Blue Jays outfielder Kevin Pillar kicked up a familiar kind of offseason debate this week when he suggested Toronto should at least consider testing the market on several of its players, including All-Star catcher Alejandro Kirk. The comment landed because Kirk has become one of the more dependable pieces on the roster, giving the Jays value on both sides of the ball at a time when the club is trying to figure out how to get back into contention.
Pillar later clarified that he was not specifically calling for Toronto to move Kirk, and that distinction matters. Kirks appeal is obvious enough already, especially with the Blue Jays needing upgrades elsewhere, from the pitching staff to more from Vladimir Guerrero Jr. if the lineup is going to carry them forward. The bigger question is whether Toronto sees Kirk as part of the solution long term or as the kind of asset rival teams would surely love to pry loose. [Read more 🡒]