The Blue Jays need offense, and Kevin Pillar thinks Toronto would be making a mistake if it let Luis Arraez slip by.
Pillar, the former Blue Jays fan favorite, made the case that Arraez belongs in Toronto’s lineup next season, pointing to the way the infielder handles elite pitching and grinds through every at-bat.
“Whether Luis Arraez is getting on base or not, you know what you're gonna get every single time. He’s going to grind out at-bats, he’s gonna be tough … It doesn’t matter who he’s facing, he hits elite pitching … It’ll be foolish to not want a guy like that in your lineup,” Pillar explained on Blue Bird Territory.
He also said that in a setting like the postseason, when the best arms are on the mound, Arraez is exactly the kind of hitter you want stepping in.
That profile is easy to see. Arraez has won three batting titles and led the National League in hits twice, even though his power has never been his calling card. He has reached double-digit home runs only once in his career, when he hit 10 for the Miami Marlins in 2023.
Still, the bat plays. Last season, the 29-year-old turned in another All-Star year, hitting .310 with a .765 OPS. Across 151 games split between the Giants and Phillies, he scored 67 runs, added 33 doubles, seven triples, six home runs, drove in 64 and stole 10 bases.
He also kept doing what he’s known for: making pitchers work. Arraez walked 34 times and struck out just 28 times last season, a rare combination that makes him one of the toughest outs in the sport.
Over his career, he has hit .316 with a .775 OPS and has struck out only 243 times in more than 3,840 at-bats. That kind of contact ability would fit neatly near the top of Toronto’s order, where he could help set the table for the club’s power bats.
There’s more to his game than the bat, too. FanGraphs rated Arraez at +12 Outs Above Average and +10 Fielding Run Value at second base last season. He can also handle first base and third base if needed.
Toronto’s free-agent buzz has centered on power hitters, with names like Seiya Suzuki, Randy Arozarena and Teruaki Sato drawing the most attention. But Pillar’s point is simple: the Blue Jays should not overlook one of the best pure hitters available.
In Other News...
Blue Jays May Have Found Their Best Rotation Upgrade This Winter
Michael Kings name has quickly moved into the conversation for clubs looking to bolster the top of their rotation this winter, and Toronto fits that group as well as anyone. After opting out of his Padres deal on Oct. 29, the right-hander is suddenly one of the more intriguing starters on the market, coming off a season in which he gave San Diego a heavy workload and steady results over 185 innings with a 3.21 ERA and 1.18 WHIP.
For the Blue Jays, the appeal is obvious: they need pitching help, and King offers the kind of track record that can change the look of a staff. There has been no official signing or offer reported, but the fit is easy to see, which is why his market figures to stay worth watching as the offseason unfolds. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Fans May Need To Let Go Of These Reunions
A familiar trio surfaced in Jim Bowdens early look at the 2026-27 free-agent class, with former Blue Jays Kevin Gausman, Shane Bieber and Daulton Varsho all landing on his list of top names. For Toronto fans, it is the kind of reminder that the roster churn never really stops, especially when players who once mattered in the clubhouse and in the standings start popping up in future market projections.
The Blue Jays have reason to keep an eye on all three, but the fit is not as simple as nostalgia might suggest. Recent performance and injury history are part of the equation for each player, and Bowdens read points in directions that could make those reunions harder to imagine than some fans would like, leaving Toronto to weigh memory against the realities of what comes next. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Suddenly Have A Bullpen Opportunity Worth Watching
A late-opening bullpen market just gave the Blue Jays something to monitor as they look for ways to deepen an already solid relief corps. Emilio Pagan is headed into free agency after declining his one-year player option with Cincinnati, and his name now sits near the top of the available relievers after a strong finish to the season.
For Toronto, the fit is obvious enough to keep in mind: the club already has a bullpen anchored by Louis Varland, but there is still room to add a right-handed setup arm who can handle high-leverage innings. Pagans second half made him one of the more interesting options on the board, and the question now is whether the Blue Jays decide to get involved before the market tightens further. [Read more 🡒]