Blue Jays Make One Urgent Lineup Call With Wild Card Hopes Alive

With a crucial game against the San Diego Padres and struggling pitcher Walker Buehler, the Blue Jays aim to capitalize on power hitting and strategic lineup choices as they continue their push for a playoff spot.

The Blue Jays have a chance to keep rolling Saturday night in San Diego, and they’re doing it with a lineup built to pressure Walker Buehler from the jump.

Toronto enters the game at 45-49 after taking a series from the San Francisco Giants, and a win over the Padres would give the club back-to-back series victories. The bigger picture still leaves plenty of ground to cover, but the Blue Jays are at least giving themselves a shot.

FanGraphs gives Toronto a 31.1% chance to reach the playoffs, with the clearest route coming through the American League Wild Card, where the team sits at 30.1%. Their odds of winning the AL East are just 1.1%, which leaves them fourth in the division.

On the mound for Toronto is right-hander Trey Yesavage, who has been especially sharp away from home. His road ERA sits at 2.36, and he’ll also be looking to bounce back after taking a loss against the Seattle Mariners in that ALCS rematch just over a week ago.

John Schneider’s starting nine puts Ernie Clement at second base and Nathan Lukes in right field at the top of the order, followed by Vladimir Guerrero Jr. at first base and George Springer as the designated hitter. Kazuma Okamoto hits fifth at third base, with Dalton Varsho in center field, Alejandro Kirk behind the plate, Andres Gimenez at shortstop and Jonathan Clase in left.

The matchup lines up well for Toronto’s power bats. Buehler has struggled for San Diego in 2026, carrying a 5.07 ERA overall and a 4.06 ERA at Petco Park. He’s also given up five home runs in two starts this month, which could matter against a Blue Jays lineup that has some real pop in the middle.

Okamoto has been Toronto’s biggest home run threat this season, and he’s done even more damage on the road, where he has 12 homers - two more than he’s hit at Rogers Centre.

Guerrero is still searching for a bigger July. He’s batting just over .200 this month and has one home run, though he does bring a three-game hitting streak into Saturday’s game.

In Other News...

Blue Jays Make Sudden Pitching Call That Fans Have Waited Years For

CJ Van Eyks steady work at Triple-A Buffalo finally earned him a long-awaited look with the Blue Jays, as Toronto promoted the right-hander to the 26-man roster ahead of its July 12 game against the Padres. The move gives the club another arm in relief and rewards a pitcher who has been trending in the right direction for Buffalo, where he has been one of the more dependable starters in the system.

For Van Eyk, the call-up is especially meaningful because it puts him on the active roster for the first time in his Blue Jays career. Toronto cleared the spot by optioning Chad Dallas to Triple-A, and now the focus shifts to whether Van Eyk gets into the game and what kind of role the club has in mind for him as the bullpen gets an added option. [Read more 🡒]

Blue Jays May Have Found A Catching Value Fans Should Watch

The Blue Jays kept adding to the catching pipeline in the 2026 MLB draft, and one of the more interesting names to come out of it was an 18-year-old prep backstop from Christian Brothers High School in Tennessee. Toronto used its fourth-round pick on a player viewed as one of the better defensive catchers in the high school class, the kind of selection that says as much about long-term planning as it does about immediate need.

What makes the pick worth watching is the blend of traits: strong receiving skills, above-average arm strength and enough offensive upside to make him more than a glove-only bet. The Blue Jays have already been building depth at the position through other prospects and a trade acquisition, so this was less about filling an empty cupboard than giving the organization another catcher with a real chance to develop into something useful. [Read more 🡒]

Blue Jays Double Down On Pitching With Intriguing Day 2 Pick

The Blue Jays kept leaning into pitching on Day 2 of the 2026 MLB Draft, adding another arm in Nolan Higgins out of Michigan State. The 22-year-old right-hander brings some of the traits Toronto tends to value in this part of the draft, with strikeout ability and the kind of experience that comes from working both as a starter and out of the bullpen in college.

Higgins gives the organization another development project with some flexibility attached, since the Blue Jays have said they can try to build him up as a starter or use him as a relief option. For a club that has already taken two pitchers in the draft, it is another sign that Toronto is stockpiling arms and leaving itself room to sort out roles later, which is often where the real intrigue begins. [Read more 🡒]