The Blue Jays are rolling into their three-game set with the Cleveland Guardians with a different look on the mound Tuesday, and Spencer Miles will be the one setting the tone.
Toronto has chosen the right-hander to open the series opener, with Spencer Arrighetti expected to come in afterward and cover the bulk of the innings. It’s a clear nod to the way Miles has handled his role this season, and the Blue Jays are leaning into that reliability again.
Miles has been one of the more steady pieces in Toronto’s staff since the club grabbed him in the Rule 5 Draft last December out of the San Francisco Giants organization. He’s made 42 appearances this season, putting together a 5-2 record with a 2.92 ERA and one save over 83.1 innings. That kind of production has made him a trusted arm for a team that has had to juggle both the rotation and the bullpen.
His most recent outing in an opener role came last week against the Kansas City Royals, and it went exactly the way Toronto wanted. Miles worked two scoreless innings, gave up only two hits, and helped the Blue Jays finish off a 3-0 shutout win. That performance almost certainly strengthened the case for giving him the ball in the same role against Cleveland.
Arrighetti, meanwhile, is still trying to find his footing with Toronto. Acquired in the trade involving Daulton Varsho and the Houston Astros, the right-hander has had a rough start since joining the Blue Jays. In 7.1 innings, he owns a 7.36 ERA, has allowed six earned runs, and struck out eight.
The hope is that coming in behind Miles will let Arrighetti settle in without the immediate burden of starting the game from the first pitch. For Toronto, the setup is simple: get the early edge with a pitcher who has been getting the job done, then give Arrighetti a chance to build some confidence as the game unfolds.
In Other News...
Blue Jays Roster Shift Puts September Upgrades In Focus
The Blue Jays made a quiet roster move before September, optioning pitcher CJ Van Eyk to Triple-A Buffalo without announcing a corresponding move. Van Eyks minor league season had been solid, but his brief major league looks never really translated into much impact, and the decision opens the door for Toronto to start reshaping its roster as the calendar turns.
September is when the depth chart gets interesting, and the Blue Jays are expected to add three players to their 28-man group. Ricky Tiedemann and prospect Sean Keys are among the names in the conversation, giving the club a chance to reward development while also adding some late-season energy to a roster still sorting out its priorities. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Suddenly Have A Bigger Spencer Arrighetti Problem
Spencer Arrighetti looked like he might be settling in after a strong opening run with the Astros, but the right-handers season has taken a sharp turn since late May. The home runs have piled up, the fastball has lost some of its edge, and the result has been a pitcher who is no longer giving Houston the kind of stability it expected when he first flashed promise earlier in the year.
For the Blue Jays, the concern is less about one bad outing than a growing pattern that has made Arrighetti a tougher assignment than he seemed a few weeks ago. Most of the damage has come against his fastball, which puts the focus on how effectively he can make the pitch work again, and whether Houston can help him get back to the version of himself that looked so much more dependable before the slide. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Face A Tough Myles Straw Decision This Offseason
Myles Straw has given the Blue Jays what they expected on the defensive side, but his fit in Toronto is still going to be judged on more than glove work alone. As the 2026 season winds down, the front office has a decision coming on an $8 million club option for 2027, and Straws uneven offense has made it one of the more interesting calls on the clubs offseason docket.
Toronto does not need to decide immediately, and that matters. The team plans to keep evaluating Straw through the end of the season before settling on the option, which gives him a little more time to strengthen his case. For a club weighing roster value and payroll flexibility at the same time, the final weeks could go a long way toward shaping what Straws future looks like in blue and white. [Read more 🡒]