The Toronto Blue Jays came heartbreakingly close to a World Series title last season-just one win away from the crown. But instead of hoisting the trophy, they watched the Los Angeles Dodgers go back-to-back for the first time in over 20 years.
Now, with the sting of that near-miss still fresh, Toronto is wasting no time trying to get over the hump. And they’re swinging big.
One of the biggest names on the free agent market, Kyle Tucker, has already visited the Blue Jays’ facilities in Dunedin. That’s not just a casual meet-and-greet-it's a clear signal the Jays are serious about adding another elite bat to their lineup. Tucker, a consistent offensive force with Gold Glove-caliber defense in the outfield, would be a major get for a team that’s already knocking on the door of a championship.
According to reports, the Blue Jays still have their eyes on re-signing Bo Bichette as well. That’s where things get tricky.
Bichette’s situation is one of the most intriguing storylines of the offseason. He’s been a cornerstone of this Blue Jays core-a homegrown star with a bat that plays and a swagger that fans have rallied behind.
But his future hinges on how teams view his defense at shortstop. If front offices believe he can stick at the position long-term, then his market value skyrockets.
Think something in the neighborhood of Willy Adames’ seven-year, $182 million deal with the Giants. Bichette, being younger and with inflation in play, could fetch even more-potentially seven years, $189 million.
That’s a hefty investment. And while the Blue Jays certainly have the resources to make big moves, insiders are skeptical they’ll be able to land both Tucker and Bichette this winter. MLB insider Mark Feinsand put it bluntly: “The only thing that I don't see is Toronto getting Tucker and Bichette.”
That’s not to say they won’t get one of them-just that pulling off both might be a stretch. And that puts the front office in a tough spot.
Do you go all-in on the top free agent available in Tucker, a player who could elevate your outfield and batting order immediately? Or do you double down on the guy who’s been with you from the start, who knows the clubhouse, the city, and the weight of wearing that Blue Jays uniform?
It’s a decision that could shape the franchise for years. Tucker brings proven production and postseason experience. Bichette brings continuity and a fanbase that’s grown up with him.
One thing’s for sure: the Blue Jays aren’t standing still. After coming so close to the mountaintop, they’re pushing hard to get back-and this offseason could be the moment that defines their next championship run.