The Blue Jays left Sunday’s game with the series win, but they also left Rogers Centre with another fresh grievance against José Caballero.
Caballero, already a lightning rod in this rivalry, found himself in the middle of a controversial ninth-inning play during Toronto’s 10-inning loss to the Yankees on Aug. 17. With one out and Blue Jays infielder Josh Smith standing at third as the tying run, Ernie Clement sent a fly ball to center field that looked deep enough to bring Smith home.
On the play, Caballero appeared to position himself in a way that blocked Smith’s view of the ball’s flight, seemingly trying to disrupt his tag-up timing. The play was not called that way in real time, but the reaction online was immediate.
“This is actually obstruction and it should have been called on Caballero. You cannot obstruct the view of the catch from the runner like this. It didn’t matter as he scored anyway, but this is obstruction and has been called before.
Last year Max Muncy was called for the exact… https://t.co/H06UTCOON8
- MLB Scoring Changes (@ScoringChanges) August 18, 2026”
Smith still scored, so the moment didn’t change the result of the play. Even so, it gave Toronto fans another reason to be annoyed with a Yankees infielder who has already rubbed them the wrong way this season.
Caballero’s name has been tied to controversy before in this matchup, including earlier this year when his timing in the batter’s box stirred up a big reaction in a game between the clubs. This latest moment added to a long list of bad feelings in a rivalry that has only grown sharper in recent years.
The Blue Jays did take the weekend series from New York and cut into the playoff chase a bit, but the loss Sunday kept the tone sour. And with Toronto heading to New York for another weekend set, the temperature between these two teams looks ready to rise again.
In Other News...
Kevin Gausman's Early Exit Just Put New Focus On Blue Jays Trade
Kevin Gausmans outing at Wrigley Field ended earlier than anyone expected, and for Blue Jays fans the sight carried a little extra weight because it came so soon after the right-hander was moved from Toronto to the Cubs at the 2026 trade deadline. The trade already gave the Blue Jays a fresh point of evaluation on their side of the deal, but seeing Gausman forced out of a start in a new uniform quickly turned attention from the transaction itself to the kind of condition that can shape how a pitcher looks over the rest of a season.
Gausman later said the issue was a cramp in his left hand, the non-throwing one, and noted he has dealt with it before. What made this trip to the mound stand out was how early it arrived, cutting into the rhythm of a start before it could really settle into place. For Toronto, the immediate takeaway is less about one outing than about how a familiar arm now fits into the aftermath of a deadline move that is already being watched closely. [Read more 🡒]
Alejandro Kirk Is Giving The Blue Jays A Lift They Desperately Need
Alejandro Kirk has been one of the more important reasons the Blue Jays have kept their recent winning streak rolling, and the timing could hardly be better. After returning from a thumb injury, he has provided a noticeable lift with the bat while splitting time between catcher and designated hitter, giving Toronto a steadier presence in the middle of the lineup at a point when every productive at-bat matters.
For a team still trying to claw its way into the playoff picture, Kirks resurgence carries real weight beyond a hot stretch at the plate. The Blue Jays have needed dependable offense from players who can handle pressure and stay available, and Kirk has checked both boxes lately, adding another layer of optimism as the season tightens and the margin for error shrinks. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Missed Ketel Marte Chance Suddenly Looks A Lot Better
The Blue Jays reported interest in Ketel Marte now carries a different kind of weight after the Diamondbacks put the infielder on the restricted list following his absence from a game against the Red Sox. Toronto was known to be in the mix when Martes name surfaced in trade conversation, but nothing ever got across the finish line, leaving the club to watch the situation from the outside.
Marte is expected to return to Phoenix for an MRI on his knee, and the uncertainty around when and where the injury happened only adds to the intrigue. For a Blue Jays team that had already wondered what it might have cost to land him, the latest twist makes the missed opportunity look a lot more complicated than it did even a few days ago. [Read more 🡒]