The Toronto Blue Jays are under fire from fans after posting a sponsored social media video this week that many viewers believe was made with AI.
The clip, a collaboration with Nestea titled “Spill the Tea,” showed animated versions of several players swapping stories about their days off. In one segment, an animated Ernie Clement talks about teammates heading on a fishing trip in Florida last season. In another, Mason Fluharty recalls a day off when he and Trey Yesavage stopped by a sports card shop in Toronto.
On the surface, it was the kind of light, harmless content teams usually lean on for a quick fan-friendly hit. Instead, it set off a wave of criticism almost immediately after it was posted on Wednesday.
“Why is my team posting AI, WTF?” one fan wrote.
The Blue Jays pushed back hard, saying the video was “not AI,” but a “human-animated video.”
“Corny. Rogers can't afford real animation?” another fan wrote.
“Corny comment. This was made by a real animator,” the Blue Jays replied, doubling down.
Even so, skepticism kept growing as the video climbed to nearly two million views. X attached a community note to the post saying the clip was “entirely” AI-generated, despite the team’s denial. The note pointed to what it described as visible AI artifacts, including issues in the characters’ mouths and eyes, along with garbled background text.
“At basically any timestamp in this video, you can pause and see AI artifacts in both the mouth and eyes on the characters, or garbled text in the background,” the community note read.
blogTO also reached out to the Blue Jays for comment on the allegations.
To get another read on it, blogTO consulted an expert from a Toronto-based AI consulting firm. That expert said the video does not look like it was made by an animator, contrary to the team’s claim.
“The players' faces warp between frames, and there is gibberish background text all throughout the video,” the expert said.
In Other News...
Davis Schneiders Blue Jays Future Suddenly Looks Far Less Secure
Davis Schneiders path with the Blue Jays has been trending in the wrong direction for a while now, and this season only sharpened the concern. After flashes that once made him look like a possible part of Torontos long-term picture, his playing time has shrunk and his offense has slipped over the past three years, leaving him with far less margin for error than he had when he first broke through.
In 2026, Schneider spent time back at Triple-A with the Buffalo Bisons, and when September came around, Toronto looked elsewhere for its call-ups. The fact that other players got those promotions instead says plenty about where he stands in the organization right now, with competition for roster spots making his future with the Blue Jays feel more uncertain than ever. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Suddenly Have A Late-Season Injury Question That Matters
The Blue Jays have reached the point in the season where even the rehab updates matter, and the latest ones are at least giving the club some hope. Jameson Taillon is expected back soon after a forearm injury, Trey Yesavage has advanced to throwing off a mound after knee surgery, and Shane Bieber is already back to playing catch while working through shoulder inflammation. Those are the kinds of checkpoints Toronto has been waiting for as it tries to keep the roster stable through the stretch run.
Anthony Santander is the most interesting name in the mix right now. He has moved to hitting off live pitching and could begin a rehab assignment in Triple-A Buffalo next week, which would be a meaningful step in his comeback. The bigger question is whether there is still enough runway left for him to help the Blue Jays at the major league level this season, and that uncertainty makes his progress worth following closely. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Just Took A Risk Fans Will Be Watching Closely
Simeon Woods Richardsons stint in Toronto ended the way so many roster gambles do, with the Blue Jays moving on after a rough outing and the pitcher heading into uncertain territory. The right-hander, who was acquired from the Minnesota Twins in a June trade, was designated for assignment after his poor performance and quickly found a new landing spot, signing a minor league deal with the Seattle Mariners.
Woods Richardson had the option to return to the Blue Jays organization but chose free agency instead, a decision that makes the original trade haul look a little less secure for Toronto in the short term. For a club that is always trying to balance present-day pitching depth with future value, his departure is the kind of move fans will keep in mind if the rotation or bullpen starts looking thin later on. [Read more 🡒]