The Blue Jays don’t have a rotation problem at the top. They have a depth problem staring them down beyond 2026, and that’s where the offseason gets tricky.
Dylan Cease gives Toronto a true ace after one of the best seasons of his career. Trey Yesavage is still just 23 and loaded with upside.
José Soriano, the trade deadline addition, rounds out a “Big 3” that looks plenty sturdy for now. But injuries kept hammering the staff, and with Shane Bieber, Max Scherzer, Patrick Corbin, and Jameson Taillon all heading toward free agency, the back end suddenly feels a lot thinner.
That leaves the Blue Jays with a decision that could define how they spend this winter: if they can only bring back one starter, do they go with Bieber or circle back to Kevin Gausman?
There’s an obvious emotional pull toward Gausman. He remains a familiar name in Toronto, and the memory of last year’s World Series run still lingers. His work on the mound during that postseason push is the kind of thing fans won’t forget anytime soon.
The numbers and the season behind them, though, make the picture less romantic. Gausman did not deliver the same postseason impact this year, allowing just one middling start with the Cubs before they were swept by the Padres in the Wild Card Round. He also looked a step slower in 2026 after a stronger 2025, even if Baseball Savant’s percentile rankings painted more or less the same picture overall.
Age matters here, too. Gausman will turn 36 in January, so expecting him to function like a No. 1 starter no longer makes much sense.
Toronto doesn’t need that anyway with Cease at the top. What it does need is someone who can take the ball, cover innings, and handle big spots - and Gausman still checks those boxes.
Bieber brings a different kind of appeal. He’s younger, since he won’t turn 32 until May, and he offers more upside if you’re betting on a rebound. The downside is just as clear: he’s been far more injury prone, and since joining the Blue Jays at the 2025 trade deadline, he has posted a 4.03 ERA with a 4.87 FIP.
His contact-quality numbers were rough this season, but there’s still some life in the arsenal. Every pitch in his mix except the four-seam fastball produced more run value than Gausman’s comparable offerings.
If this were only about talent in a vacuum, the answer wouldn’t come easy. Gausman is the steadier, playoff-tested veteran with the fan base behind him. Bieber is the former Cy Young winner with more age on his side and more uncertainty attached.
But Toronto’s current need points toward reliability, not volatility. If the Blue Jays are choosing just one reunion, Gausman’s profile - and the fact that he has logged at least 170 innings in six straight seasons - gives him the stronger case.
In Other News...
Blue Jays Still Waiting On The Most Important Draft Debut
The Blue Jays have already gotten an early look at several players from their 2026 draft class, with Ryan Cooney, Nolan Higgins, Gable Mitchell and Dean West all stepping into pro ball and giving the organization a first read on where they stand. For Toronto, that first wave matters because the club has been careful about development, watching early performances closely while easing workloads rather than rushing anyone through the system.
Cole Carlon, though, remains the draft pick everyone is still waiting to see. Toronto took him at the top of the class, but he never appeared in a game after the draft, leaving his introduction to pro baseball for later on the timeline as the Blue Jays continue to sort through a crop of young talent that is already starting to take shape. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Face Early Offseason Questions Around Several Veteran Names
The Blue Jays are already staring at a winter filled with veteran decision-making, with a number of familiar names potentially heading for free agency after the World Series. George Springer is among the biggest questions on the board, and the broader list also includes arms and position players whose recent production, contract status and age all make this a complicated offseason to sort through.
Toronto has spent enough time leaning on experienced talent to know how quickly those choices can reshape a roster, and this market could test how much interest there is in bringing some of those players back. The possibilities stretch well beyond Springer, with Jose Berrios, Max Scherzer, Shane Bieber and others all part of the uncertainty, leaving the Jays to weigh whether any of these veterans fit into the next step or whether they will be moving on to chase new deals elsewhere. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Fans Will Hate How This World Series Collapse Unfolded
A familiar kind of October sting is starting to creep back into the conversation for Blue Jays fans. In Game 4 of the 2026 World Series, Milwaukee Brewers reliever Shane Drohan could not close out the final outs, and the Tampa Bay Rays rallied to force a Game 5, the sort of late collapse that can leave a fan base reliving old wounds long after the final pitch.
The parallel is hard to miss for Toronto supporters, who saw a championship path slip away in painfully similar fashion last year. The Brewers still get another shot to finish the job, which is the part Blue Jays fans will notice most, since Toronto did not have that luxury after its own Game 7 heartbreak. [Read more 🡒]