The Blue Jays’ bullpen is headed into another round of decisions, and the shape of that relief mix may matter just as much as any rotation comeback.
Toronto got 52 saves in the 2026 season, and 35 of them belonged to Louis Varland. That alone tells you where the late-inning weight sat. Tyler Rogers was the other piece at the back end, but the path to those final two innings was anything but smooth.
Varland’s rise didn’t even start right away. He didn’t take over closing duties until late April, after Jeff Hoffman’s uneven stretch led to his trade to the Minnesota Twins at the trade deadline.
From there, Varland took off. He finished the season with a 1.27 ERA, the best mark in the league among qualified relievers, and his 3.1 fWAR ranked second among all qualified relievers behind only San Diego Padres closer Mason Miller, who posted 3.7.
The contrast with the rest of the bullpen was stark. Toronto’s relievers combined for 4.8 fWAR overall, but without Varland, the other 32 pitchers who logged a total of 535 innings managed only 1.7 fWAR.
Spencer Miles, at 1.5 fWAR, and Rogers, at 1.1, were the other steady presences. Mason Fluharty also carved out a big role, leading the club with 79 relief appearances, which ranked second in the entire league behind New York Yankees left-hander Brent Headrick’s 81.
Beyond that core, Toronto spent the year cycling through options, and most of them simply didn’t work. Simeon Woods Richardson (-0.1 fWAR), Paul Sewald (0.1), Spencer Arrighetti (-0.3), Michael Lorenzen (-0.3), Patrick Corbin (-0.1), and Yariel Rodriguez (-0.2) all got looks. It is unlikely all of them will get another one.
Woods Richardson was designated for assignment on August 28. Lorenzen was also designated for assignment in September, rejected an assignment to the minors, and became a free agent. Rodriguez never recovered and was designated for assignment in June.
That leaves Corbin and Sewald as the most interesting holdovers to sort through. Corbin, 37, opened the year in the rotation before landing on the injured list with a left teres major strain. Sewald, 36, arrived after losing his job with the Arizona Diamondbacks and posted a 0.63 ERA in 17 appearances with Toronto, though questions remain about what he can still give a club going forward.
Both are set to become free agents at the end of the season, and both could be looking at limited markets. Corbin’s injury history and Sewald’s drop to minus-0.5 fWAR in 2026, even after recording 24 saves for Arizona, make that clear.
If Toronto stays true to the way it has tried to mine value from veterans, both could get a modest offer to come back, likely on a minor league deal. Corbin, in particular, still has a lane as a bullpen arm because of what he can do against left-handed hitters. In 2026, he allowed just one home run and a .650 OPS against lefties, while his 5.0 K/BB rate against them dropped to 1.9 against righties.
The contact profile was just as notable. Left-handed hitters produced 9.8% less contact against Corbin’s pitches in the strike zone than right-handed hitters did.
The sample was only 99 batters faced, but Corbin still posted the best xFIP among Toronto’s left-handed pitchers against same-handed hitters last season at 2.90. Joe Mantiply followed at 3.11 over 54 batters faced, then Brendon Little at 3.44 over 62, and Mason Fluharty at 3.75 over 138.
In Other News...
Vladdys Next Step Could Decide How Real This Blue Jays Rebound Is
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. took a notable offseason step with laser eye surgery, a move that naturally invites a fresh round of curiosity about what it might mean for the Blue Jays at the plate. A 2025 Society of American Baseball Research study looked at the broader effect of LASIK on major league hitters and found a positive trend, though not one that showed up as statistically significant, with most players not quite getting back to the level they had been two years before surgery.
For Toronto, the more interesting question is whether Guerreros recent struggles were ever going to be solved by vision alone. The full picture around his dip has included other possible contributors, from a bad back to anxiety and depression, and the details of his procedure and pre-surgery eyesight have not been disclosed. So even as the surgery adds a compelling new layer to his reset, it remains only one part of a much bigger rebound storyline for a player whose next step could tell a lot about how real this Blue Jays push really is. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Face A Tough Bieber Decision This Offseason
Shane Bieber gave the Blue Jays a late-season reminder of why he remains such a complicated offseason case. After dealing with health setbacks and limited innings over the past three seasons, he settled in enough down the stretch of 2023 to leave Toronto with a meaningful sample to consider, and that matters because his next stop could come on the open market shortly after the World Series.
Bieber has said he would like to return, and the Blue Jays appear at least open to exploring it, especially if the price reflects the risk that comes with his recent track record. General manager Ross Atkins said the club will work through its process before deciding, which leaves Toronto in the familiar spot of weighing upside against uncertainty as it tries to sort out whether Bieber fits as a reunion candidate this winter. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Face An Uncomfortable Jazz Chisholm Decision This Offseason
The Yankees season ended in an ugly sweep at the hands of the Rays, and Jazz Chisholm Jr. was left with an awkward finish after a rocky postseason that saw him struggle at the plate and in the field. An All-Star just a year earlier, he was even left out of the starting lineup for some playoff games, a reminder of how quickly October can change the conversation around a player who looked like a centerpiece only months before.
Chisholm has said he wants to stay in New York, but his offseason still carries real uncertainty, and that has opened the door to a possible move elsewhere if the Yankees and the infielder go their separate ways. From Torontos perspective, that is at least worth monitoring as the club looks for ways to add more impact to its lineup, leaving the Blue Jays in position to watch a situation that could end up reshaping one of the divisions more intriguing winter markets. [Read more 🡒]