The Blue Jays’ offseason already has a few obvious priorities, but the bigger question may be what they do with two familiar veterans who’ve meant plenty to the club: George Springer and Max Scherzer.
Toronto was officially knocked out of playoff contention by the Baltimore Orioles earlier this week, and now the attention shifts to how the team gets back to World Series level. That means addressing a rotation that ran out of healthy arms and an offense that spent too much time chasing pitches out of the zone.
The pitching situation is stark. The Blue Jays entered the season with plenty of starting depth, but they finished with only one truly healthy starter, and that pitcher, José Soriano, didn’t even begin the year in Toronto. The club will need durable starters, whether that comes through free agency or a trade.
The lineup has its own problem. According to FanGraphs, the Blue Jays have the third highest chase rate and the highest contact rate on chase pitches.
Ernie Clement and Andrés Giménez both sit in the second percentile in chase rate, per Baseball Savant. If Toronto wants a cleaner offensive profile next summer, it has to find hitters who swing at fewer pitches outside the zone.
That brings the conversation back to Springer.
George Springer
Springer’s six-year, $150 million deal from the 2021 offseason was worth it. His regular-season production has bounced around, with three years above average and three years that were average or worse, but he has repeatedly delivered in the biggest spots.
Before he joined the Blue Jays, Springer had already built a reputation as a postseason force. He added to that in Game 7 of the 2025 ALCS, when he hit the go-ahead home run that sent Toronto to the World Series. His 23 career playoff home runs rank third all time.
The Blue Jays themselves highlighted that moment with the message: “George Springer: BIG TIME PLAYER #SpringerDinger pic.twitter.com/pnkTKB7OOA”
But the current version of Springer looks much closer to the 2023-2024 player than the one who turned in a surprise 2025 career year. In 2026, he is hitting .251/.323/.407 with a 107 wRC+. His batted-ball numbers and contact quality have slipped.
At 37, and with decline showing in three of the last four seasons, bringing him back for another year would be a hard case to make. Defensively, the issues are even clearer. Springer was a liability in the outfield last season, posting -6 OAA in 67 games, and he has since moved to DH.
That matters because the Blue Jays already have other players who may need those DH at-bats. Assuming baseball starts on schedule in 2027, Barger will need DH time early while recovering from Tommy John surgery. Santander also hasn’t graded as a positive defender since 2020, when he was at +1 OAA, so Toronto would prefer to use him at DH once Barger is healthy.
The verdict on Springer is straightforward: as valuable as he has been, the Blue Jays are better off moving on. They already have internal options who can fill DH roles and let them cycle bats through the lineup.
Max Scherzer
Scherzer’s case is different, but it lands in a similar place.
He joined Toronto in 2025 and brought value well beyond the box score. Even though his regular-season results weren’t strong, he gave the Blue Jays a veteran presence and showed up in key moments. In Game 4 of the ALCS, he went 5.2 innings, allowed two earned runs, struck out five, and helped even the series against Seattle at 2-2.
The Blue Jays signed him late in February, and injuries to his arm and back limited him again. He appeared in 17 games this season and finished with a 6.14 ERA and a 1.36 WHIP. At 42, expecting anything close to peak Scherzer is no longer realistic.
Still, his value to the pitching staff is obvious. With 19 major league seasons behind him, Scherzer brings a depth of experience and knowledge that matters in a clubhouse and on a staff.
If he comes back for a 20th season, the role would probably have to change. A bullpen assignment would make more sense, especially since he hasn’t relieved since 2008. His body has simply not held up; he has appeared in just 43 games since 2024, and when healthy, he has still posted a 5.29 ERA.
Scherzer remains ninth all time in strikeouts, four behind Justin Verlander and 24 behind Don Sutton. For Toronto, though, the issue is not legacy.
It’s reliability. He is hard to trust as a starter, and if he wants to keep starting, it would likely need to be somewhere other than Toronto.
A coaching role, though, should remain on the table.
In Other News...
Brett Bateman Just Gave The Blue Jays A Tough Offseason Call
Brett Batemans arrival gave the Blue Jays something they had been looking for in the outfield: a center fielder who looked comfortable right away. Acquired from the Cubs, he reached the majors on August 7 and, over 172 plate appearances, showed enough at the plate and in the field to become part of the everyday conversation almost immediately. By August 14, he was batting leadoff, a clear sign the club trusted him in a premium spot and saw more than just a short-term spark.
Now Toronto has to weigh what Batemans start really means for the offseason plan in center field. The performance was strong, but the sample is still small, and the right hip injury he suffered on September 21 adds another layer to the decision-making. The Blue Jays have seen enough to consider him a real option, but not enough to assume the job is settled. [Read more 🡒]
Vladdy's Blue Jays Comments Sparked A Debate Fans Can't Ignore
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. found himself in an awkward spotlight after saying he feels pressure following his 14-year contract extension with the Blue Jays, especially because he views the deal as payment for what he has already accomplished rather than what comes next. It was the kind of remark that can linger in Toronto, where every word from a franchise cornerstone gets parsed, and it did not take long for fans to push back and for former players Vernon Wells and Joey Votto to weigh in with their own takes on the situation.
Guerrero later revisited the controversy and stood by his feelings, but the conversation did not fade there. He also added another layer to the debate with cryptic posts on social media, leaving the impression that the noise around his comments is still far from settled and that this is now about more than one quote. [Read more 🡒]
George Springer Just Turned Torontos Final Weekend Into A Farewell Watch
The Blue Jays doubleheader loss to the Orioles not only ended Torontos postseason hopes, it also shifted the spotlight to George Springer as the season winds down. With the club officially out of the race and Springer in the final year of his contract, every remaining game now carries a little more weight, especially for a veteran who has spent the year reflecting on what his time in Toronto has meant.
Springer did not commit to whether he will retire after the season, saying he will sort through his options once the offseason arrives. For now, he has centered his remarks on gratitude, both for the organization and for the fans who have followed him through his run with the Blue Jays, leaving the final weekend to feel less like a cleanup lap and more like a possible farewell watch. [Read more 🡒]