Blue Jays Face A Risky Jazz Chisholm Decision This Winter

As top free agent Jazz Chisholm Jr. navigates mixed evaluations, the Toronto Blue Jays consider adding his dynamic skills to their roster.

Jazz Chisholm Jr. sits in a tricky spot on the free-agent board, and the gap between evaluators says plenty. FanGraphs has him seventh, while Keith Law slots him 25th, a spread that reflects just how hard he is to pin down.

The 28-year-old infielder, who turns 29 in February, spent last season at second base for the Yankees. He’s now been in the majors for seven seasons, with four and a half in Miami and two and a half in New York.

The appeal is obvious: Chisholm brings power, speed and the kind of defensive versatility teams covet. He has logged time at second, third and in the outfield, and that matters for a Blue Jays club that has been talking to him or his agent.

Toronto wants more power, likes players who can move around the diamond, and has been exploring an upgrade from Ernie Clement at second while also keeping an eye on corner outfield help.

The production has swung from strong to merely solid over the last two seasons. In 2025, Chisholm posted a .242/.332/.481 line with 31 home runs, 58 walks, 148 strikeouts and a 4.1 bWAR. This past season, he dropped to .231/.312/.399 with 19 home runs and a 1.7 bWAR.

Law’s read is blunt about the inconsistency. “Chisholm is a maddening player to watch, despite his energy and enthusiasm for the game, because he could be a much better player if he had any semblance of an approach at the plate.

He doesn’t hit lefties at all, and even against righties he doesn’t get on base or put the ball in play enough. He doesn’t swing enough at strikes, and he doesn’t make enough contact on strikes when he does swing (79.8 percent, in the bottom 10 among qualifiers, although there are good hitters below him).

His value in 2026 was much more driven by his plus range at second base than by his bat; his slugging percentage of .399 was a career worst, and it was .381 away from Yankee Stadium. He’s athletically and physically gifted enough to be better than this, and he does do enough things well to hope there’s still another leap ahead of him.

He might get multi-year offers, given his age, but he should look for a one-year deal in the $20 million range to try to have a better season and return to free agency next winter for his age-30 season.”

Ben Clemens sees the upside too, but he’s just as aware of the risk. “I waffled more on this projection than any other.

Chisholm’s blend of speed and power is droolworthy; up-the-middle defenders with 30-homer power don’t grow on trees. But you can do the same kind of forecasting to the downside, too.”

Clemens thinks Chisholm may prefer a shorter-term path back into the market. “I imagine Chisholm will want to bet on himself, and to me that means a shorter deal with the possibility of hitting the market again, probably via an opt-out, or perhaps by taking fewer years while peppering in escalators and incentives.”

The projection from Clemens is four years and $23 million per season, for a total of $92 million. Still, both evaluators point to the same possibility: Chisholm could choose a shorter contract and try to rebuild his value before testing free agency again.

In Other News...

Blue Jays Just Saw One Rotation Move Make Their Search Harder

Dustin Mays agreement with the Chicago White Sox on a three-year, $52.5 million deal has already given the pitching market a clearer shape, and not in a way that helps the Blue Jays. After a bidding war that drew multiple teams, Mays contract landed at a level that reflects both the demand for starting pitching and the cost of getting it done this winter, even with his uneven recent work in the mix.

For Toronto, the bigger issue is what comes next. If May can command that kind of money, the price for other starters the Blue Jays have had on their radar could climb right along with it, including Freddy Peralta, Michael Soroka and Kris Bubic. In a market where one move can reset expectations quickly, Toronto may have just watched its search for rotation help get a little more expensive. [Read more 🡒]

Blue Jays May Have To Sacrifice A Young Infielder Fans Like

The Blue Jays winter conversation is already turning toward how they can reshape the roster after missing the playoffs in 2026, and that usually means tough decisions on young players with upside. One name that has surfaced is Charles McAdoo, whom MLB.coms Mark Feinsand pegged as a top trade candidate because of his age, potential and the kind of value he could bring back if Toronto decides to shop from its depth.

McAdoo only got into 36 major league games in 2026, but he did enough to make himself part of the organizations future picture and part of its trade calculus at the same time. For a club trying to add talent and get back into contention, that kind of player can become one of the most complicated assets on the roster, especially when the front office starts weighing immediate help against what a promising young infielder might become down the line. [Read more 🡒]

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. Just Opened An Intriguing Offseason Question

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. has added another layer to an already interesting winter by changing Dominican Professional Baseball League rights from Toros del Este to Tigres del Licey. For Blue Jays fans, it is the kind of off-field development that always draws attention because it ties one of the franchises biggest stars back to a familiar baseball tradition, and it does so with a club that has long been part of the Guerrero family story.

What happens next is still the real question. Tigres general manager Audo Vicente has made clear he is excited about the possibility of Guerrero joining the team, but there is no clarity yet on when or even if that will happen, or whether he will actually appear in a game. For now, the move simply opens the door to a winter storyline that could become meaningful for both Guerrero and the organization if it ever turns into more than a rights transaction. [Read more 🡒]