The Toronto Blue Jays’ broadcast crew remains in the upper tier of MLB booths, even with a slight slide in the latest local TV rankings.
Dan Shulman, Joe Siddall and Hazel Mae landed eighth in Awful Announcing’s 2026 MLB broadcaster poll, keeping Sportsnet’s Blue Jays team inside the top 10 for the fourth straight year. More than 85,000 votes were cast as readers graded all 30 local television crews from A to F.
That eighth-place finish puts Toronto just ahead of the American League East broadcasts in Baltimore at 10th and Boston at 11th. It also marks a drop from last season, when the Blue Jays were ranked fourth.
Awful Announcing pointed to the retirement of Buck Martinez after the 2025 season as a major reason for the fall. The outlet still had plenty of praise for the group, writing, "Despite the loss of the great Buck Martinez, Shulman is still great, and it's a reliable broadcast," the ranking reads.
Shulman drew the strongest reaction from voters, with one calling his work "an absolute masterclass" and others praising the way he speaks to viewers like "intelligent adults."
Siddall, stepping into the full-time role left by Martinez, got mixed reviews. Some voters said he is "still finding his footing," though others appreciated the analytical edge he brings to the booth.
At the top of the list, the San Diego Padres were voted MLB’s best broadcast team for the second year in a row. Don Orsillo and Mark Grant were praised for staying sharp and entertaining no matter the game state, and Orsillo thanked voters on social media while saying the crew was humbled to repeat as winners.
In Other News...
Padres Have A New Late-Inning Weapon Drawing Serious All-MLB Buzz
The All-MLB conversation is already starting to take shape, and for clubs around the league, it is a useful snapshot of which pitchers are forcing their way into the seasons biggest honors discussion. The projections lean heavily on current performance, with names like Jacob Misiorowski, Cristopher Snchez and Dylan Cease headlining the starting group while high-impact relievers such as Mason Miller and Louis Varland have also pushed their way into the picture.
For a Blue Jays team that knows how quickly late-inning arms can change the feel of a series, the reliever debate is the most interesting part of the board. Miller and Varland are drawing serious buzz as the kind of weapons that can reshape October expectations, but these All-MLB predictions remain just that for now, a snapshot of where the season stands before anything is officially handed out. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays May Have Found A Serious Bat Far Later Than Expected
Jake Bennett has made an early impression in Dunedin, and it is not hard to see why the Blue Jays were drawn to him in the draft. The club took him in the eighth round largely because of the bat, and through his first 12 games with Single-A Dunedin, he has given that evaluation some real traction with four home runs and a .940 OPS. The extra-base damage has been the headline, even if the approach still comes with a fair amount of swing-and-miss.
What makes Bennett especially interesting is how much room there still is for the Blue Jays to sort out the rest of the profile. His defensive home is not settled yet, with catcher, first base and designated hitter all in the mix, which leaves Toronto with a pretty straightforward question: how much of his value will come from the bat alone? For now, the organization can at least feel encouraged that a late-round pick is already forcing a closer look. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Take A Risky Pitching Approach Into Yankees Series
The Blue Jays are heading into a pivotal weekend in New York with a pitching plan that says plenty about where things stand right now. Toronto will open the series against the Yankees with a bullpen game on Friday, a reflection of the injuries and rotation juggling that have forced the club to get creative as the games start to carry more postseason weight.
From there, the schedule settles down a bit with Dylan Cease lined up for Saturday and Jos Soriano on Sunday, giving Toronto a more traditional look after the opener. Even so, the approach underscores how carefully the Blue Jays have to manage every arm while they try to keep pace in a race where each matchup can shift the playoff picture. [Read more 🡒]