Anthony Santander arrived in Toronto with the kind of power profile the Blue Jays have been missing for years, but his first season in blue never came close to matching the billing.
That matters because this franchise has gone a long time without a left-handed bat capable of putting 30 balls over the fence in a season. The last one to do it was Adam Lind in 2009, when he launched 35 homers, drove in 114 runs and finished with a .305/.370/.562 line, a 140 wRC+ and 3.3 fWAR.
Before that, the Blue Jays’ left-handed 30-homer club was a tiny one, with Carlos Delgado, Fred McGriff, Shawn Green, Brad Fullmer and John Mayberry Sr. making up the list. Delgado sits alone at the top with eight such seasons, and his 44 homers in 1999 remain the franchise mark for a left-handed hitter.
That is the backdrop for Santander, who signed a five-year, $92.5 million deal in January 2025 and came to Toronto with a resume that made him one of the club’s priority free-agent targets. He had already shown real thump in Baltimore, where he debuted in 2017 and reached at least 20 homers in four seasons. His peak came in 2022 with 33, then he exploded for 44 in 2024, his final year with the Orioles.
From 2022 through 2024, Santander hit 105 home runs, the sixth-highest total in the majors over that stretch. Only Aaron Judge, Shohei Ohtani, Kyle Schwarber, Pete Alonso and Matt Olson were ahead of him.
He also brought something a little different to the table: switch-hitting power. As a right-handed batter against lefties, Santander has 43 home runs, a 4.5% HR/PA rate, and his .767 OPS from that side is actually a touch better than the .760 he has posted as a left-handed hitter.
But Toronto did not get that version of him in 2025. A left shoulder injury in May, caused by a collision with the outfield wall that led to a subluxation and then lingering inflammation, knocked him out for more than three months and wrecked his production. The damage showed up everywhere.
Against left-handed pitching as a right-handed hitter, Santander managed only a .188 slugging percentage, a 36.4% strikeout rate and 32 wRC+ in 55 plate appearances. Against right-handers, he was still well below the level Toronto expected, finishing with a .606 OPS and 70 wRC+ in 166 plate appearances. The split was ugly either way, and the overall return was far from what the Blue Jays paid for.
The problem, though, is bigger than one injured season. Toronto’s left-handed bats have been stuck in this lane for a while. Since 2021, they have averaged just 70 wRC+, with a .221/.287/.313 slash line, a .600 OPS and a 0.27 BB/K rate.
In 2026, the picture got even worse when Santander and Addison Barger were mostly unavailable. Barger, who hit 21 home runs in 2025 before injuries limited him to just 28 plate appearances in nine games in 2026, has also struggled badly against lefties over his career, with a .190/.246/.298 line and 70 wRC+.
Without either of them for most of the year, Toronto’s left-handed hitters finished with a 66 wRC+, their worst mark in a single season against left-handed pitchers since 2022, when they posted a 63 wRC+. Their OPS against lefties also fell from .604 in 2025 to .592.
If that doesn’t change, the Blue Jays are going to keep seeing the same challenge from the rest of the league, especially in the AL East. The Yankees, Red Sox and Rays all have the kind of starting pitching and bullpen depth that can keep leaning on Toronto with left-handed arms.
In Other News...
Blue Jays Fans Just Got A Bittersweet Rowdy Tellez Update
Rowdy Tellez is heading overseas for the 2027 season, a move that closes the book on a major league run that stretched across nine seasons and six clubs. For Blue Jays fans, it lands with a little extra weight because Tellez was one of the more memorable homegrown bats to come through Toronto, and his name still carries plenty of goodwill north of the border.
His path has been winding since then. Tellez spent 2026 mostly in Triple-A after a brief stint with the Atlanta Braves, and now he is set to continue his career with the Rakuten Golden Eagles of Nippon Professional Baseball. It is a bittersweet update for fans who followed him from his Toronto days, especially given how well he peaked with the Milwaukee Brewers in 2022 and how long he remained a familiar figure in the majors. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Suddenly Have A Real Shortstop Problem For 2027
Andrs Gimnezs first season as the Blue Jays shortstop did not give Toronto much comfort heading into the future. The offense around him was already a problem in 2026, and his own production at the position only added to the concern, with a .241/.291/.359 line, nine home runs and 59 RBIs leaving the club with more questions than answers on a spot that is supposed to help stabilize the infield.
Now the Blue Jays are staring at a shortstop situation that could become a real issue by 2027, especially if they want more punch from a lineup that struggled to score. The front office is at least looking at ways to upgrade, whether through a trade or a signing, but there is no obvious fix yet, which makes this one of the more important roster decisions hanging over the teams next move. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jays Trade For A Needed Bat Looks Even Worse Now
The trade Toronto made to add a needed bat has taken on a strange look in a hurry. Joey Loperfido, one of the players involved, was placed on outright waivers by the Astros, cleared, and then came off Houstons 40-man roster with a trip to Triple-A Sugar Land ahead while he continues recovering from hip surgery.
Jess Snchez, the other piece in the deal, has followed a similarly unsettled path. Toronto designated him for assignment earlier, the Diamondbacks claimed him and then designated him again, and he has now cleared waivers and will become a free agent. For a move that was supposed to help the Blue Jays on offense, the reality now is that neither player is on a major-league roster. [Read more 🡒]
