The Heisman Trophy conversation always starts with the headliners, and for 2026 the obvious names are already out in front: Dante Moore, Julian Sayin, Arch Manning, Jeremiah Smith, and CJ Carr, among others. But the race doesn’t always belong to the favorites. Sometimes it gets hijacked by the guy who piles up numbers, keeps his team in the spotlight, and makes a late charge into the mix.
That’s the path for these four dark horse candidates.
Will Hammond may not have been the original plan at quarterback for Texas Tech this season, but after the Brendan Sorsby debacle, he is in line to start. The Red Raiders can light up the scoreboard no matter who is taking snaps, and Hammond already flashed in limited action in 2025, throwing for 680 yards and seven touchdowns in mop-up duty.
Texas Tech’s offense is built to sling it around, and after reaching the College Football Playoff a season ago, the Red Raiders will draw plenty of attention again. They’re expected to contend for the Big 12 once more, and if that happens, Hammond should be putting up the kind of passing numbers that keep him in the Heisman conversation.
Jordan Marshall is a different kind of candidate, but Michigan has a path here too. The Heisman hasn’t gone to a running back since Alabama’s Derrick Henry in 2015, and the Wolverines will have Bryce Underwood soaking up plenty of the attention.
Still, Michigan’s identity remains grounded in the run game, and that won’t change just because Jason Beck is now the offensive coordinator. Beck’s offenses finished No. 2 in the nation in each of the past two seasons.
Marshall started last year as a backup, finished hurt, and still came close to 1,000 rushing yards. If Michigan wins 10 or more games, he could put together the kind of season that sends him to New York.
Cam Coleman brings star power to Texas after two average seasons at Auburn. The 6-foot-3 receiver had more than 1,300 receiving yards and 13 touchdowns over those two years, and now he joins Ryan Wingo in catching passes from Arch Manning.
Texas finished 44th in passing offense last season, and Manning himself was uneven at times. But with a full season under his belt, the expectation is that the passing game should take a step forward in 2026.
If that happens, Coleman has the setup to explode.
Kevin Jennings has already shown he can produce. SMU reached the College Football Playoff two seasons ago and stayed competitive this past year, and Jennings threw for more than 3,200 yards in both seasons.
He’s firmly in the mix as one of the ACC’s top quarterbacks, even if SMU doesn’t carry the national weight of Miami, Clemson, or Florida State. The Mustangs have a real chance to knock off the Hurricanes this season, but that kind of leap will depend on Jennings continuing to improve.
Entering his third year as the starter, he has to clean up the interceptions. If he does, a trip to New York would not be a surprise.
In Other News...
Texas Tech May Have Found A Defensive Tackle Worth Watching Fast
Mateen Ibirogba has taken an unusual path to Lubbock, one that helps explain why Texas Tech coaches are already paying close attention. The Maryland native played both football and lacrosse in high school before beginning his college football career at Georgetown, then moving on to Wake Forest, where he developed into a 300-pound defensive tackle with the kind of size that naturally turns heads in the trenches.
Now at Texas Tech, Ibirogba did not arrive as a developmental project waiting his turn. He was immediately slotted into the starting lineup on the defensive line, and the early buzz around him has centered on the combination of physical tools and visible growth that made him stand out in the first place. For a Red Raiders defense looking for stability up front, he has already become one of the more interesting names to track. [Read more 🡒]
Will Hammonds Progress Suddenly Matters Even More For Texas Tech
Texas Techs first full-pad practice brought the kind of jolt every staff holds its breath over, even in a controlled setting. During the session, offensive tackle Jacob Ponton and defensive tackle Mateen Ibirogba collided and quarterback Will Hammond went to the ground, an unsettling sight for a player still working back from the season-ending knee injury he suffered last October. Joey McGuire has been encouraged by Hammonds recovery, and the same goes for running back Quinten Joyner as the Red Raiders keep moving toward more live football.
The timing makes Hammonds progress matter even more now, because Texas Tech is no longer just monitoring rehab reports - it is lining up for an intrasquad scrimmage and beginning to sort out what the offense can count on. McGuire said both Hammond and Joyner are coming along well, and the next stretch of camp should show how close they are to handling real football demands after months of rehab work. [Read more 🡒]