Texas Tech’s defense has learned the hard way that a second trip through the transfer portal doesn’t guarantee a repeat performance.
A year ago, the Red Raiders struck gold. David Bailey, Romello Height, Bryce Pollock, Lee Hunter and A.J.
Holmes arrived before the 2025 season and immediately changed the outlook on that side of the ball. Bailey, Height, Pollock and Hunter all earned first-team All-Big 12 honors, while Holmes landed on the third team after breaking into the starting lineup in the middle of the year.
That haul helped drive Texas Tech to a conference title and gave the defense the look of one of the nation’s best units.
This season, though, the portal return has been far more modest. Texas Tech is still 6-1, matching its seven-game mark from a year ago, but the defense hasn’t come close to the same standard.
With Bailey, Height, Hunter and All-American linebacker Jacob Rodriguez gone to the 2026 NFL Draft in the first half, the Red Raiders were forced to reload. The replacements have mostly been serviceable, not special.
The biggest concerns start up front, where Adam Trick and Trey White were brought in to keep the edge rush humming. Instead, the pair has combined for just four sacks through seven games.
Bailey alone had 10.5 at this point last season, and Height added 5.0. Trick and White also have only 6.0 tackles for loss between them, a steep drop from the 17.5 Bailey and Height had together through the same stretch in 2025.
Both edge additions came from the Group of 6 level - Trick from Miami of Ohio and White from San Diego State - and that difference in pedigree has shown up on Saturdays. Bailey arrived from Stanford, while Height had already logged time at Georgia Tech, USC and Auburn before coming to Lubbock.
Inside, Mateen Ibirogba was expected to bring the kind of disruptive presence Hunter provided, even if the style was different. Instead, the Wake Forest transfer has blended in more than Texas Tech wanted.
He has 13 tackles and 2.0 sacks, but his overall impact has been hard to separate from the rotation around him. At this point last season, Hunter had 19 tackles and 1.5 sacks, and he finished with 42 tackles overall.
Ibirogba is on pace for 24 in a 13-game season.
Austin Romaine has carried the heaviest burden of all, asked to step into Jacob Rodriguez’s role in the middle of the defense. He has been the most productive of Tech’s major portal additions, with 52 tackles, 3.5 tackles for loss, three pass defenses and two pick-sixes.
Even so, the fit has been uneven. He has been caught out in coverage at key moments, including the Houston game’s closing minute when he gave up a touchdown that cut the lead to two.
And outside of the two pick-sixes against Sam Houston, he has not been a consistent factor in creating turnovers.
The numbers tell the story of the drop-off. Last season, Texas Tech finished No. 3 nationally in total defense, No. 1 against the run and No. 26 against the pass.
This year, those marks have fallen to No. 86, No. 24 and No.
That decline has many causes, but the portal misses stand near the top of the list. Texas Tech didn’t just need bodies.
It needed another home run. Instead, the Red Raiders got singles.
In Other News...
Texas Tech Just Got Caught In A Brutal Big 12 Shakeup
Saturdays Big 12 results tightened the picture around Texas Tech in a hurry. BYU and the Red Raiders both took losses, a rough turn for two teams trying to stay in the mix as the conference race and the College Football Playoff conversation start to sharpen.
Utahs win over Houston only added to the pressure, giving the Utes a boost in both the league standings and the national picture while the pecking order around them shifts. With Arizona coming to Lubbock next and BYU heading to Utah, the next round of games could say a lot about where Texas Tech fits in a suddenly crowded race. [Read more 🡒]