ESPN Just Sent BYU Fans Back Into The Disrespect Debate

Despite returning talent and strong preseason selections, Big 12 teams struggle for recognition in ESPN's latest College Football Power Index.

ESPN’s first crack at the 2026 College Football Power Index did the Big 12 no favors.

When the numbers dropped, the conference was barely visible in the top 25. Texas Tech landed at No. 10, BYU came in at No. 20, and that was it for the league among the highest-ranked teams.

At the top of the board, Ohio State opened at No. 1 overall with 28.7 points. Texas followed at 26.9, then Notre Dame at 25.9. The conference breakdown was just as lopsided: the SEC took nine spots, the Big Ten grabbed seven, and the ACC outpaced the Big 12 with three teams - Miami, Clemson and Iowa.

Texas Tech’s placement makes sense on paper. The Red Raiders are dealing with the departures of linebackers Jacob Rodriguez and David Bailey, which leaves the defense more exposed against veteran offenses.

Even so, they still look like a Big 12 favorite because of what returns around them, including running back Cameron Dickey and tight end Terrance Carter Jr. That gives Will Hammond a steadier runway after Brendan Sorsby’s exit in the middle of a chaotic offseason gambling scandal.

The respect is there elsewhere, too: six Red Raiders made Phil Steele Preseason All-Americans, and eight more were named to his First Team All-Big 12 list.

BYU’s No. 20 ranking feels light for a team that has done enough to earn more trust. Kalani Sitake is back for the foreseeable future, and the Cougars enter 2026 with the kind of continuity that matters in this league.

They were one game away from the program’s first Big 12 title in 2025, and they bring back enough to stay in the mix. Defensive coordinator Jay Hill is gone, but tackle Keanu Tanuvasa and linebacker Isaiah Glasker return to anchor a defense that should be deep in Year 1 under new coordinator Kelly Poppinga.

Offensively, BYU has a strong starting point with running back LJ Martin and quarterback Bear Bachmeier. The schedule is no picnic either, with nine straight weeks of football and matchups against Notre Dame on Oct. 17 and Utah on Nov.

The Big 12 doesn’t show up again until Utah at No. 31 under Morgan Scalley. Arizona follows at No. 34 and Houston at No. 35, each with enough pieces to look like a contender.

Outside of Texas Tech and BYU, ESPN’s first pass at the 2026 FPI wasn’t wildly off base for the Big 12. But the broader picture still isn’t flattering.

With so many teams sitting below the top 30, the league has work to do in 2026 if it wants these preseason numbers to start looking kinder. And with the Big 12 sitting at 1-8 overall in the history of the College Football Playoff, that’s a hurdle the conference can’t afford to ignore.

In Other News...

Texas Commit Fires Back After Joey McGuire's Latest Challenge

Joey McGuire has never been shy about leaning into the biggest stage, and his latest push for a season-opening meeting with Texas fits the way he has tried to position Texas Tech as a program ready for more than just regional noise. The Red Raiders are chasing College Football Playoff relevance, and McGuires willingness to say Texas Tech would line up immediately only adds fuel to a rivalry that already carries plenty of recruiting and bragging-rights weight across the state.

John Meredith III did not let the challenge sit unanswered, adding his own edge to a matchup that would give both programs a chance to make a statement early. Texas has the recent upper hand in the series, but the broader conversation is really about where these teams are headed and whether a future meeting could feel less like a novelty and more like a collision between two programs trying to climb into the same national conversation. [Read more 🡒]

Texas Tech Finally Put A Timeline On JT Toppins Return

Texas Tech finally gave its fan base something concrete on JT Toppin, even if the update still leaves plenty of uncertainty. The Red Raiders said the standout forward is expected back for the 2026-27 season after a knee injury cut short what had been a dominant run, one that put him on the national radar with First-Team AP All-American recognition and production that made him one of the most productive big men in the country.

What Texas Tech did not spell out is the more immediate part of the recovery, and that is the part that matters most for the programs planning. Toppins absence changes the shape of the roster and the expectations around next season, while also keeping the focus on how he comes back from an injury that interrupted a season built on high-end scoring, rebounding and all-around impact. [Read more 🡒]

Eric Gutierrez Headlines A Texas Tech Hall Of Fame Class Fans Will Love

Texas Techs Hall of Fame will have a little extra buzz next fall, with the school announcing its 2026 class of eight former athletes from across the programs sports. The group will be honored during the weekend of the Sept. 26 home game against Sam Houston, and the headliner for plenty of Red Raider fans is Eric Gutierrez, the former baseball standout who is now on the Texas Tech coaching staff.

Gutierrezs induction carries a nice full-circle feel, especially since he made the Hall of Fame on his first year on the ballot. He is joined by Joe Filani, another former Red Raider who has gone on to coach at the college level, giving the class a strong current-day connection to the program as Texas Tech gets ready to celebrate a group that should resonate well beyond one sport. [Read more 🡒]