The Texas Rangers have been drafting since 1965, and like every franchise with that much history, they’ve had their share of swings that missed. First-round picks come with expectations baked in.
Some become cornerstones. Others never come close.
A few of the biggest whiffs in Rangers history came with plenty of hype and, in some cases, painfully short big league careers. Here are five first-round picks who never lived up to the billing.
David Clyde remains the lone No. 1 overall pick in Rangers history, and the pressure on him was enormous from the start. The left-hander out of Westchester High School in Houston was pushed into his first MLB start only one month after graduating, a decision that did him no favors.
He spent parts of three seasons with Texas, missed two years because of arm injuries, then logged two more seasons with Cleveland. His career ended with an 18-33 record and a 4.63 ERA, and he was done by age 24.
The Rangers later honored him in 2023 on the 50th anniversary of his first MLB start at Arlington Stadium.
Then came Scott Meyer, the No. 6 overall pick out of Oklahoma State. He was an all-American, and in college he teamed with Robin Ventura in the middle infield.
Over 69 games, he hit .397 with 30 home runs, 114 RBI and an .860 slugging percentage, which made him look like a future fixture for Texas up the middle. Instead, he played 86 games for the Rangers and hit just .223/.314/.335 with four home runs and 27 RBI.
He went to Miami the next year, appeared in 18 more major league games with the Florida Marlins, and never returned to the big leagues. His career was over at 25, though he did spend two more years in the minors.
One year after Farris, Texas used the No. 5 overall pick on Billy Harris, the Texas Tech outfielder with rare athletic gifts. He played both football and baseball at Texas Tech, and the Dallas Cowboys even drafted him as a safety.
The Rangers were hoping for a player who could bring power and speed together, but it never happened. Harris appeared in only 82 MLB games from 1991-93 and hit .205/.248/.282 with two home runs and 11 RBI.
He was out of the majors after 1993, though he kept playing in the minors, independent leagues and the Mexican League until 2000.
Kiker came out of Russell County in Seale, Ala., and Texas took him No. 12 overall, paying a $1.6 million bonus. Unlike Clyde, he never reached the majors at all.
He didn’t get above Double-A and finished with a 23-31 record and a 4.53 ERA before the Rangers released him in 2011. The frustrating part for Texas was what came before that pick: Tim Lincecum and Max Scherzer were selected two spots ahead of him.
The Rangers also thought they were getting a shortstop with a quick path to the majors when they drafted Meyer No. 10 overall out of South Carolina. It took him four years to reach the big leagues, and once he got there, the opportunity was tiny.
He played in five games, had 15 at-bats and collected three hits. After that, he stayed in minor league baseball until 2010.
He had already been a highly regarded high school prospect, going in the second round to the Los Angeles Dodgers three years before Texas took him.
And the one that really stings? The Rangers passed on Cole Hamels, who went seven picks later to Philadelphia.
In Other News...
These 3 Rangers May Be Less Untouchable Than Fans Think
The Rangers trade-deadline picture is getting more complicated than a simple buyers-or-sellers label, and three names keep surfacing in the conversation. Kumar Rocker, Josh Smith and Corey Seager all sit in very different spots on the roster, but each has enough uncertainty around him to make rival clubs wonder whether Texas might listen if the right offer comes along before Aug. 3.
Rockers early run as a starter has not quite matched the raw stuff that made him such an intriguing arm, while Smiths value is tied more to his versatility than to any clear everyday role. Seager is the biggest name of the group, and his situation is shaped by the kind of long-term considerations front offices always weigh carefully, especially when a players trade protection can change if a deal is not made in time. [Read more 🡒]
Former Rangers Coach Named His Only Two Untouchables
Bret Boones recent comments on 105.3 The FAN offered a different kind of deadline lens on the Rangers, one shaped less by front-office calculus than by how he sees the rosters core. The former Texas hitting coach singled out Wyatt Langford as the kind of young, controllable player teams usually build around, pointing to the offensive ceiling and defensive flexibility that make him such a valuable long-term piece.
Boones other choice was a more surprising one, especially for a club that could hear plenty of calls on pitching depth as the deadline approaches. He made the case for Jacob Latz as a pitcher he would keep off the table, citing the way he has handled relief work and even closing duties, which gives the Rangers a useful arm with a role that can still grow. [Read more 🡒]
Rangers Deadline Reality Just Got A Lot More Uncomfortable
Sitting at .500 and clinging to the final American League wild card spot, the Rangers have reached the point where every front-office move feels heavier than it should in late July. They are only a game and a half out in the division race, but the margin for error is thin enough that the deadline conversation has turned less into a simple buy-or-sell question and more into a test of how much the organization is willing, and able, to spend for a push.
The problem is that Texas does not have an easy answer on either side of the market. The farm system has already taken real hits in recent deal-making, and injuries to key players have made the current roster harder to evaluate as a true contender. Even the sell-off path is messy, with limited movable pieces and contract situations that do not create much obvious value, which is why the Rangers are staring at one of the more uncomfortable deadlines in the league. [Read more 🡒]