Red Sox Shortstop Debate Just Got Much More Complicated

The Boston Red Sox may have an opportunity to bolster their shortstop position by eyeing a potential trade with the Texas Rangers for Corey Seager, as his acquisition cost could align with their strategic plans.

The Red Sox’s shortstop picture is still unsettled, and a new report has pushed Corey Seager into the conversation.

Boston still has Trevor Story, but chief baseball officer Craig Breslow stopped short of locking him in as the starter when he spoke to the media on Monday, according to MassLive.com’s Chris Cotillo. Franklin Arias is also in the mix as a top prospect, and the Red Sox could still go shopping for help at the position. Elly De La Cruz has been floated repeatedly this offseason as a possible target, but on Tuesday Evan Grant of The Dallas Morning News added another name: Seager of the Texas Rangers.

Grant also reported that the Rangers are "fully on board" with gauging Seager’s trade market.

"The Red Sox are just about to emerge from a long-term deal with a shortstop from the free agent class of ‘22, Irving’s Trevor Story," Grant wrote. "He’s free after 2027.

So why potentially sign up for that all over again with Seager having five years remaining? The Red Sox were interested last winter.

They may have some of their down deals they’d like to offload, like Story and perhaps arb-eligible Jarren Duran. ... The Red Sox also have some prospects who’ve lost value Kristian Campbell, who signed a long-term deal, but spent last year in the minors."

Seager would bring a résumé that few shortstops can match. Over a 12-year major league career, he has been a five-time All-Star, a three-time Silver Slugger Award winner and a two-time World Series champion. He also won two World Series Most Valuable Player Awards.

The contract, though, is the other side of the equation. Seager signed a 10-year, $325 million deal and has five years left at $31.5 million per season.

He is also coming off a season that was quiet by his standards, batting .227 and appearing in only 102 games. Still, he produced 3.1 wins above replacement.

Boston’s interest in Seager is not new. The Red Sox showed interest during the summer, but he was not moved. Last offseason, it was reported that Boston was not on a list of teams Seager could veto in a trade.

From the Red Sox side, a pursuit would say plenty about how the club views its current options. It would suggest uncertainty about Story and likely cast doubt on Arias as the eventual answer. Boston already explored the shortstop market this past summer, with Zach Neto, De La Cruz and CJ Abrams among the names it pursued.

Seager’s recent production also matters in how teams might value him. In 2024, he was worth 7.2 WAR, then followed that with a 6.1 WAR season in 2025. Even so, at 32 years old and with a down year behind him, the cost to acquire him should be lower than the kind of package De La Cruz or perhaps even Abrams would require.

That makes Seager an interesting middle ground for a team that wants to swing big without paying the steepest price. If Boston wants to make a major move at shortstop, Seager fits that lane. But taking on five more years of his contract, along with the injury concerns that come with it, would have to come at the right price.

In Other News...

Rangers Trade Talks Could Put One Familiar Name In Play

With the General Manager Meetings set for Nov. 10-12 in Las Vegas, Chris Young is heading into the kind of week that can quietly shape a roster for months to come. The Rangers president of baseball operations is expected to be in the room for trade conversations, and as always at this stage of the calendar, familiar names can start surfacing in speculative talks as clubs explore what it might take to improve.

For Texas, the chatter naturally circles back to a few players who would draw attention if the Rangers decided to listen. Nathan Eovaldi remains the sort of established arm that could interest contenders, while Sebastian Walcott gives the organization a premium young piece whose value is easy to imagine in bigger conversations. Nothing is settled, and these are still just possible frameworks rather than actual deals, but the fact that both veterans and prospects could enter the discussion is enough to make Las Vegas a place worth watching for Rangers fans. [Read more 🡒]

Rangers May Be Heading Toward A Corey Seager Crossroads

The Rangers are entering the offseason with a difficult question hanging over Corey Seager, and the answer may start taking shape at the general managers meetings in Las Vegas. Texas is expected to gauge the trade market for its star shortstop, a move that reflects both the clubs desire for payroll flexibility and the reality that Seagers contract and injury history make any deal complicated from the start.

Seagers full no-trade rights give him control over where this goes, and the financial commitment attached to him means any conversation will be about more than just baseball value. If the Rangers do decide to explore moving him, it could open a path for Sebastian Walcott, the prospect many around the organization see as a possible long-term answer at shortstop, but the first step is simply finding out whether there is real interest at all. [Read more 🡒]

Rangers Bullpen Need Could Force An Offseason Spending Decision

The Rangers bullpen picture is already pushing the front office into a difficult corner this winter. After losing several veteran arms, Texas is looking at a relief group that needs help from both the left side and the back end, and Sports Illustrateds Will Laws has floated a familiar sort of fix: a proven reliever with a long track record who could stabilize the unit without requiring a full overhaul.

Sean Newcomb fits that general profile after a strong season with the White Sox, and his rsum across multiple teams over a 10-year career makes him the kind of arm clubs tend to trust when the market gets thin. The problem for Texas is less about identifying the need than finding a way to meet it, because the Rangers are operating with limited payroll flexibility, which makes any meaningful bullpen addition a more complicated call than it might look on paper. [Read more 🡒]