Texas Rangers pitching prospect Alejandro Chiquillo has been the one who has separated himself in the Arizona Fall League, while Mason McConnaughey and Jacob Johnson have had more uneven runs for Surprise.
Chiquillo, a non-ranked right-hander from Caracas, Venezuela, owns a 3.86 ERA in 9.1 innings across three games. He has allowed six hits, four earned runs and four walks while striking out 10.
The underlying numbers have been just as solid: a 1.07 WHIP and a .176 batting average against. The one blemish is the damage on balls that have left the yard, with two home runs among those six hits.
That performance looks especially meaningful when stacked against his third minor league season. In 2026 with the Class-A Hickory Crawdads, he went 1-3 with a 4.79 ERA in 17 games, 13 of them starts, and also picked up a save.
But the strikeouts and opponent average have stayed in the same neighborhood. He held hitters to a .217 average in the regular season, struck out 56 over 56.1 innings and walked 26, and those numbers have carried over well enough in Arizona that he’s been the Rangers’ best arm in the AFL so far.
McConnaughey’s trip has been more up and down. The Rangers’ No. 30 prospect, selected in the fourth round of the 2025 MLB draft out of Nebraska, did not pitch last season while recovering from Tommy John surgery.
In his first pro season with Hickory, he went 1-1 with a 3.48 ERA in eight games, including seven starts. In the Fall League, though, he has a 6.14 ERA in three games and 7.1 innings, with eight hits, five earned runs and two home runs allowed.
Opponents are hitting .276 against him.
There is at least one encouraging piece in McConnaughey’s line: he has struck out 13 and walked four, which is a better strikeout-to-walk ratio than he posted during the regular season. He struck out 16 and walked six in 20.2 innings with Hickory. The stuff has held up, but more hitters are putting the ball in play.
Johnson entered the AFL as the highest-ranked Rangers pitching prospect among the group, but the results have been rougher than the reputation. He has a 1-1 record and a 7.11 ERA in three starts, though he has only thrown 6.1 innings. During that stretch, he has allowed four hits and five earned runs.
The bigger concern has been command. Even with opponents hitting just .182 against him, Johnson has issued seven walks while striking out only four.
That’s a stark turn from his first pro season, when he reached Hickory and struck out 48 while walking 25 in 43 innings. The Rangers will likely view it as a blip, but his final outings will matter as they look for him to smooth out that strikeout-to-walk ratio before the season closes.
In Other News...
Rangers Face A Risky Catching Decision Fans Will Debate All Winter
The Rangers catching picture is one of the more intriguing winter questions on their board, especially if the market opens in a way that lets them chase an upgrade without sacrificing too much flexibility elsewhere. Milwaukee catcher William Contreras is at the center of that conversation after another strong postseason showing, and his name carries real weight because the Brewers have a track record of dealing star players before they get too close to free agency.
For Texas, the appeal is obvious: an established bat at a premium position and a player who could change the shape of the lineup. The hesitation is just as clear. The defensive side of the ledger has not looked nearly as clean as the offensive reputation, and recent trends suggest the Rangers would have to decide whether they trust the upside enough to make a major commitment, or whether the safer move is to keep looking for catching help elsewhere. [Read more 🡒]
Rangers Offseason Pressure Is Suddenly On Chris Young
A season that ended just short of the playoffs has already pushed Texas into an early offseason reckoning, and the priorities are pretty clear. The Rangers want more offense they can count on from the top of the lineup, along with deeper pitching support behind Jacob deGrom and Nathan Eovaldi, because the margin for error shrank over the course of the year and showed up in the spots that matter most.
Chris Young is now the one under the microscope as the front office maps out what comes next. The president of baseball operations has made it plain he wants better depth and more Major League-ready competition for roster spots, which puts the pressure on this winter to produce real answers rather than another layer of maybe-help. [Read more 🡒]
Which Rangers Draftees Could Force Their Way Into The 2027 Picture
The Rangers came out of the 2026 MLB draft with a mix of upside and immediacy, headlined by left-hander Gio Rojas and shortstop Connor Comeau, but the more intriguing early path may belong to the college arms in the class. Hudson Calhoun, Michael Anderson Jr. and Caden Aoki all arrive with the kind of polish that can shorten the runway, and that matters for a club always looking for controllable help to emerge before long.
Each brings a different look, but the common thread is maturity, both physically and mentally, along with college production that suggests they may not need a long apprenticeship. If any of them can translate those traits quickly in pro ball, the Rangers could have a real chance to see one or more of these picks force their way into the 2027 conversation sooner than expected. [Read more 🡒]