The Rangers are looking for ways to upgrade this offseason, but chasing Milwaukee Brewers catcher William Contreras could take them down the wrong road.
Texas has been tied to catcher help before, including Ryan Jeffers at the trade deadline, and the need at the position still lingers. The club brought in Logan O’Hoppe at the deadline, then sent him to Round Rock right away before giving him just 18 plate appearances in September after recalling him. After two straight abysmal seasons, how much the Rangers trust him going forward is still an open question.
Danny Jansen is set to return, and the Rangers are likely to decline their end of the mutual option with Kyle Higashioka. So another catcher may be on the table. The problem is that the price for Jeffers could be too steep, which is why a possible Contreras deal would draw attention if Milwaukee made him available.
That said, Texas should stay away.
Contreras was front and center in Game 1 of the World Series, driving in Milwaukee’s second run in the first inning and then throwing out would-be basestealers in back-to-back innings, snapping Tampa Bay’s perfect streak on the bases. He has a real arm and above-average pop time, and that part of his game showed up on a huge stage.
But the rest of the defensive profile is a concern. In 2026, Contreras ranked in the fifth percentile as a pitch framer and the eighth percentile as a pitch blocker.
There’s also the Brewers’ track record to consider. FanSided’s MLB insider Robert Murray pointed to Contreras as a possible trade candidate once the offseason starts, noting Milwaukee’s recent habit of dealing stars such as Corbin Burnes, Josh Hader, Devin Williams, and Freddy Peralta in the final year of team control. The Brewers either lock up their players early, like they did with Cooper Pratt and Luis Lara, or they move them a year before free agency to reload the system.
Recent history should make Texas wary. The last two deals of this kind, Devin Williams to the Yankees and Freddy Peralta to the Mets, left those clubs with regrets. Peralta later rebounded with the Rays, but the broader message remains the same: when Milwaukee is willing to move someone, there’s usually a reason.
Contreras’s regular-season numbers also have moved the wrong way. His wRC+ has gone from 132 in 2024 to 114 in 2025 to 109 in 2026.
His fWAR has followed a similar slide, dropping from 5.5 to 3.7 and then to 3.0. Those are still strong seasons, but the trend line matters, especially if Texas would have to pay up to get him.
Then there’s the future cost. If Contreras keeps producing, he’ll be in line for a major payday by the time free agency comes around.
The Rangers will have money coming off the books, with Nathan Eovaldi’s contract expiring and Texas holding a $20 million club option for Jacob deGrom. But if both starters are gone, the club will have to replace that pitching, and starting arms aren’t cheap.
Without Ray Davis suddenly opening the wallet, keeping Contreras long term would be a tough ask.
So if Milwaukee does put Contreras on the block, the fit may be tempting. It still wouldn’t be the right move for Texas. He’d be an expensive one-year rental with enough risk attached to make passing the smarter play.
In Other News...
Rangers Prospect Is Making A Late AFL Case Fans Should Notice
The Rangers gave three pitching prospects a fall-stage test in the Arizona Fall League, and the early returns have been mixed but still worth tracking. Alejandro Chiquillo, Mason McConnaughey and Jacob Johnson all got the chance to make a late impression after their minor league seasons, with each arm showing a different version of where he stands right now.
Chiquillo has been the most encouraging of the group, pairing a solid ERA with tough contact against him, while McConnaughey has had to battle through some rough outings even as his strikeout-to-walk ratio has moved in a better direction. Johnson, meanwhile, has run into command problems, which is the kind of issue that can overshadow the rest of his arsenal if it lingers into next spring. [Read more 🡒]
Rangers Offseason Pressure Is Suddenly On Chris Young
A season that ended just short of the playoffs has already pushed Texas into an early offseason reckoning, and the priorities are pretty clear. The Rangers want more offense they can count on from the top of the lineup, along with deeper pitching support behind Jacob deGrom and Nathan Eovaldi, because the margin for error shrank over the course of the year and showed up in the spots that matter most.
Chris Young is now the one under the microscope as the front office maps out what comes next. The president of baseball operations has made it plain he wants better depth and more Major League-ready competition for roster spots, which puts the pressure on this winter to produce real answers rather than another layer of maybe-help. [Read more 🡒]
Which Rangers Draftees Could Force Their Way Into The 2027 Picture
The Rangers came out of the 2026 MLB draft with a mix of upside and immediacy, headlined by left-hander Gio Rojas and shortstop Connor Comeau, but the more intriguing early path may belong to the college arms in the class. Hudson Calhoun, Michael Anderson Jr. and Caden Aoki all arrive with the kind of polish that can shorten the runway, and that matters for a club always looking for controllable help to emerge before long.
Each brings a different look, but the common thread is maturity, both physically and mentally, along with college production that suggests they may not need a long apprenticeship. If any of them can translate those traits quickly in pro ball, the Rangers could have a real chance to see one or more of these picks force their way into the 2027 conversation sooner than expected. [Read more 🡒]