The Rangers’ reported push to improve defense behind the plate raises a bigger question than just who they might add: what does it say about Logan O’Hoppe?
Texas is said to be looking for upgrades all over the field, with catcher and center field drawing the most attention. Center field is easy enough to understand with Evan Carter sidelined, though it also opens the door to bigger questions about Carter’s future in Arlington. Catcher, though, is murkier.
That’s because catcher defense is one of the hardest things in baseball to pin down. A backstop’s job stretches across a lot of different skills - blocking pitches, controlling the running game, framing, and now ABS challenges.
Game calling sits in that mix too, even if it’s harder to measure. Finding a catcher who can handle all of that and still hit is rare.
Danny Jansen is a good example of that tradeoff. He has been a 90th-percentile or better pitch blocker for the last few years, but he has been below average in the running game and as a framer.
Whether that makes him a good defender depends on how you weigh those pieces. Either way, he’s not going anywhere.
Jansen is under contract for $8 million in 2027, and after struggling offensively for much of the year while dealing with injuries, he caught fire late once he came off the IL.
That brings the focus to O’Hoppe, whom Texas acquired at the trade deadline before immediately optioning him to Round Rock. In 23 games there, he hit .264/.363/.494. The move also gave the Rangers an extra year of team control by keeping him down as long as they did.
But O’Hoppe’s profile makes this whole situation tricky. At his best, he’s a bat-first catcher.
His defense has not gotten better since the Angels called him up in 2022, and it may have slipped. He finished in the first percentile in both pitch blocking and framing, while ranking in the 30th percentile in throwing runners out and the 23rd percentile in pop time.
The Angels had concerns at times about his game-calling, too.
His offense has also cratered. Over 85 games between Los Angeles and Texas, he hit .219/.275/.303. So he’ll need to rebuild his bat while also trying to clean up the defensive issues that have followed him for years.
That’s why the fit gets so awkward if Texas really does bring in a glove-first catcher. The Rangers do not have the budget for a premium backstop who can do everything, which points toward a cheaper, defense-heavy option more in the backup lane.
Freddy Fermin, who the Padres are shopping, is one possible fit. In 2026, he finished in the 72nd percentile in framing, 93rd percentile in pitch blocking, and 97th percentile in cutting down baserunners, but he hit just .203/.274/.315.
Texas also won’t carry three catchers. Unless the Rangers trade Jansen, there doesn’t seem to be room for O’Hoppe unless an injury opens the door. That leaves the obvious question hanging: is this really the best use of assets?
In Other News...
Evan Carters Rangers Future Suddenly Feels Far Less Certain
The Rangers offseason shopping list is starting to say plenty about where they think the roster needs help, and center field is right near the top. According to MLB Networks Jon Morosi, Texas is looking for defensive upgrades in center and at catcher, a sign that the club is bracing for uncertainty at a couple of key spots while trying to tighten up run prevention.
For Evan Carter, that makes an already uneasy stretch feel even more precarious. He burst onto the scene with real promise, but injuries and offensive struggles have clouded his path since then, and the Rangers do have other defensive options they can lean on, including Wyatt Langford. Whether the concern is Carters recovery from hip surgery or something broader about his place in the organization, the report suggests Texas may be planning as if he is not central to its future. [Read more 🡒]
Rangers Offseason Pressure Just Shifted In Two Important Areas
The Rangers offseason to-do list got a little clearer on two fronts this week, and neither development was especially subtle. Chris Martin, a former Texas reliever, announced his retirement after 11 major league seasons, closing the book on a veteran arm who had once been part of the organizations bullpen mix. At the same time, Texas moved to address its own offensive issues by hiring Tommy Joseph as its major league hitting coach, a change aimed at helping a lineup that needs more production.
On the pitching side, the market also shifted against Texas. Former Dodgers reliever Evan Phillips, who had been a logical bullpen target for the Rangers, signed a three-year deal with the Atlanta Braves, taking one more name off the board for a relief corps that still has work to do. Between the coaching hire and the bullpen market thinning out, the Rangers offseason pressure now sits in two familiar places: getting more out of the bats and finding the right arms to support them. [Read more 🡒]
Jake Bauers Just Made The Rangers' Offseason More Difficult
Jake Bauers breakout season with Milwaukee changed the way teams around the league viewed him, and now the market has responded in a big way. After a career year that ended with NL Championship Series MVP honors, he has agreed to a four-year, $58 million deal with the Red Sox, a contract that says plenty about how aggressively clubs are willing to pay for a player whose value has clearly climbed.
For the Rangers, that kind of price tag only adds another layer to an offseason that already figures to be shaped by payroll decisions and a crowded free-agent market. A deal like this does more than move one player off the board - it gives the rest of the winter a new benchmark, and it makes it harder for Texas to shop comfortably if it wants to stay disciplined while still filling needs. [Read more 🡒]
