Rangers Already Face Doubts About One Deadline Bullpen Bet

As the Texas Rangers reflect on their 2026 trade deadline decisions, concerns mount over a key bullpen acquisition that has yet to deliver the expected return on investment.

The Texas Rangers did not exactly light up the 2026 trade deadline, and that’s what makes one of their two moves stand out now.

Texas made just a pair of notable deals in August. One sent minor league infielder Angel Arredondo to the Los Angeles Angels in exchange for relief pitcher Chase Silseth and catcher Logan O’Hoppe. The other, completed on deadline day, shipped utility infielder Josh Smith to the Toronto Blue Jays for relief pitcher Adam Macko.

The Rangers were clearly trying to strengthen the bullpen, and Silseth was the bigger swing of the two additions. He fit the kind of profile teams love: a controllable right-hander who could help in a division title chase and remain under team control through 2030 because he was not yet arbitration-eligible.

On paper, it made sense. In practice, the fit has not been nearly as clean.

Silseth was effective with the Angels before the move. In 47 games, he went 3-2 with a 2.72 ERA, struck out 48, walked 22 and held opponents to a .230 average in 39.2 innings. He also picked up eight holds.

Once he landed in Texas, the line changed fast. In 26 games with the Rangers, he went 0-2 with a 5.31 ERA.

He struck out 26, walked 13 and worked 20.1 innings, while opponents hit .266 against him. The strikeout-to-walk edge narrowed, and hitters were seeing him much better.

Usage may be part of the story. Silseth threw a career-high 73 appearances in 2026, which was more than all of his other MLB outings combined - 35 - since his debut in 2022.

He also lost time in 2024 and 2025 because of elbow surgery, appearing in just 12 games over those two seasons. That kind of workload could easily be a factor for a pitcher who had never been pushed this hard in the majors.

Even with the rough finish, the Rangers still have reasons to believe in the arm. Silseth brings a solid four-pitch mix, and Statcast likes several parts of his profile: his whiff rate sits in the 94th percentile, his strikeout rate in the 82th percentile and his hard-hit rate in the 90th percentile. His sweeper has also graded as a plus-5 pitch against right-handers.

That’s why Texas is betting this can still become something useful long term - a controllable right-handed setup option who can help stabilize the innings ahead of a closer like Jacob Latz.

He might still become that pitcher. But with the early returns looking the way they do, the Rangers have reason to wonder whether this is the deadline move they’ll end up regretting.

In Other News...

Rangers Offseason Squeeze Could Lead To One Tough Roster Cut

The Rangers are heading toward a familiar kind of offseason squeeze, with a Nov. 20 deadline looming for decisions on arbitration-eligible players and others under team control. With the club intent on keeping payroll flat for 2027, every tender decision carries extra weight, especially for a roster that still needs to balance present value against longer-term flexibility.

Most of the attention in that process figures to fall on the edges of the roster, where the Rangers are sorting through who fits the next version of the team and who does not. MacKenzie Gore and Jacob Latz are viewed as likely keepers, but the front offices shifting priorities make at least one power bat a tougher fit than it once might have been, and that could turn this into one of the more uncomfortable calls of the winter. [Read more 🡒]

Rangers Could Turn Nathan Eovaldi Into More Than Salary Relief

Chris Youngs willingness to talk about moving Nathan Eovaldi, Jacob deGrom and Corey Seager says plenty about where the Rangers are headed this winter. For Eovaldi in particular, the appeal is obvious: a proven veteran arm on a deal that could help Texas reshape its payroll while still bringing back something useful in return. It is the kind of conversation that usually starts with flexibility and quickly turns into a broader look at what a contender can afford to keep.

The market for Eovaldi is the part worth watching, because a pitcher with his track record should draw interest from clubs looking for stability at the top of a rotation. Boston and Houston both make sense as possible landing spots, and Texas would not be shopping him just to clear money if it can avoid it. The Rangers would want a return that helps beyond the ledger, and the bigger question is whether the right fit emerges before the offseason gets too far along. [Read more 🡒]

Rangers Linked To Low-Cost Outfield Fix With Bigger Moves Looming

The Rangers are heading into the offseason with more than one conversation on the table, and Chris Young has already signaled that trades are very much in play. Texas has bigger questions to sort through as well, with the possibility of dealing established names such as Jacob deGrom, Nathan Eovaldi and Corey Seager part of the broader picture. But before the front office gets to any of those heavier lifts, it still has to patch a hole in the outfield.

A low-cost fit has surfaced in Toronto outfielder Nathan Lukes, a versatile defender whose profile lines up with what Texas needs under the current collective bargaining agreement. The interest makes sense because the Rangers are staring at uncertainty in center field while Evan Carter works through hip surgery, and they need some insurance as they map out the rest of the winter. Lukes would not solve everything, but he could be the kind of practical move that lets Texas keep its bigger options open. [Read more 🡒]