MacKenzie Gore’s name showing up on MLB Trade Rumors’ offseason trade board says plenty about how the Rangers’ gamble played out.
Texas paid a steep price for him - five prospects sent to Washington - with the idea that he’d help anchor a rotation that had just posted a league-leading 3.41 ERA in 2025. The plan was obvious enough: pair Gore with Jacob deGrom and Nathan Eovaldi, then ride that trio back into the postseason.
Instead, Gore’s first year in Arlington became a cautionary tale. His 4.58 ERA ranked fifth-worst among qualified starters, a far cry from what the Rangers expected when they made the deal.
The final game of the season captured the whole thing in miniature. Gore started on short rest and lasted only 2 1/3 innings before being pulled with the season on the line.
He may have been able to keep going, but the quick hook made it clear Skip Schumaker didn’t fully trust him to get the job done.
That said, the season wasn’t a total wipeout. Gore had stretches where he looked like the pitcher Texas thought it was acquiring, and he was as durable as they come. He led the league with 34 starts and took the ball on short rest multiple times, often helping the Rangers when they needed him most.
But durability only goes so far when the performance doesn’t match the price tag. Gore has long been the kind of arm who lives around a 4.00 ERA, and in 2026 he slid backward instead of taking the leap Texas needed. That’s why his placement at No. 17 on MLB Trade Rumors’ list of the offseason’s top 40 trade candidates lands like another reminder of the Rangers’ miss.
The deeper problem is what the trade was supposed to solve. Texas didn’t just want innings; it wanted a long-term answer. Gore had two seasons of team control left, and the ideal outcome was simple: he becomes a true ace in 2026, then gets extended this offseason as the rotation’s future face.
That never happened. Now deGrom and Eovaldi are both free agents after the 2027 season, both are getting up there in age, and both come with expensive commitments that may not fit beyond next year.
Gore was supposed to be the bridge - the younger starter who could carry the rotation into the next phase. Instead, he’s headed toward free agency next winter with more questions than certainty around him.
There’s also the possibility that Texas reopens the door on deGrom after the trade deadline rumors that swirled around him. He still has a full no-trade clause, but the winter could bring a different mood and a clearer sense of where the Rangers are headed. If he’s willing to waive it, the whole picture changes.
And if that happens, Gore becomes even more of a trade piece. A bigger reset would make him less useful to the Rangers’ timeline, especially since the club is unlikely to commit major money to extending him after such a rough season. That leaves one path: move him to a contender in need of starting pitching, probably one that can’t just go shopping at the top of the free-agent market.
It wouldn’t come close to matching what Texas gave up to get him. But if Gore is going to walk after 2027, the Rangers may decide getting something back is better than letting the value keep draining away.
That’s the real sting here. Gore was supposed to be the player who connected the present to the future without shutting the window on either. Instead, he’s become a distressed asset, and the Rangers are left staring at an underwater return on a huge swing that missed.
In Other News...
Rangers Just Made A Pitching Depth Move Fans Should Notice
The Rangers quietly added right-hander Aidan Curry to their 40-man roster, a move that says plenty about how they view the young pitchers place in the organization. Signed as an undrafted free agent in 2020, Curry has worked mostly as a starter in the minors and has built out a five-pitch mix, with a fastball that can get into the mid-90s.
For Texas, it is the kind of depth decision that can matter later, especially with a pitcher who has shown enough to merit roster protection and a possible path toward a promotion. The move also trims the clubs flexibility a bit, leaving the Rangers with 37 players on the 40-man roster as they continue sorting out their pitching inventory. [Read more 🡒]
Rangers Suddenly Have A Catching Decision They Cant Ignore
The Rangers offseason roster churn has already reached the catching picture, and it could shape how the club builds out its depth for next season. Texas declined the mutual options on designated hitter Joc Pederson, catcher Kyle Higashioka and reliever Jakob Junis, sending all three into free agency and leaving the team with a little more work to do behind the plate.
With the market now open, the Rangers are looking for additional catching help as they prepare for the upcoming season. The move also creates a clearer path for Logan O'Hoppe, acquired from the Los Angeles Angels, to enter the conversation for a backup role, giving Texas at least one internal option while it sorts through the rest of the position. [Read more 🡒]
Rangers Are Already Facing One Offseason Debate Fans Will Hate
The Rangers are heading into an offseason that already sounds more practical than flashy, with the expectation that they will shop mostly in the mid-tier market through signings and trades. One name that has surfaced in that lane is catcher Tyler Stephenson, whom Jim Bowden of The Athletic connected to Texas while weighing his offense, defense and fit against the clubs current catching picture.
Stephenson would give the Rangers another option behind the plate, but the broader debate is really about where the front office should spend its limited attention. Catching help is part of the conversation, yet the roster still has other areas that could demand more urgent work, and the way Texas balances those needs could shape how fans judge the winter before it really gets going. [Read more 🡒]