Jacob deGrom Just Put The Rangers In A Tough Offseason Spot

With Jacob deGrom's performance slipping, the Texas Rangers must weigh the risks and rewards of keeping their star pitcher or exploring trade options as a contract year looms.

Jacob deGrom’s name belongs in the same offseason conversation as Corey Seager, but the Rangers’ decision on the ace may be even more complicated.

Texas is staring at a familiar roster puzzle: trim payroll, add talent, and somehow avoid gutting the rotation in the process. deGrom sits at the center of that equation. He’s the club’s highest-paid player, and he’s in the final year of the five-year, $185 million contract he signed before the 2023 season. In 2027, he’ll make $37 million.

That number matters because moving him would bring real financial flexibility. It also would leave a massive hole on the mound. Nathan Eovaldi is the only starter on the roster with deGrom’s level of ability, so dealing the two-time Cy Young winner would shake up the rotation in a way a Seager move would not.

The Rangers, though, can’t ignore what happened last season.

deGrom debuted with the New York Mets in 2014 and built his reputation as one of baseball’s most overpowering arms when healthy. His 2018 National League Cy Young season was a classic example: a 10-9 record, but an MLB-best 1.70 ERA. From that year through 2025, he finished with an ERA of 3.00 or higher only once before, and that came in 2022, when injuries limited him to 11 starts and a 3.08 ERA.

His first full season with Texas in 2025 looked like a return to form. He posted a 2.97 ERA, went 12-8, made the American League All Star team and was named the AL comeback player of the year.

Then came 2026, and the numbers changed.

deGrom stayed on the mound for a second straight season with at least 30 starts, something he had not done in consecutive years since 2018 and 2019. He won double-digit games again and struck out 201 hitters, topping 200 strikeouts for the first time since his 2019 Cy Young season, when he piled up 255.

But he also turned in a stat line he had never produced before: a season ERA at 4.00 or higher. He finished at 4.20.

The decline showed up in the workload and the damage. He threw 10 fewer innings than he did in 2025 and allowed 19 more earned runs.

Statcast added another layer of concern, with his hard-hit percentage landing in the 4th percentile. Batters produced hard contact against him 45% of the time.

Even with strong chase, whiff and strikeout numbers, the contact he did allow was loud.

That showed up in the home run total, too. deGrom gave up 20 long balls, and he had never before had back-to-back seasons with 20 or more home runs allowed. He surrendered 26 in 2025. Before that, his career high was 2028 in 2017, when he posted a 3.53 ERA.

Now the Rangers have to decide whether 2026 was a blip or the start of a real slide for a 38-year-old ace. That question sits right alongside the trade market, especially after deGrom already blocked one possible deal in August and said he wanted to stay in Arlington and win.

Will he feel the same way this offseason? Will Texas push harder to move him? Or will the Rangers keep him for one more year and revisit the situation with free agency looming in 2028?

However they answer it, this is one of the biggest calls on the Rangers’ offseason board, and deGrom’s ERA is a major reason why.

In Other News...

Rangers Face A Costly Corey Seager Trade Reality

Chris Young is at least doing the math on a Corey Seager trade, and for the Rangers, the numbers are as important as the baseball. Seager still has five years left on his contract, which makes any potential move far more complicated than a simple roster shuffle. His no-trade clause adds another layer, and it means Texas would have to navigate both the players approval and the reality of a deal that is difficult to fit into another clubs payroll.

The part Young is weighing is how much salary the Rangers might need to absorb to make a trade workable, because that could determine whether they can turn one expensive star into multiple pieces. It is the kind of front-office decision that speaks to a larger effort to create payroll flexibility without giving away too much value in return, and it leaves the organization balancing financial relief against the cost of moving one of its most recognizable players. [Read more 🡒]

Rangers Face Two Roster Decisions That Could Signal Their Free Agency Plan

The Rangers are staring at a pair of roster deadlines this week that could offer a clearer read on how they plan to handle the winter. First comes Tuesdays Rule 5 protection deadline, when Texas has to decide which eligible players to add to its 40-man roster and which prospects it is willing to leave exposed. The club already has 37 players on the roster, so there is room to maneuver, but every spot matters as the organization weighs present depth against future upside.

Then comes Friday, when the Rangers must tender contracts to their pre-arbitration and arbitration-eligible players. That decision can be as revealing as any signing, because it forces teams to choose between keeping a player in the fold or moving on before the next season gets underway. With collective bargaining agreement talks still hanging over the sport, these moves may be among the earliest signs of how aggressively Texas intends to shape its free-agent approach. [Read more 🡒]

Rangers Free Agency May Be Heading In A Frustratingly Familiar Direction

The Rangers free-agent approach under Chris Young has already shown a clear evolution since 2020, moving away from the splashier pursuits that once defined the market and toward a more measured, cost-conscious style of roster building. That shift matters again as Texas looks ahead to the 2027 offseason, where the club is expected to shop with an eye on value and fit rather than chasing the biggest names available.

The early list of possible targets reflects those priorities. JoJo Romero, Daulton Varsho, Jonathan Loisiga and Adrian Morejon all line up with areas Texas could want to reinforce, especially in the bullpen and in the outfield, but each comes with a contract expectation that would test the Rangers spending limits. The challenge is familiar: finding enough help to keep the roster competitive without drifting back into the kind of aggressive spending that no longer seems to be the default. [Read more 🡒]