The speculation around Arch Manning has gotten loud enough that it’s starting to drown out almost everything else around Texas. His future at the school - and with coach Steve Sarkisian - has become the sport’s favorite debate topic this week, with national voices openly kicking around the idea that Manning could leave.
That chatter has only intensified because of Manning’s struggles, which have fueled questions about both his own path and Sarkisian’s ability to develop him. For Texas fans, the constant discussion can feel like a jolt every time they flip on ESPN. The frustration is easy to understand: Texas is the biggest brand in college football, the most-watched team in the sport, and yet the conversation keeps circling back to whether Manning will be somewhere else next year.
So what are the actual outcomes on the table? Manning has three. He can stay at Texas, transfer, or declare for the NFL Draft.
The pro route is the one that made sense before the season. If Manning put together a strong year, the assumption was that he’d head to the draft.
But halfway through the season, that kind of résumé is not there. He has not played like a player who should be taken No. 1 overall, or even like a first-round lock, even though quarterbacks tend to get pushed up draft boards.
There are still teams that would absolutely take him with the top pick if they had it, and the Cleveland Browns owner definitely has an affinity for Arch. But that is a lot of things needing to break the right way.
Manning might even prefer to stay in school rather than land in that spot.
Odds: 5%
The transfer buzz has become the louder storyline, and it’s gotten a boost from former ESPN analyst and former Georgia QB David Pollack. He said an "SEC coach" told him Manning will definitely transfer.
Pollack didn’t name the source, but because of his ties to Kirby Smart and his prediction that Manning would end up at Georgia, the connection is easy to draw. That has also led to the suggestion that Kirby may be planting a story to help push the narrative, which is a trick coaches are using more and more.
The complaint from that side is that Sarkisian’s offense hasn’t developed Manning the way people expected. That part is fair.
But it doesn’t automatically mean Manning is ready to bolt. He still appears to believe in Sarkisian.
Odds: 25%
The strongest case for Manning staying is rooted in the Mannings themselves. They’ve always come off as loyal, and the family history backs that up.
Eli could have gone to a powerhouse school, and Texas and Mack Brown recruited him hard. Instead, he stayed home at Ole Miss, the same school his dad played at, with David Cutcliffe as coach.
Cutcliffe wasn’t some perfect answer, but Eli wasn’t going there primarily for the coaching. The family has shown it will stick with its choice.
That matters here, because the Mannings don’t seem like a family that runs at the first sign of trouble. They chose Sarkisian to be Manning’s QB guru, which suggests they may know more about what’s happening behind the scenes with his development than everyone outside the program does.
Arch also loves Austin, which was a major part of why he chose Texas in the first place. His parents love the program too.
And there’s another layer: his younger brother Heid is now at Texas, and the two are very close. Heid is two years younger, and he’ll be without Arch at college soon either way.
It’s fair to wonder whether Arch would even ask him to transfer.
Odds: 70%
There’s still plenty of season left, and this could all shift again. The final five games will tell the story.
In Other News...
Texas Pass Rush Just Took Another Hit Before Mississippi State
Texas is heading into its meeting with Mississippi State with more questions on the edge than it would have liked. Colin Simmons, the Longhorns standout pass rusher, was downgraded to doubtful because of an ankle sprain, and Richard Wesley is already out, leaving the front seven thinner than usual at a spot where Texas normally likes to create disruption.
There is some relief on the other side of the availability report, with running back Hollywood Smothers and wide receiver Cam Coleman removed from the injury list and expected to play. Mississippi State, meanwhile, will be missing starting quarterback Kamario Taylor and wide receiver Ayden Williams, so the matchup still comes with some notable absences for both teams as kickoff approaches. [Read more 🡒]
Texas Must Avoid One Trap As Mississippi State Changes The Equation
Mississippi States quarterback situation has changed the shape of this matchup in a way Texas has to respect, even if the Longhorns still look like the more complete team on paper. With the Bulldogs dealing with that injury at the most important position, the focus shifts to how Texas handles the trenches, where the offensive line will be tested by Mississippi States front seven and the Longhorns need to stay steady enough to let the rest of the offense settle in.
There is also plenty for Texas to attack through the air if it protects the football and keeps the penalties in check, two areas that can turn a manageable road game into something messier than it should be. On defense, the Longhorns will need clean work from the linebackers in particular against Fluff Bothwell, because Mississippi State may look for ways to stay balanced and make Texas earn every stop while the game plan adjusts around its quarterback issue. [Read more 🡒]
Texas Playoff Push Now Hinges On An Unlikely Offensive Lifeline
Texas kept its College Football Playoff push alive with a 34-27 win over Ole Miss, but the bigger story inside that victory was how the offense held together after starting left tackle Trevor Goosby went down with a season-ending knee injury. The line had to adjust on the fly, and Andre Cojoe was the one who stepped in to help stabilize things, giving the Longhorns a fighting chance to keep their quarterback upright and the run game moving.
Raleek Browns 157 rushing yards gave Texas the kind of ground production it needed in a tight SEC-style game, while Michael Terry added 41 yards and a touchdown to keep the pressure on Ole Miss. Even with the win, the Longhorns now have to figure out how much of this offensive success can travel forward if Goosby is out for good and Cojoe remains the answer on the edge. [Read more 🡒]